After
presenting the command forbidding offering blemished animals as sacrifices, the
Torah adds (Vayikra 22:5), “U’mi’yad Beneh Nechar Lo Takribu Et Lehem Elokechem
Mi’kol Eleh” – that we may not offer such animals as sacrifices even if they
are brought by non-Jews. We might have
thought that although a Jew is not permitted to offer a blemished animal as a
sacrifice, the Kohanim are allowed to accept such an animal sacrifice from a
gentile. Gentiles are permitted to bring
voluntary sacrifices to the Bet Ha’mikdash (“Nedarim” and “Nedabot”), and we
might have assumed that the Torah’s strict standards for our sacrifices,
disqualifying a blemished animal, do not apply to gentiles. The Torah therefore clarified that even when
a gentile offers a sacrifice, it must be unblemished. In order to maintain the people’s sense of
awe and reverence toward the Bet Ha’mikdash and the sacrifices, the Torah
demands that all animals brought as sacrifices – even those offered by gentiles
– must be unblemished.
All
73 physical blemishes which disqualify an animal sacrifice when brought by a
Jew likewise disqualify an animal sacrifice brought by a gentile. A Kohen who offers a blemished animal
sacrifice brought by a gentile is liable to Malkut for transgressing this
prohibition.
This
command brings to mind the famous, tragic story told by the Gemara in Masechet
Gittin (55b-56a) of Bar-Kamsa, who became incensed when he was violently driven
from a party to which he was mistakenly received an invitation. In order to avenge his humiliation, he
schemed to arouse the Roman emperor’s ire at the Jews by falsely reporting to
him that the Jews were planning a revolt.
To verify his charge, Bar-Kamsa advised the emperor to send an animal to
Jerusalem to be offered as a sacrifice in the Bet Ha’mikdash on his
behalf. As the animal was being
transported to Jerusalem, Bar-Kamsa made a blemish in the animal which
disqualified it as a sacrifice according to Torah law, but not according to the
Roman pagan tradition. (The Gemara
brings two opinions – that Bar-Kamsa either slit the animal’s lip, or slit its
eyelid.) The Rabbis debated whether or
not they should offer the animal, as some argued that the animal should be
sacrificed despite the blemish, in order to avoid tensions with the Roman
government. In the end, however, the
decision was made to refuse to offer the sacrifice. The emperor viewed this refusal as compelling
evidence of the Jews’ disloyalty, and this ultimately led to the destruction of
the Bet Ha’mikdash.
The
Maharal of Prague (Rav Yehuda Loew, 1520-1609) raises the question of why the
Jews were not upfront with the emperor, and did not simply explain to him that
they could not offer the sacrifice because it was blemished en route to
Jerusalem. Seemingly, they could have
avoided this problem altogether by explaining the situation, and asking the
emperor to send a new animal which they would happily sacrifice.
The
Maharal answers that there was a more fundamental issue at stake. The Romans insisted that the Bet Ha’mikdash
belonged to everyone equally, to Jews and gentiles alike, all of whom have the
same level of access to the sacred domain.
If the emperor would have heard that the Jews refused to offer his
animal because it had a blemish which disqualified it according to Jewish law,
even though it did not disqualify the animal according to the rules of Roman
paganism, he would have been enraged. In
his mind, he had the same rights in the Bet Ha’mikdash as the Jews, and so an
animal which he deemed suitable should be offered. In truth, the Maharal explains, the gentiles
receive the spiritual benefits of the Bet Ha’mikdash only because of the Jews’
service there, and thus the gentiles’ animal sacrifices must adhere to the same
standards as the Jews’ sacrifices. Telling
this to the emperor would have aroused his ire, and thus the Jews did not have
the option of avoiding tensions by asking the emperor to send a different
animal.
Developing
this point further, the Maharal writes that the gentiles have no authority
whatsoever over the Bet Ha’mikdash, and did not even have the power to destroy
it. As the Gemara (Sanhedrin 96b) states,
“Kimha Tehina Tehinat” – when the Romans destroyed the Bet Ha’mikdash, it was
as if they were grinding finely-ground flour.
The Bet Ha’mikdash was already destroyed because of the Jews’ misdeeds,
specifically, the sin of Sin’at Hinam (baseless hatred among the people). It is not the enemy nations who destroy the
Bet Ha’mikdash, but rather the Jewish People, through their wrongdoing. The gentiles have no connection to the Bet
Ha’mikdash, despite the right they are given to offer sacrifices, and it only
our sins which lead G-d to send them to destroy the Mikdash.