Unanswered Prayers and the Treasury of Jewish Tears
The Message of Parashat Va'etchanan
We are continuing with the theme we started yesterday—a
central message from Parashat Va'etchanan. Moshe Rabbeinu prayed to enter Eretz
Yisrael and was not answered. This gives us chizuk (encouragement): when
we pray and feel we are not being answered, it does not mean our prayer was
wasted. We are no different than Moshe Rabbeinu.
Rav Aryeh Levin and the Widowed Woman
Rabbi Feuer brings down a beautiful story about Rav Aryeh
Levin, a man of rare compassion and sensitivity.
Once, a distraught, recently widowed woman came to him,
crying uncontrollably. All his efforts to console her were to no avail.
Finally, the widow said she would accept consolation if he could answer one
question:
"Please tell me: what happened to all my tears? I prayed
and prayed for my late husband. I recited chapter after chapter of Tehillim and
shed thousands upon thousands of tears. My very soul flowed into those tears.
Where are they? Were they all wasted?"
Gently, Rav Aryeh Levin replied:
"After 120 years, when you leave this world and ascend
to the Heavenly Tribunal, you will see how meaningful and precious your tears
were. You will discover that Hashem Himself gathered them, counted every single
teardrop, and treasured it like a precious gem.
There is a beautiful line that Sephardim say in Selichot:
העבר חטאתי אלהי ישועתי וגם את דמעתי שימה בנאדך
('Forgive my sins, God of my salvation, and place my tears in
Your flask.')
This based on a pasuk in Tehillim(56:9) נֹדִי סָפַרְתָּה אָתָּה שִׂימָה דִמְעָתִי
בְנֹאדֶךָ הֲלֹא בְּסִפְרָתֶךָ:
"You Yourself have counted my wanderings; place my tears
into Your flask—are they not recorded in Your book?"
The Gemara comments on this pasuk : "Whoever sheds
tears over [the passing of] a virtuous person, the Holy One, Blessed be He,
counts them and stores them in His treasure house, as it is stated: 'You
Yourself have counted my wanderings; place my tears in Your flask, are they not
in Your book?'" (Shabbat 105b)
God has a flask where He places every Jewish tear. You will
discover that whenever a harsh decree loomed over the Jewish people, one of
your tears came and washed the evil away, making it null and void. Even a
single sincere tear is a source of salvation."
Hearing this, the woman burst into a fresh flow of tears—no
longer tears of sorrow and grief, but tears of courage and hope.
The "Tefillah Bank" and the Power of Unanswered
Prayer
The Sefer Chasidim teaches that prayers that go
unanswered enter a "tefillah bank." We often view an unanswered
prayer as if it were thrown in the garbage, but it is actually deposited in a
celestial bank to be used later. It may even work for you in ways you don't yet
see.
The Chazon Ish and the Returned Generation
Rav Yitzchak Scheiner zt"l (Rosh Yeshiva of
Kamenetz Yerushalayim) spoke in the Deal Shul on Tisha B'Av many years ago,
following Rav Matisyahu Salomon zt"l. Rav Matisyahu had spoken
about the remarkable spiritual renewal of the Jewish people that we are
witnessing today.
Rav Scheiner shared how those words struck a personal chord,
recalling his own journey from public school to becoming the Kamenetz Rosh
Yeshiva. He shared the following story:
In 1950, the Chazon Ish asked Rav Galinsky to keep an eye on
a young bochur who had left his non-religious kibbutz to learn at the
Ponevezh Yeshiva in Bnei Brak. Rav Galinsky noticed this was not an isolated
case; there was a steady stream of young men returning to Yiddishkeit.
Rav Galinsky asked the Chazon Ish: "Why do you
suppose so many children are coming back to Yiddishkeit today, leaving behind
the lifestyle of their non-committed parents?"
The Chazon Ish answered:
"The generation that left Yiddishkeit came from
religious parents. Those parents saw what was happening to their children
and—for whatever reason—could not stop them. They cried lonely, bitter tears.
They prayed and they fasted, but it was too late to stem the tide.
However, Hashem does not forget a Jewish tear. If those
sincere tears did not save their own children, they were preserved to help
their grandchildren and great-grandchildren. That is why these children are
returning today—because Hashem never forgets a tear."
