The
Torah in Parashat Ahareh-Mot (Vayikra 18:14) commands regarding one’s father’s
brother, “El Ishto Lo Tikrab, Dodatecha Hi” – “Do not approach his wife; she is
your aunt.” This verse establishes a
prohibition against having relations with the wife of one’s father’s
brother. This prohibition applies even
after the uncle died or divorced his wife; once one’s father’s brother marries
a woman, the nephew may never have an intimate relationship with that
woman. Furthermore, this prohibition
applies even to a woman whom the uncle merely betrothed, even before the
marriage was completed.
The
Biblical command applies only to the wife of one’s father’s brother from the
same father. If one’s father has a
half-brother from the same mother, but not from the same father, that the
nephew is, on the level of Torah law, allowed to marry a woman to whom the
uncle had been married. The Sages,
however, enacted a provision prohibiting such a relationship.
This
prohibition applies in all times and in all places. If one intentionally transgressed this
command, and had a relationship with his father’s brother’s wife while she was
married to the uncle, then the nephew and the aunt are punished by Henek
(execution by strangulation), for violating the prohibition of adultery. If the uncle and aunt were no longer married,
then their forbidden act is punishable by Karet. If witnesses saw the act, then the violator
is liable to Malkut. If the act was
committed unintentionally, then the violator must bring a Hatat (sin-offering). If one had intercourse with the wife of his
father’s brother from the same mother but not from the same father, then he
receives Malkut by force of Rabbinic enactment.
The
Torah later (Vayikra 20:20) says about those who engage in such a relationship,
“Aririm Yamutu” – “they shall die childless.”
The Gemara (Yebamot 55) explains this to mean that the violators will be
unable to beget children, and if they already had children, the children will
die during their lifetime. Rashi writes
that this verse establishes that part of the punishment of Karet is
childlessness; the Torah here states that whenever someone deserves Karet, his
punishment will include having no offspring.
Tosafot, however, disagree, and maintain that only when one is guilty of
a sin involving Arayot (forbidden intimate relationship), his punishment includes
childlessness. Sinners who are liable to
Karet for other offenses, by contrast, are not, in Tosafot’s view, subject to
this punishment of childlessness.
During
the Vidui (confessional) prayer on Yom Kippur, we confess “Al Hataim She’anahnu
Hayabim Alehem Karet Va’ariri” – “for sins for which we are liable to Karet and
childlessness.” This text is readily
understandable according to Rashi’s opinion, that every sin which carries a
punishment of Karet also carries the punishment of childlessness. Naturally, then, we mention these two
punishments together, in reference to the same category of sin. According to Tosafot’s opinion, we must
explain this prayer text as referring first to all sins punishable by Karet,
and then specifically to those that carry the additional punishment of
childlessness – meaning, sins of Arayot.
Interestingly, the Maharil (Rav Yaakob Moelin, Germany, 1365-1427) had
the practice to include the word “Va’ariri” in this passage only during the
Minha service on Yom Kippur afternoon.
The likely explanation is that he followed Tosafot’s opinion, that the
punishment of “Ariri” is reserved only for violations of Arayot. The Maharil therefore made mention of this
punishment specifically during Minha, when the portion read from the Torah is
the section in Parashat Ahareh-Mot which introduces the Arayot prohibitions. Having just read the section of Arayot, the
Maharil felt, we should make special mention of these sins in our confessional
prayer.