A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Sutton

Daily Bitachon

The Months of Tamuz and Av 10

Lectured by Rabbi David Sutton

Published
July 3, 2026
Duration
06:15

Shabbat: The Root of Exile and the Key to Redemption

As we find ourselves in the Three Weeks, mourning the Churban Beit HaMikdash (Destruction of the Temple), we can find a profound connection between this period of exile and the holiness of Shabbat.

The Gemara (Masechet Shabbat 118b) states a radical concept:

If the Jewish people had fully kept the very first Shabbat, no nation would have ever been able to gain control over them.

The Apparent Contradiction

The Gemara derives this from the text in Shemot. Right after the Jewish people desecrated Shabbat by trying to collect the Manna (Shemot 16:27), the Torah states, "Vayavo Amalek"—Amalek came and attacked (Shemot 17:8).

However, there is a textual problem. These two events do not happen right next to each other. In between the desecration of Shabbat and the arrival of Amalek, the Torah records the episode of Massah U-Merivah, where the people openly doubted God, asking: "היש ה' בקרבנו אם אין" ("Is God among us or not?").

We traditionally learn that Amalek attacks precisely when our faith wavers and we ask "Where is God?" If their lack of faith caused the attack, why does the Gemara blame it on the desecration of Shabbat?

To use an analogy: If someone drinks Alka-Seltzer, then drinks cyanide, and dies—you cannot claim the Alka-Seltzer killed them. The cyanide did.

Resolution: Shabbat Filters Our Emunah

Rav Matityahu Salomon answers this using a passage from Yechezkel (20:12-13). The prophet describes how God took the nation out of Egypt, gave them commandments, and they rebelled. Yechezkel highlights one specific sin: "ושבתותי חללו מאד" ("And My Sabbaths they greatly desecrated"), noting that this is why God initially wanted to destroy them in the desert.

We usually associate the threat of destruction in the desert with the Sin of the Spies (Meraglim). Why does Yechezkel point to Shabbat?

  • The Root and the Symptom: If not for the initial breakdown in Shmirat Shabbat (Shabbat observance), the Jewish people would never have developed doubts in their Emunah (faith).
  • The only reason they asked "Is God among us?" at Massah U-Merivah, and the only reason they faltered during the Sin of the Spies, was because the spiritual shield of their Shabbat had been compromised.
  • (Note: This identical insight was published 300 years ago by Rav Moshe Frankfurt in his Sefer Mincha Gedola).

The Path to Geulah (Redemption)

Just as Shabbat neglect is the root of exile, proper Shabbat observance is the fast track to the Geulah. The Gemara famously notes that if Israel keeps just two Shabbatot properly, they will be immediately redeemed.

But how is it practically possible to get the entire global Jewish population to keep Shabbat perfectly all at once?

1. The Power of a Single Community

Rav Matityahu Salomon (Matnat Chaim, p. 205) quotes the Zohar Chadash (Parshat Noach), which resolves this exact logistical question:

If even one single synagogue or community sincerely returns to God and elevates their Shabbat together, the entire global exile will be gathered back in their merit.

The responsibility doesn't fall on those who do not yet know the beauty of Shabbat; it falls on us—those who do know—to uplift our own observance.

2. The Anatomy of "Two Shabbats"

The Sefer Apiryon (quoting Rav Teitelbaum, the Yismach Moshe, 1758–1841) takes this a step further. He explains that we technically only need to keep one Shabbat flawlessly—but a flawless Shabbat requires a specific framework:

[Shabbat 1: The Source] ──> [6 Holy Weekdays] ──> [Shabbat 2: The Destination]

To truly rest on the seventh day, the preceding six days of work must be infused with the holiness of the Shabbat that came before them. Therefore, to experience one perfectly integrated holy week, you naturally need to experience two Shabbatot—one to fuel the week, and one to conclude it.

3. Overriding the Laws of Nature

A final, mind-boggling piece of this puzzle is found in Gemara Niddah 13b, which states that Mashiach cannot come until all destined souls (Neshamot) are born into the world.

Tosafot poses a challenge: If keeping two Shabbatot can bring Mashiach instantly, what happens to the remaining unborn souls?

Tosafot answers: The spiritual power of keeping two Shabbatot is so immense that God will alter the laws of nature. Much like the miraculous births in Egypt, mothers will instantly and safely give birth to multiple children at once, rapidly bringing all remaining souls into the world to clear the path for Mashiach.

Conclusion

Shabbat holds the ultimate spiritual leverage. When neglected, it weakens our foundational faith and leaves us vulnerable to exile. But when cherished and elevated—even by just one dedicated community—Shabbat possesses the supernatural power to alter reality, repair our Emunah, and bring the ultimate Geulah today.