The Holiday of Distance: Understanding Tisha B'Av as a Moed
In Alei Shur (Volume 2, Page 411), Rav Shlomo Wolbe zt"l
addresses a well-known halachic anomaly noted by the Shulchan Aruch: We
omit Tachanun (supplicatory prayers) on Tisha B'Av because the prophet
Yirmiyahu refers to the day as a Moed—a designated time or holiday.
How can a day of national tragedy and mourning be considered
a festival? What does it mean for Tisha B'Av to be called a Moed?
The Three States of Spiritual Connection
Quoting his teacher, Reb Yeruchom Levovitz zt"l, Rav
Wolbe explains that the word Moed stems from the concept of a meeting or
encounter. Naturally, we understand a holiday as a time of spiritual
proximity—a Moed shel Kiruv (a holiday of closeness). How, then, can
there be a Moed shel Richuk—a holiday defined by distance?
Rav Wolbe explains that human spiritual awareness exists on
three distinct tiers:
Closeness (Kiruv): Active, conscious alignment with
Hashem.
Distance (Richuk): Acknowledged separation, where one
feels the pain of being far from Hashem.
Ambivalence (Avad Cheshbon): Total spiritual apathy, delusion, or
loss of self-awareness.
Rav Wolbe draws upon Rabbeinu Yona (Sha'arei Teshuva,
Gate 2, Letter 9), who describes the lowest spiritual state: individuals whose
hearts have lost all self-accounting (mikerav libam avad cheshbon).
Described in Yishayahu as a "nation that has lost all
counsel" (goi ovad etzot hemah), people in this state drift
along without a true barometer. They may view themselves as righteous and
perform mitzvot, yet their deeds are tainted by self-justification. As
the Gemara notes of self-righteous hypocrites, they act corruptly like Zimri
yet expect the reward of Phinehas.
The Delusion Before the Destruction
This state of self-delusion defined the generation
immediately preceding the destruction of the First Beit HaMikdash.
Yirmiyahu rebuked the nation:
"How can you say, 'I am not defiled, I have not followed
the Ba'alim'? Look at your way in the valley, know what you have done..."
— Yirmiyahu 2:23
The prophet's primary indictment was not merely the sins
themselves, but the complete denial and rationalization of those sins: "Behold,
I will enter into judgment with you because you say, 'I have not sinned'"
(Yirmiyahu 2:35).
As the Yalkut Shimoni comments on this verse, Hashem's
judgment came specifically because the people refused to admit their
wrongdoing. Hashem extends mercy to one who acknowledges and forsakes sin ("Modeh
v'ozev yerucham"), but genuine repentance is impossible when one lives
in denial.
The Realization: A Return to Truth
When the Beit HaMikdash was destroyed, the delusion
shattered. In that catastrophic moment, the Jewish people experienced a
profound epiphany: I thought I was connected, but I am entirely far away.
While devastating, that realization was a vital reality
check. Recognizing one's distance is itself the beginning of a relationship. In
human terms, a married couple undergoing a period of distant dynamic still has
a relationship; it is a far cry from complete dissolution or indifference. When
a person feels the pain of being distant from Hashem, they re-anchor themselves
in reality.
Hashem is a God of truth, and His presence cannot reside in a
life built on self-deception. When we confront our distance and grieve over it,
we connect to that essential point of truth. As Dovid HaMelech writes:
"Hashem is close to all who call upon Him, to all who
call upon Him in truth."
— Tehillim 145:18
Reawakening on Tisha B'Av
This insight redefines how we approach Tisha B'Av each year.
Chazal teach that any generation in which the Beit HaMikdash is not
rebuilt, it is as though it was destroyed in their time.
If the generation of the Beit HaMikdash—a generation
operating at a lofty spiritual frequency—could fall trap to self-justification,
how much more vulnerable are we? Steeped in physical comfort and modern
distractions, it is easy to slip into a state of avad cheshbon, where
the absence of the Beit HaMikdash hardly registers.
Tisha B'Av serves as our annual spiritual reset. By mourning
the loss and confronting the immense gap between where we are and where we
ought to be, we transform our apathy into awareness. Recognizing our distance
becomes our point of contact with Hashem, establishing Tisha B'Av as a true Moed—the
essential gateway to the High Holidays and the call to "search and
examine our ways, and return to Hashem" (Eichah 3:40).