Good morning, everyone. Erev Shabbat Kodesh (holy Shabbat eve), Rosh Chodesh (new month) Tov to everyone, and Chodesh Tov. It is Rosh Chodesh Iyar, and we have a double header, a two-day Rosh Chodesh. What better way to spend Rosh Chodesh, Erev Shabbat (Shabbat eve), than studying the holy Parashat HaShavua (weekly Torah portion)?
Today I want to share a beautiful idea from Rabbi Bernstein. Yes, he is back, he is back, and he is better than ever. My friends, I had the zechut (merit) to meet Rabbi Bernstein last summer for the first time in my life, after studying his Torah for four or five years. Then he gave me this beautiful book called Aggadah. I think it is his first book. He has beautiful endorsements from Rabbi Akiva Tatz, a barrel of wine, alav hashalom. He wrote me a nice little blessing on the front page. That was a nice treat.
Rabbi Bernstein has an essay in here. It is basically a bunch of essays. Some of them each connect to a teaching from our Midrash (rabbinic exposition), our Aggadot (aggadic teachings), our Rabbis, the Gemara, or elsewhere. I don't know how many: one, two, three, four, five; let's say 10, 15 essays. I don't know, 15, 20 essays on important topics in Judaism, like free will, tests, faith, and Lashon Hara (gossip).
Our parasha deals with Lashon Hara. Of course, we have spoken about it for many days already, and I am sure you will hear more about gossip and different ideas about gossip on Shabbat. I think gossip is something we all struggle with. No matter how religious you are, I know a lot of people who speak gossip. You want me to tell you their names? Fine.
We all struggle with gossip. There were two friends who met right before Yom Kippur and said, “Listen, I think we should confess our sins to each other. It will be a good way to atone for our sins, by confessing and being embarrassed about our sins to each other.” The friend said, “Okay, good idea. I'll go first. I cheat on my wife. I steal from people in business. I hurt old ladies. I don't know, whatever he said. How about you?” The friend said, “Me? I have a very bad habit of speaking Lashon Hara.” Either way, my friends, Lashon Hara is something we all struggle with.
Raise your hand if you don't struggle with Lashon Hara. Raise your hand if you are clean from gossip. Anyone here? Could anyone say that with certainty? Anyone here have no problem whatsoever? I think we all struggle, no matter how righteous or religious we are. Therefore, it is always a good day, my friends, to study Lashon Hara, to learn about Lashon Hara. Hopefully, Hashem should bless us. We pray every day, “Please, Hashem, guard my tongue from evil.” It is something we need help with, something we pray for.
A Pasuk (verse) says in Tehillim—this is brought down in a famous Midrash in Vayikra Rabbah—that there was once a peddler traveling through town, asking, “Who wants an elixir of life? Who wants an elixir of life?” Life for sale, 50 cents a hat. “Who wants life?” People started to gather around this peddler until Rabbi Yannai, who was there, took an interest. Finally, the peddler said, “You want life? You want life? Who wants life?” Everyone said, “We, we, we want life. What do you got? What vitamin, what multivitamin, do you have for life?”
The peddler said, “Here, right here.” They were all expecting vitamins or some potion, but he pulled a Tehillim out of his pocket. “Look right here.” He opened it to chapter 34 of Tehillim. David HaMelech says, “Who wants life? Who wants life?” David HaMelech says right there, in the few-thousand-year-old book: “You want life? Stop talking bad about people. You want to live? Stop talking bad about people.” It is a black-and-white Pasuk, my friends. Every person knows this Pasuk, especially a rabbi. I expect Rabbi Yannai knew this Pasuk.
And yet, says the Midrash, when Rabbi Yannai heard this peddler quote the Pasuk, he said, “I never realized the meaning of this verse until it was revealed to me by the peddler.” This, of course, needs understanding. What in the world did the peddler teach Rabbi Yannai? All he did was quote a Pasuk. Did Rabbi Yannai not know the Pasuk beforehand?
To understand the depth of this beautiful Midrash, my friends, let us delve a little into the understanding of gossip. David HaMelech is saying, “Guard your tongue from gossip and you will be given life.”
We know that one of the punishments for gossip is brought down in our parasha. Our parasha tells us that a man will be afflicted with tzara'at, which we translate as some form of leprosy, although we know it is not so simple. Leprosy is more of a physical ailment, while the tzara'at the Torah talks about is a spiritual ailment. It manifests itself in a physical way, with some discoloration on his skin. Ultimately, this man who has tzara'at, who has leprosy, has to go outside the camp.
