The
Torah in Parashat Shemini (Vayikra 11:42) forbids eating “Kol Ha’sheretz
Ha’shoretz Al Ha’aretz” (“all the crawling creatures which crawl on the
ground”), which the Sefer Ha’hinuch explains as referring to insects which grow
in fruits and vegetables and have left onto the ground. Once these insects leave the fruit or
vegetable in which they have grown, they are forbidden for consumption. As long as they remain inside the fruit or
vegetable, there is no prohibition against eating them, but once they leave,
they are forbidden, even if they then return to the fruit.
This
prohibition applies only to insects that grow in produce while the produce was
still attached to the ground. Insects
that grow in produce after harvesting are not included in this
prohibition. However, as the Sefer
Ha’hinuch writes, it is all but impossible to determine whether an insect grew
in a fruit or vegetable before or after it was harvested, and thus we must
refrain from all insects that grow in produce.
The
Rambam, in Sefer Ha’misvot, rules that if an insect emerged from inside a
fruit, but remained on the fruit’s surface instead of leaving and going onto
the ground, it is nevertheless included in the prohibition, and one would be
liable to Malkut for eating such a creature.
The Sefer Ha’hinuch notes that this ruling is mistaken, because the
Gemara writes explicitly that the insect’s status at this point is uncertain,
and thus, while it is forbidden to eat the insect, one would not be liable to
Malkut if he does, given the uncertainty of its status. In fact, the Rambam himself, in his Yad
Ha’hazaka, codifies the Gemara’s ruling that the insect’s status if it remained
on the fruit’s surface is uncertain.
Insects
found inside fish are assumed to have originated outside the fish, and are thus
forbidden. This applies also to insects
found inside the stomach of an animal.
Insects
found in water are permissible if they grew in the water, but not if they
originated outside the water and then went into the water. (A number of years ago, there was a debate
concerning small insects found in the New York City water system, as it was
uncertain whether they originated outside the water or grew in the water.)
This
prohibition, of course, applies in all times and in all places, and to both
males and females. One who intentionally
eats a complete insect is liable to Malkut.
If, however, the insect is incomplete – even it is missing just a single
leg – then one is not liable to Malkut unless he consumes a Ke’zayit of
insects.
In
order to avoid this Biblical command, it is imperative that one carefully
inspects his produce to ensure that they do not contain insects. The Gemara in Masechet Makkot states that it
is possible to violate five or six commands by consuming an insect.
It
is famously told that the Ben Ish Hai (Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909)
once saw a woman checking lettuce on Ereb Pesah casually, without making a
thorough inspection. He turned to the
woman and asked how many hairs were on her head.
“How
many hairs?!” she asked. “There are so
many – I cannot possibly know how many!”
“You
will be responsible for more violations than hairs on your head for failing to
properly check the lettuce,” the Rabbi said.
He explained that each guest she will be serving at the Seder could end
up consuming large numbers of insects, and for each one, he will be liable to
numerous sets of Malkut, because of her failure to inspect the produce…
To
give us some perspective, if a person eats a hamburger in a non-kosher
restaurant, he transgresses only a single prohibition – the consumption of
Nebela (meat from an animal which was not properly slaughtered) or Terefa (meat
from an animal with a terminal physical ailment). But if one eats a salad in a non-kosher
restaurant, he violates hundreds of prohibitions, as he consumes an untold
number of insects. It is thus vitally
important to exercise caution in this regard and ensure to avoid eating produce
which has not been properly inspected.