A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H

Torah Lecture

Seeing The Entire Picture Megillah Moshe and Rabbi Frank

Lectured by Rabbi David Bibi

Published
March 1, 2023
Duration
11:30
Lecture code
DB-TES01

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

There’s a halakha (Jewish law) that tells us that when we read the Megillah, we’re not allowed to read it out of order. We have to read it in the order it comes in. And the question is: why? Why are we not allowed to read it out of order? Because when you go through the Megillah, you really can’t understand what’s flying. You’re looking at different things. You think that they’re not good, right? You see Mordechai doesn’t want to bow down to Haman, or Mordechai hears what the guys are saying. Esther is taken into the palace. The edict is passed. All of these terrible things happen, and you don’t see how everything is part of the whole story until you come to the very end. One of the things the rabbis tell us is that you always have to look at life and realize that it’s very hard to judge life when you’re inside the picture. Until you can stand back and see the whole picture, you rarely understand. And in life, we rarely understand. But sometimes we get a glimpse, and it gives us a little glimpse to show us that there’s someone putting everything together.

Today’s the yahrzeit (anniversary of death) of Moshe Rabbeinu. Even in Moshe’s life, you could think, “How could I understand?” Moshe is born, and he goes to live with the Egyptians. Even with the Egyptians, he grabs the fire and burns his tongue. How is this guy going to be anything in his life? And then you see he goes, works for the Egyptians, and becomes a general in the Egyptian army. Then he comes back, and what does he do? He kills an Egyptian, and then they want to kill him. He runs away, and you think it’s all over. And then he comes back, and then he comes back, and he comes to Paro, and then things get worse. And then he has to come back again, and then everything starts. So we don’t understand life when we look at individual things.

I just want to share with you a crazy story I heard. The Arabs, yimach shemam (may their names be erased)—my son had a friend, and his friend was killed yesterday. He was one of the guys who, unfortunately, was shot. This Ilan Ganeles was a friend of my son. You see the terrible tragedy when we lose people. I heard a story on Friday that was recorded by Rabbi Yaakov Frank. Rabbi Yaakov Frank is a rabbi. He’s 95 years old. His grandfather was Rav Tzvi Pesach Frank. This rabbi was born in 1929, on the 17th of August in 1929. His grandfather, who would be the chief rabbi of Israel from 1930 until his passing, was supposed to go to Hebron in 1929 for a wedding celebration. His niece lived in Hebron, and they were going to have a wedding celebration. He was supposed to go on Shabbat, which would have been the 18th of Av. But his grandson was born on the Shabbat prior, and he had to cancel his visit because of the baby who was born. So he wasn’t in Hebron on the 18th. That was the day the Arabs, yimach shemam, went and literally killed the Jews in Hebron with knives and axes. He would have been in the house of Eliezer Dan Slonim, who thought his house was protected. He had an Arab business partner who was in the house with him when they came to attack. He opened the door for them and said, “Don’t worry, they won’t do anything.” They ended up killing 25 people in that house.

He says that when his brit milah (covenant of circumcision) happened, even in Yerushalayim, they were shooting. And his grandfather couldn’t come. His father went with his uncle. They ended up going to the hospital where the brit milah was going to take place. There, they couldn’t get a minyan (quorum of ten). Then Rav Aryeh Levine came. What did he do? He went outside into the shooting to get 10 guys and bring them in for the brit milah.

He tells a story that he told when he went to see the Lubavitcher Rebbe. He says there was a young man from America who was in the yeshiva in Hebron, and his parents wanted him to come home. So they wrote a letter to the Rosh Yeshiva in Hebron. They said, “You know, we’re nervous. The situation in Israel—we want our son to come home.” The rabbi, who was the head of the yeshiva, went to Rav Tzvi Pesach Frank, who was the chief rabbi, and said, “Could you do me a favor? Write a letter to the parents and tell them it’s safe in Hebron.” So the rabbi wrote a letter to the parents. In the letter, he said he would personally look out for the welfare of this boy. “Don’t worry, everything is fine in Hebron.” And what happened? Obviously, it wasn’t fine, and this boy was killed. The rabbi said that, for the rest of his life, when other people in Hebron were killed, he thought about the fact that he had assured the parents he would be responsible for this boy.

Fast-forward to 1960. His grandson, Rav Yaakov Frank, was on his miluim, his army, his reserves, reserve duty. It was pouring rain while they were on reserve duty. They were digging ditches or something, and he said it was just the worst kind of thing. The rain didn’t stop. They were flooded, and they were out all night. It was finally 3 o’clock in the morning, and they didn’t know what to do. The commander said, “Look for shelter.” He saw the guy next to him, and they started a conversation. The man asked, “What’s your name?” “My name is Yaakov Frank,” he replied. The man said, “Oh, you’re related to Rabbi Tzvi Pesach Frank. You know, everyone’s going to tell you—he’s the chief rabbi.” He said, “Yeah, he’s my grandfather.” Then they started to talk about the massacre. This guy turned out to be a historian, a historian of the yishuv, of Israel before 1948. Yaakov said, “My grandfather was so upset that he told this boy to stay.” The man said, “Let me tell you the rest of the story.”

