Tisha B'Av, Rosh Hashanah, and the Power of Remembering
According to the Zohar, one of the central themes of Tisha
B'Av is forgetting God. Where do we see this?
It says that when Yaakov Avinu had his wrestling match with
Esav's angel, it took place on Tisha B'Av—the time when Esav was granted the
power to impact Yaakov and bring about the Galut (exile). As we know,
Esav's angel displaced Yaakov's sciatic nerve, the Gid Hanasheh. That is
the simple explanation.
The Deeper Meaning of Gid Hanasheh
The Zohar expands on this by asking: what does Nasheh
actually mean? Simply put, nasheh means to be dislocated, as the root nash
means "to move." However, the Zohar points out , nasha means
to forget, making the Gid Hanasheh the sinew of forgetting. Its
spiritual essence causes a person to forget God. We see the word נשה meaning to forget when Yosef said, "Ki nashani"—"For
God has caused me to forget."
As we know, the human body has 365 sinews, which correspond
to the 365 solar days of the year and the 365 negative commandments (mitzvot
lo ta'aseh). Each day has a matching component in man, in time, and in the
Torah:
- In
man: The
physical Gid Hanasheh.
- In
mitzvot: The
prohibition against eating the Gid Hanasheh.
- In
time: The fast
of Tisha B'Av.
Furthermore, the words "Et Gid" (
) contain a hidden hint to all the dark fast days of the Churban
(destruction):
- Et
(
): Refers to Tisha Av (
).
- Gimmel
(
): The 3rd day of Tishrei—Tzom Gedalia.
- Yud
(
): The 10th of Tevet—Asara B'Tevet.
- Dalet
(
): The fast of the 4th month (Tammuz)—Shiva Asar
B'Tammuz (Tzom Harevii).
Another connection between Yaakov and the Churban on
Tisha B'Av is the custom to place a stone under one's pillow on Tisha B'Av
night. This stems from Yaakov Avinu placing stones around his head when he
slept. Some teachings suggest that Yaakov's dream also occurred on Tisha B'Av;
that is why he saw the spiritual guardians of the nations ascending and
descending, and why he became terrified when he saw Edom (Esav) ascending
without coming down.
Regardless, we see that the primary force of Tisha B'Av is
the force of forgetting.
Rosh Hashanah: The Remedy of Zikaron
The way we fight back against this spiritual forgetfulness is
through Rosh Hashanah. Rosh Hashanah is Yom Hazikaron—the Day of
Remembrance.
Simply speaking, we often explain this as the day when God
remembers us, which is true. However, Rav Moshe Feinstein offers a deeper
insight: "remembrance" in this context means God remembering our
memory of Him.
The secret to our success on Rosh Hashanah is our active
remembrance of God. The more we keep God in our thoughts, the more He remembers
us—as we say in the Retzei Vhachaletzanu addition to Birkat HaMAzo
on Shabbat: if we do not
forget the Beit Hamikdash, God will not forget us. Our act of not
forgetting Him and His act of not forgetting us are intrinsically linked.
Of course, God never literally forgets us. When it appears He
has forgotten, it is merely hester panim (the hiding of His Face). In
truth, God is always watching us—metzitz min hacharakim (peeking through
the lattices).
In the haftarah of Parshat Shoftim, the Jewish people
claim, "God has forgotten me and forsaken me." God responds:
"Can a mother forget her nursing child?"
Hashem adds that even if a human mother could somehow forget
her child, "I will never forget you."
What Does It Mean to Forget?
"Forgetting" in a spiritual sense does not mean
complete amnesia—like forgetting a computer password. It means that something
is no longer at the forefront of your mind.
If someone asks you today, "Did you think about your
eighth-grade rebbi today?" You would say, "No." Did
you forget who he is? No, but he was "forgotten" in the sense that he
was not on your mind. Similarly, when the prophet asks if a mother could forget
her child, it doesn't mean she forgot his name; it means she became distracted
and left him behind. He wasn't on her mind at that moment.
Conversely, Zikaron (remembrance) means
actively bringing something to mind and setting it into action.
The word Zachar (male/remember) is connected to
action—males represent active givers, whereas females represent recipients.