A Personal Reflection: The Legacy of a Teardrop
I will share something on a personal note as well. Many years
ago, in the early 1980s, I met a great Rabbi—Chacham Abraham Raful (the uncle
of Chacham Yosef Raful shlit"a from Ateret Torah). He was in his
90s at the time.
When he heard my last name was Sutton, he asked, "Are
you related to Abraham Sutton?" That was my great-grandfather. When I
said yes, he told me a story he had witnessed firsthand:
"Your great-grandfather lived in Syria, but he would
travel to Yerushalayim on occasion. One morning in shul, I noticed he was
weeping bitterly during his tefillah. Thinking he had a terrible personal
problem, I asked him, 'Mr. Sutton, how can I help you? What's wrong?'
He answered, 'Nothing is wrong. But every morning when I
recite Birkat HaTorah and reach the words וצאצאנו וצאצאי צאצאנו ('our children and the descendants of our children'), I
think to myself: My children I know, and I can guide them to the best of my
ability. But my grandchildren and great-grandchildren—what can I do for them?
All I can do is cry for them. So that is what I do every morning during Birkot
HaShachar.'"
Chacham Abraham Raful concluded: "If he has religious
grandchildren and great-grandchildren today, it is from those tears."
I am living proof—a product of tears shed decades ago that
are still working today. And while there were tears that seemingly didn't work
immediately for certain family members, in the end, even those who experienced
a temporary lapse returned. The spiritual gene was awakened by those prayers.
Understanding the Full Impact of Tefillah
The Steipler (Chayei Olam, ch. 28) explains that the
question "Why wasn't my prayer answered?" comes from a flawed
perspective. We have no idea what would have happened without our
prayers. How can we say a prayer wasn't answered when it may have prevented a
far worse outcome?
The Midrash notes that prayer sometimes accomplishes half:
- When
a decree was issued that all of Aharon HaKohen's children should pass
away, his and Moshe's prayers saved two of his four sons. While losing two
sons was a horrific tragedy, the prayer mitigated a harsh decree and saved
the remaining two.
Tears with a Delayed Reaction: The 100-Year Siyum
Sometimes, tears have a delayed reaction even for the very
person they were meant for. (Jewish Observer, Dec. '98, p. 47)
A man once made a Siyum Mishnayos on Shas for his
father's yahrzeit, marking the 100th anniversary of his father's arrival
in America. He retold the trials his family faced and how the "Goldene
Medina" (America) had eroded their Yiddishkeit.
He was the youngest of nine children, and his eight older
siblings had already severed their connection to Yiddishkeit. His father's last
hope was him—Mordechai. On his 16th birthday, Mordechai built up the courage to
confront his father before davening:
"Papa, I'm not going to Yeshiva College. I'm not going
to lay tefillin anymore. I'm not going to shul on Shabbos. I want to be just
like my brothers, sisters, and friends."
The author recalled:
"I raised my hands expecting a slap, but my father
stopped and began to plead:
'Motke, du bist die letzte—you're the last one. My last hope.
Don't say that. Don't mean it.'
I was shocked to hear my father beg. 'Papa, please,' I said.
'I don't want to learn to be a rabbi. I just want to be like everyone else.'
'So don't be a rabbi!' he cried. 'Just stay a good Jew—put on
tefillin, keep kosher, keep Shabbos. Don't become like the others. It's enough
that I raised eight—I don't need nine! Motke, it's enough already!'
My father burst into tears. I hugged him and cried too:
'Papa, please don't cry. It makes no sense to me to be frum, but I'll
try.'"
For 16-year-old Mordechai, those tears were soon forgotten as
he eventually drifted away like his siblings. Decades later, however, the tears
returned to him.
When his own son wrote to him from Jerusalem saying he had
enrolled in Yeshiva Ohr Somayach, Mordechai booked a flight to Israel to talk
him out of his "foolishness." But as he prepared to leave, the memory
of his father's tears came rushing back—and his heart changed.
At the Siyum, he concluded:
"On this centennial of my father's arrival in America
and on his yahrzeit, I want to say:
'America, you beat us Jews bad, but you didn't win.'
And to my father:
'Papa, you were beaten badly, but you didn't lose.'"