As we've seen, one
should avoid putting on two articles of clothing simultaneously, as this can
result in forgetting one's Torah knowledge.
The reason is that a special "Or Ha'makif" ("supernal light") surrounds
our clothing once we put them on to protect them from the forces of impurity,
and when a garment is inside another garment, this light cannot reach it to provide
protection.
The question was asked
concerning men who leave their ties tied around the neck of their shirts. Seemingly, a man should not put on a shirt
with the tie already on it, because he is then putting on two garments at the
same time.
Rav Yisrael Bitan
writes that there is room to allow this practice, because it is questionable
whether a tie, which does not cover a significant portion of the body,
qualifies as a "garment" in this respect.
He notes the ruling of the Yalkut Yosef that one recites the Beracha of
"She'hehiyanu" upon the purchase of a new tie, which would indicate that a tie
indeed is considered a "Beged" ("garment"), but he questions this conclusion,
as a tie could be viewed as an accessory to the shirt, rather than an
independent garment. Furthermore, Rav
Bitan adds, even if a tie indeed formally qualifies as a "Beged," it is
possible that a garment that does not really cover any part of the body does
not require the protection of the "Or Ha'makif." Hence, there is room to permit men to put on
a shirt with the tie already tied around the collar.
This applies as well
to pants with the belt already around the waist. Many men keep the belt inside the loops of
the pants, and then put the pants on together with the belt. Rav Bitan maintains that this is permissible,
for the same reason as he explains regarding the tie– because the belt covers a
very small portion of the body, and so this Halacha likely does not apply.
A similar question
arises for women who cover their hair with a snood and a decorative kerchief on
top. Many women keep the snood and
kerchief together and then put them both on at the same time. Is this allowed?
Rav Bitan writes that
there is room to argue that since women are exempt from the obligation of Torah
study, and the entire concern of putting on two garments simultaneously relates
to the retention of one's Torah knowledge, this Halacha does not apply to women
at all. According to this theory, women
do not need to avoid putting on two articles of clothing at the same time.
Rav Bitan concludes
that one should not rely on this theory, and women should, in general, avoid
putting on two garments simultaneously, but this possibility may be introduced
as one of several factors to permit putting on the snood with the
kerchief. Another consideration is that if
they are kept tied together, then they may be considered a single garment. And even if not, if this has become the
normal method of putting the hair-coverings on, then this might suffice to view
them as just one garment. Moreover,
since the kerchief covers only part of the snood, the "Or Ha'makif" can reach
the snood, such that there is no concern.
While each of these possibilities on its own could be questioned, they
may be combined to permit women to put on the snood and kerchief together.
Incidentally, if a man
wears a long-sleeve undershirt beneath his shirt, then he must ensure not to
pull both sleeves over his Tefillin in the morning simultaneously. Although he may certainly cover his arm with
both layers, he should pull each sleeve separately, and not pull them both over
his arm together.