The man explained that when this boy died, his parents were very, very important people in America. They were very wealthy and very politically connected. They blamed the British for their kid dying, because the reality was that the Arabs had knives and axes, and the British had guns. The British just stood there. They just stood around. At some point in the afternoon, the British decided to get involved. They fired a couple of shots, and the Arabs went running. So if the British had stopped them in the morning and fired a couple of shots, the Arabs would have gone running. This guy made such a stink day after day, pressing the American government and the press, that the British government was so embarrassed about the situation that they fired the guy who was in charge of Israel and appointed a new guy. This new guy’s name was Gen. Arthur Wauchope. He was appointed in 1931 and stayed through 1937. He started to tour the land, and he had a love for the Jewish people. He issued 200,000 entry permits into the country during that period. That’s six years that he was there. He said, “You don’t realize what that meant. The British weren’t letting anyone in.” He basically changed the whole thing to let people in. They said hundreds of thousands of people. Hundreds of thousands of people from the Holocaust were saved because of him, and others came.

If you look at Israel’s population in 1930 compared to 1948, he said it was 150,000. In 1948, it was 600,000. In the War of Independence, we lost 6,000 people, which was 1% of the population. He said, “Just imagine for a second: if this guy, Arthur Wauchope, wasn’t around, you would have had a yishuv of 150,000, 200,000 people. You would have had no chance in the war in 1948. You don’t realize something. When your grandfather told this boy to stay and Hashem killed him, it was a terrible thing. But because this boy died, his parents pressed, and this guy, Arthur Wauchope, changed. You have to realize that this boy could have been responsible for the victory in 1948, for the fact that there’s a state of Israel today. All of this was based on this boy.”

So he said he heard this story and had to go tell his grandfather. The commander said, “Okay, you guys can go home. It’s raining. We’re skipping. It’s Thursday night. Just go home.” He went home and told his wife his story. He said, “I have to go tell my grandfather.” She said, “But it’s Thursday night. Where are you going to go? We’re going to Jerusalem anyway. You go every Shabbat. You see your grandfather every Shabbat. Just wait for Shabbat.” He said, “No, I have to go tell my grandfather the story.” She said, “Okay, go. But you’re exhausted. You’re soaking.” She said, “You did.” He said, “I’m going.” He went to his grandfather. It was late at night. His grandfather said, “What’s the matter?” He said, “I have to tell you a story.” His grandfather said, “Couldn’t you wait for Shabbat?” He said, “No, I have to tell you.” His grandfather said, “Okay, sit down. Have a cup of tea. Tell me the story.” He told his grandfather the story this guy had told him, about Arthur Wauchope and what happened because of this boy who died. His grandfather said, “I can’t tell you how appreciative I am that you came to tell me the story. You couldn’t wait for Shabbat. You took such a weight off of me that I can’t describe what it means to me.”

He went back home. Shabbat morning, he was walking to his grandfather’s, an hour and a half walk. On the way, he passed his brother-in-law’s house. His brother-in-law said, “Don’t bother going to Saba (grandfather).” He said, “Why?” His brother-in-law said, “Saba passed away at eight o’clock this morning.” He said, “It’s unbelievable.”

Years later, he became a guy who was developing the territories. When Menachem Begin got elected in 77, he was trying to raise money for the territories. He was behind Ariel. He was behind the Hebron yishuv. He did a lot of things. He came to America, and Menachem Begin said, “Go see the Lubavitcher Rebbe.” The Lubavitcher Rebbe said, “You know, who are you? Oh, you’re related to the rabbi?” He said, “Yes.” The Rebbe said, “Tell me a story. Tell me a story. Tell me a story.” It was two o’clock in the morning. They told him, “You can only be with the rabbi for 15 minutes.” He ended up staying with the rabbi till 3.30. In the end, he told him this story. The rabbi said, “I always tell my people: when you have an opportunity to do a mitzvah (commandment), do it right away, because you never know if you’re going to have that opportunity again. Let me tell you one thing that you don’t think about. Could you just imagine? Imagine if that Thursday night you didn’t go see your grandfather, and he passed away Shabbat morning on your way to go see him and tell him the story. What guilt you would have felt for the rest of your life, and how much it would have eaten away at you.”

He says we always have to be zariz. We always have to rush to do a mitzvah. We have to realize in life that we don’t understand the picture. This poor rabbi sat all these years with this guilt. He said he felt terrible. It was still his fault the kid died. But at the same time, as a result of an action, look at what happened. Look at what’s possible. Look at what could be. We don’t understand the story. We’re a little dot in the painting. We’re trying to see the picture from the painting. It’s impossible to see. Sometimes we have to hear a story like this to realize that the other crazy things that may happen in our lives, and we don’t understand why they’re happening, are part of a big plan. We’re a cog in the plan. But what do we have to do? We have to do what we’re supposed to do. We have the opportunity to do something. Don’t wait till tomorrow. Don’t wait six months. Take the opportunity and do it now, because you don’t know what a difference your action will make in the world. We have ten?