A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Sutton

Daily Bitachon

The Months of Tamuz and Av 15

Lectured by Rabbi David Sutton

Published
July 13, 2026
Duration
10:01

Daily Bitachon: Framing Eicha and the Secrets of Ashrei

As we get closer to Tisha B'Av, we want to share some insights on Megillat Eicha.

The Concept of a Petichta (The Opening)

Midrash Eicha starts with a section called Petichta deHakimei, which means "introductory teachings of the wise men." We find a similar concept in the Talmud (Megillah 10b), where a long list of Chachamim (scholars) introduce the Megillah using this exact term.

What is the deeper meaning of an "opening"?

The Or Gedalyahu (Purim, p. 86) explains that a Petichta acts like a mafteach (a key). It is designed to unlock the inner secrets of the text so we don't lose the forest for the trees. It anchors us to the underlying message of the book.

Beginning and Ending with Goodness

In Sefer Kad HaKemach (Gezel, Unit 2), Rabbeinu Bechaye discusses the famous rabbinic dictum:

לעולם יתחיל אדם בדבר טוב ויסיים בדבר טוב

"A person should always begin and end with something good."

He explains that "good" (tov) refers directly to God.

We can see this as we say every day in the Amidah and Ashrei:

  • "הטוב שמך ולך נאה להודות" (The Good is Your Name, and to You it is fitting to give thanks).
  • "טוב ה׳ לכל" (Tov Hashem lakol – God is good to all).

A name represents the essence of a thing, meaning God's absolute essence is goodness. This is a foundational theme of the Nine Days—a topic we will delve into further.

Rabbeinu Bechaye and the Nefesh HaChaim explain that the ultimate expression of God's name in this world is the Torah. When the verse says, "כי שם ה׳ אקרא" ("When I call out the name of Hashem"), it refers to the Torah, which is is the names of G-d and I must gibe greatness to his name this is the source for birkat hatorah, when we learn Torah, mention his name we give Him greatness by blessing him.. In fact, the Ramban writes in his introduction to Bereishit that the entire Torah is comprised of interwoven names of God. Therefore, every Petichta begins with a Torah verse because it contains fundamental holiness—the dvar tov (good thing) that reframes our perspective before we experience the grief of Eicha.

Reframing Exile: The Daughter of Waves

In the Midrash, Rabbi Abba bar Kahana quotes a verse from Yeshayahu: "צהלי קולך בת גלים" ("Raise your voice, daughter of the waves"). The Midrash explains that "daughter of the waves" (or "daughter of exiles") refers to the Jewish nation.

We are the children of exiles:

  • Avraham experienced exile and famine ("Vayehi ra'av ba'aretz").
  • Yitzchak experienced exile and famine, moving to Avimelech in Gerar.
  • Yaakov fled his home to Padan Aram.

The message here is not to despair. The pain of exile is not a historic coincidence; it was built into the blueprint of creation.

Rav Wolbe noted that the very opening lines of the Torah—"והארץ היתה תהו ובהו וחשך על פני תהום"—allude to the four exiles:

  1. Tohu (Chaos): Babylonia (Bavel)

  2. Vohu (Void): Persia and Media (Paras u'Madai)

  3. Choshech (Darkness): Greece (Yavan)

  4. Tehom (The Depths): Rome/Edom (our current, seemingly endless exile)

Immediately following this, the Torah states, "And the spirit of God hovered over the water," which refers to the spirit of Mashiach.

Why Must We Suffer?

If exile is built into creation, why is it necessary?

The Maharal (Netzach Yisrael, Ch. 15) explains that this world is not our true home. As the Mishnah in Pirkei Avot teaches, this world is merely an anteroom (prozdor) to the World to Come. The fact that we are constantly uprooted and persecuted is a reminder that we don't inherently belong in this physical domain; we belong in a higher, spiritual realm.

Our painful exile is the difficult path toward ultimate greatness. We wear the title Bat Golim (Daughter of Exiles) with pride. It is a symbol of our cosmic displacement and a reminder that our true place is in the World to Come. We must not lose faith in the face of antisemitism or tragedy. It is painful, but it is a process built for our ultimate growth.

The Father's Perspective: A Mashal from the Chasam Sofer

In Berachot 3a, Rabbi Yose enters a ruin in Jerusalem to pray, and Eliyahu HaNavi waits for him outside. When Rabbi Yose finishes, Eliyahu asks him what he heard inside the ruin. Rabbi Yose responds that he heard a heavenly echo (Bat Kol) groaning like a dove, saying:

"Woe to the children, that because of their sins I destroyed My house, burned My sanctuary, and exiled them among the nations."

Eliyahu informs him that this occurs three times every single day. Furthermore, whenever the Jewish people enter a synagogue and declare "אמן יהא שמיה רבא" (Amen, may His great name be blessed), God shakes His head and says:

"Fortunate is the King who is praised in His house! What is there for a Father who exiled His children? And woe to the children who were exiled from their Father's table."

The Chasam Sofer makes a brilliant textual analysis here. Notice the phrasing: "Woe to the children" is stated, but when referring to God, it uses the milder phrase "What is there for a Father..." rather than "Woe to the Father." Why does God not groan for Himself in the same way?

The Mashal (Parable)

Imagine a man whose wife is in labor with their firstborn son. He is thrilled, anticipating the Brit Milah and the Pidyon Haben. Right now, his wife is screaming in agonizing pain. The husband feels her pain acutely, but he isn't despairing. Why? Because he can see the bigger picture. He visualizes the joy of the upcoming celebrations and the beautiful life ahead.

We are currently experiencing Chevlei Mashiach—the birth pangs of the Messianic era. Like childbirth, the pain intensifies right before the ultimate joy.

The Chasam Sofer explains that God is like that expectant father. He feels our pain, but He does not groan for Himself because He sees the staggering spiritual heights we are climbing. He sees the light we generate by pushing against the tide of exile.

Stay tuned tomorrow as we discuss why the response of "Amen Yehei Shmei Raba" is so deeply moving to the Almighty.