Why is he going outside the camp? He is going into quarantine. Why is he going into quarantine? You may say, “We don't want other people to catch this tzara'at.” But remember, my friends, this is not something contagious. No one can catch it because it is not a physical disease. You could catch a physical disease, but you can't catch a spiritual disease. So why are we quarantining him?
Rashi, right away, on this pasuk, says it is a punishment, measure for measure. This man separated friend from friend. This man, with his gossip, separated husband from wife. With his words, he caused people to start fighting by spreading lies, by revealing things that should not be revealed, true or false. This man, therefore, caused people to be isolated. And therefore, the Torah says that his punishment is that he must be isolated. You want to cause friends to break up? You want to cause people to lose their job? You want to cause shidduchim (matches) to break? You want to cause matches to crumble? Let's see what it feels like to be alone, to have no friends, no associates, and not be part of a community.
This man is afflicted with leprosy and punished with isolation. But, as we quoted yesterday, Onkelos says that he is not only isolated; he is actually called, in Onkelos's translation, Makkat Segiru. Onkelos says that he is Sagur. Metzora doesn't just get closed off. Onkelos says Metzora means closed off. The definition of tzara'at—we again translate it as leprosy, but Onkelos says that is wrong—is closed off. What in the world does that mean, that he is closed off? That is the punishment; that is not who he is. But, says Rabbi Bernstein, maybe he actually is a closed-off person.
You see, we think about gossip and speak ill about other people, and there is definitely something enticing about it. But what is the appeal? Why do we talk gossip? Why do we speak about other people? Why do we speak about other people? The Gemara says that the Second Temple was destroyed because of Sinat Chinam (baseless hatred). The Chafetz Chaim explains that Sinat Chinam doesn't just mean baseless hatred; it means specifically gossip. Gossip is a result of baseless hatred.
When a person speaks gossip too much, the key to gossip—the antidote, remedy, the cure to gossip—is not watching how you talk. The cure to gossip is like this: If a person has a black and blue, the gossip is only the black and blue. The gossip could tell you what is going on in the person. There is something much deeper in the person, worse than the gossip. Gossip is the result, says the Chafetz Chaim, of baseless hatred. His hatred leads to gossip.
What does baseless hatred mean? Why do we hate people? Who hates people for nothing? Does that make any sense, that I hate someone for nothing? That there is no reason? Our Rabbis explain that it doesn't mean for no reason; it means for no good reason. In the eye of a hater, when I hate you, in my eyes it is well-founded. I can explain why I hate you. But our Rabbis say that in truth, there is no foundation. There is no basis.
To give you an example, if someone is trying to take something that belongs to me, then I fear them. Then I have ill feelings toward them. That makes sense. If you are trying to steal my watch, my house, my car, then I don't like you. Does that make sense? Yes, that makes sense. I don't like you. You are trying to take something that is mine, so I have certain hesitations toward you. That makes sense.
But what if someone is trying to take something that I think is mine? It doesn't really belong to me, but I think it is mine, and he is trying to take what I think is mine. But really, he is not. It is not really mine. So I think my hatred toward him is justified. But in reality, in reality, it is based on a mistake.
Every person has a sense of self. We all have an ani, an I. An I, a circle of me, where we are the ego. Ego. We all have ego, and ego is important. But what happens when ego is left unchecked, and a person's ego becomes a super ego? What happens when a person becomes arrogant to the point where they see themselves as the center, as the focus of the universe? Everyone should be focused on me. Everyone should be talking about me. If anyone is going to get kavod (honor), it should be me. If Hashem is going to bless anyone on planet Earth, it should be me.
You know, we see someone get bracha (blessing), and we get jealous. “God, why them? Why did they get married? Why did they get a kid? Why did they get better? It should have been me. Why not me?” Think about that question the person poses to God: “It should be me.” Why? Why should it be you? “Well, because if God is going to give a blessing to anyone, obviously it is me. If anyone—who would you, the king, want to honor more than me? Obviously, it would be me first.” Who spoke like that, by the way? Who used literally those words? “Who would the king want to honor more than me?” That is how Haman thought. Haman lived in this world where he was the center. Any attention, honor, or blessing should obviously be directed first and foremost to him.
Anyone who is getting attention or honor is threatening to take something from me. It is obviously supposed to come to me. If you are getting praised, it doesn't matter if it is your birthday party or your wedding: “No, it's me. I'm at the center.” So I have to make sure people stop giving you undeserved attention. At the root of Lashon Hara is a person's mistaken view of the world, where he is the center of it and everything should be coming to him. Anyone who takes is really taking at my expense. So I hate you. I hate you for it. How dare you take my... It's me.
