Daily Bitachon: The Power of Unanswered Prayer
Welcome to Daily Bitachon. We are continuing our
series on the topic of Nechama (comfort), as we enter the Seven Weeks
of Nechama.
We didn't have much time to cover Parashat Va'etchanan
in detail, but it contains a critical message: Moshe Rabbeinu offered 515
prayers—the numerical value (gematria) of the word Va'etchanan
(ואתחנן).
After these 515 prayers, Hashem tells Moshe:
"Rav lach" — "That is enough, do not speak to Me anymore on this
matter."
Our Sages tell us that had Moshe prayed just one more time,
his prayer would have been answered. At first glance, this sounds like a
depressing note on which to begin the season of comfort: Moshe Rabbeinu prays
incessantly, yet he isn't answered!
The Mystery of 515
What is the significance of the number 515?
1. The Connection to Every Tefilla
The Megalleh Amukot points out that the standard
gematria of the word tefilla (תפלה)
is 515. This means that every single prayer we recite connects back to
this concept of Moshe Rabbeinu praying and not receiving the answer he sought.
Furthermore, the Megalleh Amukot explains that this is why we recite
Psalm 90 (Tefilla L'Moshe) on Shabbat, ending with:
יראה אל עבדיך פעלך
"Let Your work be shown to Your servants..."
Moshe is pleading to see Hashem's handiwork by being granted
entry into Eretz Yisrael.
2. The Mathematical Breakdown (Pnei Yehoshua)
The Pnei Yehoshua (Berachot 32a) offers a
fascinating calculation:
- If
you count the days from Tu B'Av until the 7th of Adar (the
day Moshe Rabbeinu passed away), using the standard calendar alternating
between full and short months:
- Av: 16 days
- Elul: 29 days
- Tishrei: 30 days
- Cheshvan: 29 days
- Kislev: 30 days
- Tevet: 29 days
- Shevat: 30 days
- Adar: 7 days
- Total: 200 days
- 200
days
3 daily prayers = 600 prayers.
- Subtract
the 28 Shabbatot during this period (where personal petitions are
not made):
.
On his final day, after 515 prayers, Hashem told Moshe to
stop before he could recite the 516th prayer. Moshe began praying on Tu
B'Av—the day of turnaround and joy—and prayed continuously until his final
hours, only to be stopped just one prayer short of his goal.
Why Did Hashem Stop Him?
The Sefer Chasidim (ch. 612), quoting Rabbeinu Saadia
Gaon, notes that one reason a prayer might not be answered is due to a final
decree (gzar din). But why would Hashem issue a decree that prevents
such sincere prayer from being accepted?
The Or HaChaim HaKadosh explains that entering the
Land was ultimately not for Moshe's (or the Jewish people's) true benefit:
- Anything
Moshe Rabbeinu built was eternal because his spiritual attribute was Netzach
(eternity).
- Had
Moshe entered Eretz Yisrael and built the Beit HaMikdash, it
could never have been destroyed.
- Consequently,
when Israel sinned in the future, Hashem would not have been able to vent
His wrath on wood and stone; the destruction would have fallen entirely
upon the Jewish people themselves.
By not entering the Land, Moshe effectively took a hit for
the Jewish nation. As Moshe later reflects:
וגם בי התאנף ה' בגללכם
"Hashem was also angry with me on your account."
Moshe realized that his prayer was held back for the ultimate
protection and salvation of Am Yisrael. This realization is itself a
profound level of nechama (comfort). Sometimes we pray relentlessly for
something, but Hashem withholds it because He knows it is not ultimately good
for us.
A Second Calculation: High Holidays to Shemini Atzeret
The Sefer HaToda'ah offers an alternate tradition:
Moshe offered these prayers from Rosh Hashanah through the morning of
Shemini Atzeret—the window of cosmic judgment.
- 21
days
24 hours = 504 hours.
- Add
the 12 hours of the eve of Shemini Atzeret = 516 total
units/prayers.
Hashem stopped Moshe in that final 516th hour—the exact
moment the decree was being sealed and handed down—to prevent the decree from
being annulled, because the outcome was necessary for the greater good.
The Lesson of Nechama: No Prayer is Wasted
Why do we read Parashat Va'etchanan every year during
these seven weeks of comfort?
The Pri Tzadik explains that reading this portion
gives us strength during this period. We often ask ourselves week after week: "Where
is the comfort? Why aren't our prayers bringing the immediate redemption we
long for?"
The Torah reassures us: Do not feel defeated if your
personal prayers seem unanswered. No prayer is ever wasted.
כל המתאבל על ירושלים זוכה ורואה בנחמתה
"Whoever mourns for Jerusalem merits to see her
joy."
The Steipler Gaon writes in Chayei Olam (ch. 28) that
even if years or decades pass and you feel your prayers haven't worked, never
give up. Every single prayer accomplishes something vital. He quotes a
Midrash illustrating that some prayers are answered after 3 days, some after 30
years, and some even after 100 years. We cannot see the divine timetable, but
every word of tefilla builds something lasting.
If Moshe Rabbeinu—the greatest leader who ever lived—had
prayers that were withheld for a higher, hidden good, we shouldn't lose heart
when our own prayers seem to go unanswered. Trust that Hashem hears every word,
and every prayer accomplishes its purpose in its proper time.
We will continue more on this topic tomorrow, B'ezrat Hashem.