The Torah in Parashat Ahareh-Mot
(Vayikra 18:15) commands that one may not engage in intimate relations with
“Eshet Ahicha” – one’s brother’s wife.
This applies regardless of whether the person and his brother share both
parents, only a father, or only a mother.
Additionally, even if the brother merely betrothed a woman, and had yet
to complete the marriage, one is forbidden from engaging in relations with the
bride, forever. Even if the brother
subsequently dies or divorces his wife, she remains forbidden for the
brother-in-law.
The famous exception to this rule is a
situation of Yibum – where a married man dies without any children. In such a case, it actually becomes a Misva
for the deceased’s brother to marry the widow.
Whereas generally a sister-in-law is forbidden for marriage even after the
brother’s death, in this instance, there is a Misva for the brother to marry
the widow.
This command applies in all times and
in all places. If one had relations with
his brother’s wife while the brother was still married to her, then they are
liable to Henek (execution by strangulation) for violating the prohibition of
Eshet Ish (adultery). If this encounter
occurred after the brother had died or divorced the woman, then the violator is
liable to Karet for transgressing the prohibition of relations with one’s
sister-in-law. If one committed this
transgression mistakenly, he must bring a Hatat (sin-offering).
It is worth reflecting on the fact
that a relationship which is generally strictly forbidden, and regarded as a
capital offense, can become not only allowed, but a Misva, in certain
circumstances. The institution of Yibum,
which designates as a Misva a marriage between a man and his childless
brother’s widow – a marriage which would otherwise be forbidden – shows us how
we must humble ourselves before the Torah’s authority. Only G-d Himself determines when something is
permitted, forbidden, or a Misva. We are
to humbly submit to the Torah’s commands, without ever thinking that we can
intuitively decide what Hashem wants of us.