This is why we speak badly about people. Why do we talk badly about people? Because now it is my responsibility to show people the truth about you: that you are not deserving of the honor you got, that you went to the center of attention. People should not be praising you and showering you with goodness. It shouldn't be you. It should be me. If you are coming too close to the center, then I have to rightfully place you back where you belong in this way.
The gossiper really lives in a world that almost doesn't exist. His view of the world is not reality. He is delusional. He is hallucinating. He lives in a world where he is the center. Everything revolves around him. But it is not the real world. The real world revolves around the sun, not you. You live in La La Land. That is his view of the world. He doesn't live in the same world as everybody else.
When you live in this world, you see someone whispering in shul (synagogue). “What are they saying about me? Obviously, it's about me. Who else would they be whispering about? I am the reason people whisper. What more important things on planet Earth are there to whisper about than me? I am the only thing that really matters. I'm the most important person.” Think about that. Why would they be talking?
Or someone may be in a bad mood. “What did I do to them, that they're in such a bad mood? I must have done something to them. It has to be that their bad mood is because of me.” Why else would anyone be in a bad mood? Why else would anyone be in a bad mood? Why else would anyone be in a bad mood? Why else would anyone be in a bad mood? There can't be any other reason on planet Earth. “No, no, no. Obviously their bad mood is because of me. I am the center.” Realize how ridiculous that is.
There could be a thousand things going on in people's minds. A person could have ignored your phone call for a thousand reasons. 999 have nothing to do with you. Odds are it has nothing to do with you. Maybe there are health issues going on. Maybe there are personal issues. Maybe they have relationship issues. They have a thousand things going on in their life. “No, no, no. What did I say? Well, let me think. What's the reason they're upset at me?” Who said they're upset at you?
This all comes from arrogance: “I'm the center. People are talking; it must be about me. People are angry; it must be because of me.” Whatever my interests are, obviously everyone will be interested in them. The guy doesn't realize: he is there, talking about something, and no one gives a darn, man. Nobody cares. Get off your high horse. Stop talking. No one cares about that. Can't you see people are just so bored of you and that topic? “No, but me and me. Me. I'm me.” Everything in this guy's life is filtered through his egocentric world.
He brings over here a beautiful joke, a story. A village had only one Kohen (priest). So, obviously, if there is only one Kohen, he is going to be called up every time to the Sefer Torah. Every now and then, a visitor would come to town who was also a Kohen. On those occasions, the visitor would be given the first Aliyah (Torah reading) as the Kohen. After witnessing this a few times, the resident Kohen approached the Gabai (synagogue attendant) of the shul and said, “Okay, I see what's going on here. You only give me the first blessing when you have no other choice.” I see what's going on here. What a sad skewing of reality, when you reframe something in such a negative way.
A Metzora, my friends, is a Makkat Segiru. The Metzora, the leper, is closed off. He is closed off literally. He doesn't live in the world we live in. He doesn't live in reality. Our Rabbis call a Metzora a dead man walking. He is literally a Metzora, Chashuv K'met. What does it mean that he is Chashuv K'met? He lives in his own world. He doesn't live in this world. He is like a dead person. He doesn't live in the world we live in. He is not here. He is gone. Halakhically, his status is like a dead person. If he is in a room, anyone in that room becomes Tamei (ritually impure).
Of course, our Rabbis said it best in Pirkei Avot: “Jealousy, desire, and ego. Honor. They remove a person from the world.” They not only can kill people physically—yes, people die because of these things. How many people die because of addiction? But they actually remove a person from the world. They are not living in the world the way we see it, the way we have it, the reality. They live in their own made-up, fake version, a figment of their imagination. They are not living in this world.
It is very interesting to go back to the first story, the first story of man. God created Adam and placed him in a world, Gan Eden (Garden of Eden), a paradise. Gan Eden was beautiful. Adam was eating and enjoying himself. God says, “This world is yours. Eat everything, every tree, except for one. There's one tree that's off limits, Adam.” And what does Adam do? Adam says, “That's the one tree I need to eat.” For Adam, this was what needed to happen. This was where he needed to go. This was what he needed to enjoy.
