The Core Mindset of Tisha B'Av: The Pain of Disconnect
Welcome to Daily Bitachon.
As we approach Tisha B'Av, we must identify our fundamental
mindset. We often get caught up in the minute details of an event and lose
sight of its core theme—or, as the saying goes, lose sight of the forest for
the trees.
Consider Rosh Hashanah: if you ask people for its central
theme, they might say it's the Day of Judgment, the New Year, or the start of
the Aseret Yemei Teshuva (Ten Days of Repentance). However, the Ramchal
distills it into just two words: Yom Malkeinu—the day of our King.
Judgment and Teshuva naturally flow out of that primary reality: Hashem
is our King.
The same principle applies to Tisha B'Av.
What Is the Ultimate Focal Point?
- Is it
mourning the Churban (destruction of the Temple)? Yes.
- Is it
focusing on the sins that caused it, like Lashon Hara and Sinat
Chinam (baseless hatred)? Of course.
- Is it
stirring our emotions about the historical tragedies of the Jewish nation,
including the Holocaust? That definitely helps.
But what lies beneath it all? What is the core theme?
Rav Nosson Wachtfogel zt"l explains that our
focus during these days is rooted in a famous Gemara in Masechet Berachot
(3a). The Gemara relates that Rabbi Yossi once entered a ruined building in
Yerushalayim to pray. On his way out, he met Eliyahu HaNavi, who asked him, "Did
you hear anything in there?"
Rabbi Yossi responded that he heard a Heavenly Voice crying
out:
"Woe to the Father who exiled His children, and woe to
the children who were exiled from their Father's table!"
Eliyahu HaNavi revealed that this Voice does not cry out just
once; it cries out three times every single day when the Jewish people
recite Kaddish.
From here we see that the focal point of Tisha B'Av is
mourning the disconnect from our Father in Heaven.
Understanding the Disconnect
Our Father is alive, and we are alive—yet there is a
functional separation between us. Mourning this is no different than mourning
the loss of a relative.
Fundamentally, death is a separation of the body from the
soul. Similarly, the Beis HaMikdash became disconnected from the Shechina
(Divine Presence). The physical destruction of the Beis HaMikdash was
merely an external symptom of an internal, spiritual disconnect. As the Midrash
notes, a Heavenly Echo mocked the ancient conquerors: "You ground
pre-ground flour." The building was already hollow; it was a body
without a soul because the connection had already been severed.
The phrase "exiled from their Father's table"
perfectly describes our current reality:
- When
the Beis HaMikdash stood: We sat directly at our Father's table in His revealed
presence.
- Today: We still receive care packages
from Him—He sustains, feeds, and protects us—but we can no longer see Him
directly.
Hashem created the human framework of parents and children as
a tangible model so we could comprehend our relationship with Him. The ultimate
Father is Avinu SheBaShamayim. While fathers miss their children deeply,
children going off to camp don't always miss their parents with the same
intensity.
Why Is Kaddish in Aramaic?
This brings us back to the Gemara: why do we recite Kaddish
in Aramaic?
We noted that Hashem moans over our distance when He hears us
say Kaddish. When a son recites Kaddish for a physical parent, it
serves as a stark reminder to Hashem of the grander, broken Father-Son
connection—if only His children mourned the cosmic disconnect between
themselves and their Ultimate Father with the same intensity.
This emotional weight is precisely why Kaddish is in
Aramaic. As Tosafot explains, the ministering angels do not understand Aramaic.
We intentionally use this language because if the angels understood the depth
of Hashem's grief over His exiled children, they would attempt to block the
prayer just to spare Him the pain. Furthermore, the angels are jealous of our
unique status; they must wait for the Jewish people to praise Hashem first
because we are His children.
Awakened Mercy: The Father-Child Connection
We find another instance where Hashem's mercy is aroused by a
parent-child disconnect in Masechet Chullin (139a).
Regarding the mitzvah of Shilluach HaKan (sending away
the mother bird), the Torah states: "If a bird's nest happens to be
before you..." You might have thought you were required to search
mountains and valleys for a nest, but the verse teaches that it applies only if
you happen upon it.
Rav Yair Chaim Bacharach (Chavot Yair, Responsum 67)
deduces that if you stumble upon a nest, you are obligated to send away the
mother bird, even if you do not want the eggs. Why? He explains based on the
Zohar: the rationale behind this mitzvah is to invoke Divine mercy on the
mother bird, which in turn awakens Divine mercy for the Jewish people in exile.
Whenever Hashem sees a parent bemoaning a child—or a child bemoaning a
parent—it triggers a powerful awakening of Heavenly compassion.
As the Tanna DeBei Eliyahu Rabbah (Ch. 31)
states—quoted by Rabbi Chaim Palachi in Mo'ed L'Chol Chai (15):
"Hashem sits and waits for Klal Yisrael even more than a
father waits for his son or a wife for her husband, hoping they will do Teshuva
so that He may redeem them and rebuild the Beis HaMikdash for them."
Rabbi Chaim Palachi adds:
"Every time I read this passage, my eyes flow with
tears. How is it possible that the King of Glory, the Eternal God, sits and
waits for us to return to Him just so He can bestow upon us every good in the
world—yet each person continues following the stubbornness of their heart, with
no one taking it to heart to say, 'Come, let us return to Hashem'?"
The Tree Draped in White
A beautiful story told by Rabbi Baruch Chait/Rabbi Paysach
Spiro illustrates this bond:
A young man had a bitter falling out with his father. Fueled
by anger and rebellion, he packed his bags, walked out of his parents' house,
and went off to live life on his own terms.
Years passed, and things went downhill. He hit rock
bottom—broke, exhausted, lonely, and filled with deep regret for how he had
treated his family. He desperately wanted to come home, but he was overwhelmed
by shame and fear, assuming his parents had disowned him.
Unable to bring himself to call or walk up to the front door,
he wrote a letter:
"Dear Mom and Dad, I know I broke your hearts and I have
no right to ask to come back. But I am taking the train home next week, and the
tracks run right along the back of our property. If you can ever find it in
your hearts to forgive me and let me come home, please tie a white cloth on the
old tree next to the tracks. If the train passes and I see a white sheet, I
will get off at the station and come home. But if the tree is bare, I will stay
on the train and never bother you again."
The day arrived, and the young man boarded the train. As it
approached his hometown, his heart pounded so fast with anxiety that he
couldn't bring himself to look out the window. He turned to the stranger next
to him and whispered, "Sir, our house is coming up around the next bend
on the left. Can you please look out the window and tell me if there is a white
sheet hanging on the tree by the tracks?"
The train rounded the bend. The stranger looked out, gasped,
and put a hand on the boy's shoulder: "Son, look for yourself."
The boy opened his eyes. There wasn't just one sheet on the
tree—every single branch was draped in white. White towels, sheets, and
tablecloths hung from the clothesline, draped over the roof of the barn, and
tied along the fence. His parents hadn't just put up a signal; they wanted to
make sure there was no possible way he could miss the message: They were
waiting for him, they loved him, and he was welcome home.
This is precisely how Hashem feels toward us. Let us keep
that close to our hearts this Tisha B'Av.