The
Torah in Parashat Mishpatim (Shemot 21:33) addresses the case of a person who
opens a pit in a public area, and an animal falls in and dies. The person who dug the pit is responsible to
compensate the animal’s owner for his financial loss. The Gemara explains that although the person
cannot be said to legally own the pit, as it is situated in the public domain,
nevertheless, the Torah places it under his ownership so that he can be held
responsible to pay. Like the other laws
of damage liability, this Halacha demonstrates the Torah’s demand that we live
with a sense of responsibility to the people around us, and exercise care in
ensuring we do not cause people harm.
This
command is directed at Bet Din, requiring them to rule these cases
appropriately, and hold the guilty party responsible to pay.
A
person who digs a put in a public area is responsible only for the damages
caused to animals who fall into the pit.
He is not responsible if a person falls in, because people are expected
to watch carefully where they walk. If a
person falls into a pit, he is to blame for failing to exercise caution as he
walks, and thus he cannot claim damages from the person who dug the pit. For the same reason, the person who made the
pit is not responsible for damages caused to utensils, which quite obviously do
not travel on their own, but are rather carried by human beings, who are
expected to carefully watch where they walk to avoid harm.
The
person who opened a pit is responsible for damages only if the pit is at least
ten Tefahim (handbreadths) deep, because otherwise, it is not considered
capable of killing an animal who falls inside.
In
certain circumstances, a person is allowed to place something in the public
domain even though it might pose a hazard.
For example, a drain pipe from the roof of a house is allowed to extend
into the public domain, since this serves a necessary purpose. Likewise, when building a home, one is
allowed to keep building materials piled in the public domain near the building
site. Nevertheless, although in these
cases the person is allowed to create a potential hazard, he is responsible to
pay for damages it causes. The Sefer
Ha’hinuch writes that if one needs to erect a foundation around the building
site as he constructs a home, and this foundation extends into the public
domain, then he is not held responsible for damages it causes. Since this is something which people
generally need to do when building, and it is thus necessary for ensuring
sufficient housing, people implicitly waive each other’s responsibility for
damages caused by these structures.