Therefore, to "remember" God means to actively keep Him on the front
burner of our minds. When we do this, we, so to speak, put ourselves at the
forefront of His mind in an active, dynamic way.
Standing Before the "Spiritual MRI"
The Zichronos—the section of Mussaf where we declare
that God remembers all actions—is the most critical part of our Rosh Hashanah
prayers.
- Malchuyot: Acknowledges Hashem's
sovereignty—a fundamental pillar of emunah (faith) as we crown Him
King.
- Shofrot: Recalls the revelation at Har
Sinai.
- Zichronos: The part most personal to us,
as we read how God reviews every individual's life—who will live, who will
die, which countries will experience war or peace.
When you internalize that God is examining your every deed,
thought, and mission, it is terrifying. Rav Wolbe compares Zichronos to
passing through an MRI machine. It doesn't scan for physical ailments, but for
spiritual ones.
What will the test results be? Usually, when you take a
medical test, you get the results in a few days. But the results of this
spiritual MRI do not come immediately. You only find out the results as the
year unfolds:
- Will
you buy that new house?
- What
will happen with your health, concerns, and challenges?
Since no one is handed their results on the spot, a person
could theoretically sit on pins and needles all year worrying. So how do we
protect ourselves?
The "Life Jacket" of Ein Od Milvado
Rav Wolbe notes that right in the middle of the Zichronos
prayers, the Torah gives us a spiritual life jacket to keep us from drowning in
fear:
![Unsupported file format]()
(Fortunate is the person who does not forget You, the human
who draws strength from You.)
By actively remembering God and keeping Him on our minds, we
create a shield of protection. This is the essence of "Ein Od
Milvado"—the ultimate realization that there is nothing in existence
other than God.
Rav Matisyahu Salomon quotes a powerful idea regarding this
concept, citing a famous story about the Brisker Rav (a descendant of the Nefesh
HaChaim).
While escaping the Nazis on a train in wartime Europe without
papers, the Brisker Rav instructed his children: "Just focus entirely
on the concept of Ein Od Milvado. Think only of God." As a Nazi
officer approached them, the Rav briefly had a momentary lapse in focus, caught
himself, and re-centered his mind on Ein Od Milvado. The Nazi turned
around and walked away.
Rav Matisyahu Salomon points out: If someone told you that a
month from now you'd be trapped on a train surrounded by Nazis, what would you
do? You would spend every single day practicing Ein Od Milvado!
There is a similar
story about the Beis HaLevi (also a descendant of the Nefesh HaChaim).
The Russian authorities had blockaded a town to search warehouses for
contraband goods—which many local Jews traded in out of financial necessity.
One merchant, terrified because his warehouse was full of illegal goods, ran to
the Beis HaLevi after Shacharit.
The Beis HaLevi told him: "We are going to sit right
here and study the concepts of Ein Od Milvado in the Nefesh HaChaim until it is
crystal clear to you."
They spent the entire morning engrossed in this study. By
lunchtime, the inspectors reached the merchant's warehouse and marked an 'X' on
the door before leaving for lunch. When two different inspectors came by after
lunch, one saw the 'X' and said, "We already checked this one,"
and walked past. The man was saved.
Bringing Remembrance Into Action
Rav Matisyahu Salomon explains that Rosh Hashanah is our
personal Ein Od Milvado moment. We need Hashem on our minds the entire
day, and the entire month of Elul is designed to prepare us for this focus.
We even bring this mindfulness into our Rosh Hashanah festive
meals through the Simanim (symbolic foods).
The Meiri asks: Why do we recite the Yehi Ratzon
requests in the middle of the meal rather than before it? He explains that the
prayers were recited as people ate.
Why? Because we don't want to forget God even while eating!
- When
we eat pomegranate salad, we recite Yirbu Mitzvotenu K'Rimon to
connect the food back to God.
- When
we eat the head of a lamb, we recall Akeidat Yitzchak.
Every step of the way—even during a physical meal—is about
keeping Hashem at the forefront of our minds.
Rav Wolbe teaches that we must maximize every single second
of Rosh Hashanah. While it takes effort, keeping God in our thoughts is the
ultimate antidote to the spiritual forgetfulness of Tisha B'Av, realigning our
lives and ushering in a sweet, blessed new year.