A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Sutton

Daily Bitachon

The Month of Elul 34- Overcoming Zarut, Estrangement

Lectured by Rabbi David Sutton

Published
August 11, 2026
Duration
10:13

We continue our introduction to Elul, which begins this Thursday. We have spoken about how the opening theme of Elul is אני לדודי ודודי לי ("I am to my beloved, and my beloved is to me"). We are here to correct the mistake of Tisha B'Av—when we said that God hates us—and therefore we must reignite our understanding of ידידות (yedidut), belovedness, as we quoted from Rav Wolbe.

Rav Wolbe continues on the topic of זרות (zarut), estrangement. A זר is a stranger; estrangement means becoming strange to others. And he says something fascinating. How do you say "cruel" in Hebrew? אכזר (achzar). Rav Wolbe explains that the word אכזר is a contraction of two words: אך זר—"only a stranger."

What does it mean to be cruel? It means you do not see the other person. As someone once put it: when a lion attacks a sheep, it does not see a sheep—it sees a piece of meat. The lion does not think about the sheep's spouse, siblings, or children; it is just a piece of meat. And there are people like that—people who totally lack empathy. They do not see the other person; they are entirely estranged from everyone else. We will not enter into psychological diagnoses here, but this is a core issue in many faulty relationships and breakdowns. And this אכזריות (cruelty), as we said, can show up in many different forms.

Rav Wolbe goes on to quote the Rambam in Hilchot Ta'anit, which discusses a ציבור (community) in trouble, facing a challenge. The Rambam writes that if they do not cry out and pray, but instead say, "This is happenstance; this is coincidence," that is called דרך אכזריות—the way of cruelty. But what kind of cruelty is there here? They are simply not praying—where is the cruelty? Rav Wolbe explains: the cruelty is that they are totally estranged. When a person goes through a challenge and does not understand that it is connected to God, he is completely estranged from God. There is a disconnect; he does not realize there is a relationship at work. If someone is sitting in a room and a shoe is thrown at him, and he regards it as merely a UFO—an unidentified flying object—he is totally disconnected from the relationship behind it.

Rav Wolbe then explains how it is possible for a person to learn Torah and perform גמילות חסדים, and yet fall into trouble. Not only an individual—the Jewish people at large. The Gemara in Yoma 9b says that in the time of the בית שני (Second Temple), they learned Torah and performed chesed—which sounds quite good—and yet there was שנאת חינם, baseless hatred. This is always difficult to understand. They are doing kindness, and there is baseless hatred? They are learning Torah, and there is baseless hatred? What is going on?

He brings the Gemara in Yoma 72b, which notes that the word זר shares its letters with זֵר—a crown. The Torah can be a crown—as we know, there is a כתר תורה (crown of Torah)—if one merits it. But if one does not merit, the very Torah one learns can become a source of estrangement. Even with the Torah they are learning, there can be a disconnect. We know the pasuk: וידעת היום ("Know this day")—know it in your head—והשבות אל לבבך ("and return it to your heart"). There can be a disconnect between head and heart. A person can have a great deal of Torah, and yet it remains strange to him. It is a stranger—in his head, but a stranger to his heart.

Esav was brilliant. Esav asked his father questions that were very deep. But the Torah says of him: ציד בפיו ("hunting in his mouth")—it was all external. We know that Esav's head rolled into מערת המכפלה (the Cave of Machpelah). His head was great, but there was literally a disconnect between his head and his body—so much so that it rolled to the ground. The ideas never traveled from his head into his heart. That is a type of zarut: all the ideas you carry are actually strangers to you.

I have told in the past a story that Rav Wolbe would relate about a young man who took a walk in Be'er Yaakov. Rav Wolbe used to encourage people to take walks alone. Take a walk—why? Spend some time with yourself. Think, contemplate, get to know yourself. The boy went out on a short walk, and after ten or fifteen minutes he came back. Rav Wolbe asked, "Why such a short walk? Half an hour is a nice walk. What happened?" The boy answered, "I got scared."

Now, Be'er Yaakov in those days was one long street. It had a Yeshiva, a small marketplace that really did not sell anything, a girls' seminary further down, Yeshivat Rabbi Toledano, and a little further still, a mental hospital. That was the whole place. And he got scared.

Rav Wolbe said to him, "Do you know why you got scared? Because you met a stranger." "Met a stranger? I didn't meet a stranger." "Yes, you did." "No, I didn't." Until Rav Wolbe said: "You met yourself. There is a stranger inside of you whom you never knew. He is a stranger to you. You are so busy in the dormitory talking to people, always surrounded by people, that you never had a chance to get to know you."

And that applies to all of us. Whether we are taking a walk with earbuds in, or talking on the phone—we never give ourselves the opportunity to experience ourselves. We listen to music. All of it, really, serves to deny us the opportunity to hear ourselves. Wherever we are, we are doing something—and all that doing is a way to disconnect from ourselves.

There is a famous story about Rabbi Twerski, who once went away, after a grueling schedule, to some vacation spot. He was placed in some kind of hot bath as part of a regimen that required staying for twenty minutes. He said that after five or ten minutes, he simply could not remain there any longer. He was so uncomfortable being alone with himself that he could not stay.

That is why some people work and work and work—workaholics. It is a way to numb the pain of who you are. We have alcoholics, we have gamblers, and we also have workaholics—people addicted to work. Anyone addicted to something is really seeking to numb a pain. And the pain, at root, is that it is difficult to know yourself.

That is why we encourage, during the month of Elul: take a walk, be alone, do cheshbon hanefesh, get to know yourself—get to know what is going on inside of you. This is not psychological jargon. This is what we call התבודדות (hitbodedut), being alone with yourself. One does not have to go to a forest and play the guitar. The pasuk describes the Kohen Gadol's garment: כתונת בד...קודש—bad usually means a linen cloak, linen that must be holy. But the Rabbis read it homiletically: בד—if you are alone—קדוש—you become holy. In solitude, you have the opportunity to get to know yourself.

Rav Wolbe goes on to address what we can work on practically. Of course there are disconnects within ourselves and disconnects with God. But he says: work on your human relationships. That is what שנאת חינם is—the indicator cited regarding the destruction of the Beit HaMikdash. And he says something fascinating: we must break down the barriers between man and his friend, and between community and community—he uses the term עדה לעדה. "You know what? I don't get along with Chassidim. I don't like Hungarians. I don't like Moroccans. I don't like Persians. I don't like people from Lakewood. I don't like people from Teaneck." All of that is a disconnect—a failure to be part of the Jewish people at large. He notes that a person who speaks lashon hara about a group of people, about an entire community, is speaking lashon hara without limit. This is not merely sinat chinam against an individual; it is sinat chinam against an entire shevet of Klal Yisrael.

We all know the letter of the Alter of Kelm that was hung in the Beit Midrash: during the month of Elul, we must work on getting along—because if an army has dissension in its ranks and the soldiers are not getting along, the war is over; you have lost the war. ויהי בישורון מלך ("And He was King in Yeshurun")—when is God King? בהתאסף ראשי עם ("when the heads of the people gather together")—when we are all together.

This, then, is one of the tasks of the month of Elul: to truly understand the importance of not being strangers. Not strangers to God—we have a relationship with God. Not strangers to others—we have a relationship with others. And not strangers to ourselves—we must have a relationship with ourselves. That is אני לדודי ודודי לי: my Beloved One—and many beloved ones. Be'ezrat Hashem.