Interestingly, God comes and says, “Adam, what's the first thing that God says to him?” Ayeka. What does Ayeka mean? Ayeka means, “Where'd you go?” Literally, right? “Where'd you go?” Meaning, what God said is, “Where are you? What world are you in?” You're not in my world. My world is a beautiful world. My world is a world with rules, with respect for other people and other people's space, where you can't just do whatever you want. You can't just touch and eat and do whatever you want. It is a world with boundaries. That's a beautiful world. God says, “I created a beautiful world, but I don't see you in it. You made up this own world of yours.”
You know, we look at the world today and cry, “Wow, what a messed-up world.” But guess what? That's not God's world. God didn't create that world. Man created that world. We look at a world with death and hate and fighting and violence. That's not God's world. God says to Adam, “I put you in a beautiful world, and if you just followed my rules, it would be perfect. But you decided to leave that world. You went into another world. I don't know which world. You went into another world where you get to decide the rules, where you get to eat whatever you want, where that tree was the one you needed to have. It's not my world. You ate your own world, Adam. Ayeka, where'd you go?”
And so what does God do to Adam? He expels him. In reality, Adam had already left. God didn't need to kick him out. Adam left voluntarily the second he decided to make up his own rules. Even the original exile, my friends, began with a person realizing that they needed to do their own thing, follow their own set of rules.
The Metzora lives in his own world. He takes up his own rules. He's the center of that world. Interestingly, the book of Eicha, the book in which we mourn our exile as a nation, begins with that word as well: Ayeka. Eicha. It's called the Book of Eicha. And what does it say? It says, “Eicha, how could it be that the city that's filled with people is all alone?” On a very simple level, it means: How could you have a city filled with people that was once a metropolis and is now desolate? However, as Azariah Figo explains, no. It's not talking about a city that was once filled and is now empty. It's talking about how a city at the same time could sometimes be filled with people and, at the very same time, be empty.
You can have a city filled with people, a house filled with people, a room, a house, a family filled with people, and each one is living their own life in their own world, in their own La La Land. And they are alone. You could feel a thousand people in a room and still feel alone. You could be alone when you are delusional, when you are creating a fake sense of reality.
So this, my friends, is where Lashon Hara comes from. And it is something very sad. Not only is he cut off from life, but his life is also filled with misery, pain, and sadness. When you are always speaking Lashon Hara about people, you never know if you will be the next victim of their Lashon Hara about you. Maybe you're next. You're constantly suspicious of the relationships you are in, and happiness is really nowhere to be found.
So Rabbi Yannai hears this peddler. What does the peddler say? The peddler says, “Who wants life?” What is he talking about? He is talking about life in this world. You see, Rabbi Yannai always understood the Pasuk in Tehillim as talking about life in the next world. But the peddler comes along and says, “Who wants life in this world?” Everyone is interested: “Yes, I want the elixir of life.” The peddler says, “Well, if you want life in this world, be careful of how you speak. Watch your tongue.” Watching your tongue will give you life not only in the next world, but in this world too.
When you watch your tongue, when we cure our ego, our arrogance, all of a sudden we live, we come back to reality. We come back to reality. We come back to a world the way God intended: a world where people aren't whispering about me. No one is really talking about me. People aren't upset because of me. Not everything bad that happens is necessarily revolving around me. I'm not nervous, suspicious, paranoid, or anxious that maybe everyone's trying to get me. No one's out to get you. Stop it. Stop thinking the world revolves around you, that everyone's trying to get you. The world didn't wake up today saying, “How can I screw this person's life?” Everyone is thinking about their own life. Everyone is worried about themselves.
When we live in that world, we come back to reality. That's a beautiful world to live in. We could be calm. We could breathe. We could exhale. We could enjoy the life God created. We could enjoy paradise, this world, the Garden of Eden. But it starts by stopping the gossip. It starts by realizing that we're not the focus. We're not the center. And when we do, we'll be able to merit a beautiful life.
This is definitely, I think, a beautiful way to enter a new month, my friends, as we grow toward Shavuot, toward receiving the Torah. Ultimately, the gossiper at the end of his term has to bring a cedar tree. I think it ties in beautifully. A cedar is the tallest tree, very strong. This guy, in his own eyes, sees himself as the cedar. He sees himself as the center. And the Torah says, “Take it easy. You're not the center. People are not out to get you. People are not talking about you. And when people get blessing, it doesn't come at your expense. You don't have to live this miserable life of yours. Stop. You don't have to be miserable. You can have a beautiful life.”
Hashem should bless us to be able to create space in that world where we have an ego, but that ego is in check. Ultimately, we remember that we are part of a world that can be beautiful, with people around us who care about us. Amen.

