In its
discussion of the laws of the Korban Pesach in the Book of Shemot (12:10), the
Torah commands, “Ve’lo Totiru Mimenu Ad Boker,” forbidding one to leave over
meat of the Korban Pesach until morning.
Meat which was left over must be burned.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that the Korban Pesach celebrates not merely our
nation’s deliverance from slavery, but also our attaining a stature of “Malchut
U’gdula” – “royalty and prestige.” We
must therefore conduct ourselves with regard to this sacrifice like members of
nobility. Wealthy people do not normally
leave food over for the next day; they eat heartily, enjoying everything that
was prepared today, and discard any leftovers, confident that they will have
fresh food prepared the following day.
Thus, the Torah commanded us to eat the Pesach sacrifice like wealthy
noblemen, not leaving anything over, and destroying any meat which is not
eaten.
Whereas
most Misvot Lo Ta’aseh (Torah prohibitions) are punishable with Malkut
(lashes), this prohibition falls into the exceptional category of “Lav Ha’nitak
La’aseh” – a violation which can be “corrected.” As mentioned, the Torah commands that if one
violated this prohibition and left meat of the sacrifice over, the leftover
meat must be burned. There is a
principle that this kind of prohibition, for which the Torah prescribes a
“solution” if it is violated, is not punishable with Malkut. Therefore, one does not receive Malkut for
leaving over meat of the Korban Pesach.
The
Peri Megadim (Rav Yosef Teomim, 1727-1793) raises an interesting question
regarding the status of women vis-à-vis this prohibition, in light of the fact
that this prohibition falls under the category of “Lav Ha’nitak La’aseh.” The Gemara in Masechet Kiddushin (35)
establishes the rule that all Misvot Lo Ta’aseh apply equally to both men and
women. Whereas certain Misvot Aseh
(affirmative commands) apply only to men, Misvot Lo Ta’aseh apply also to
women. The Gemara infers this rule from
a verse in the Book of Bamidbar (5:6) which addresses a situation where “Ish O
Isha Ki Ya’asu Mi’kol Hatot Ha’adam” – “a man or woman commits any of the sins
a person can commit.” The Torah here
equates men and women with regard to sins, thus indicating that they are both
included in Misvot Lo Ta’aseh. The
Gemara’s formulation in establishing this rule is, “Hishva Ha’katub Isha Le’ish
Le’chol Onashim She’ba’Torah” – “The text equates women and men, with regard to
all punishments in the Torah.” Rashi
explains that this refers to Misvot Lo Ta’aseh, which are punishable with
Malkut. This formulation, the Peri
Megadim observes, appears to suggest that women are included only in those
Misvot Lo Ta’aseh which are punishable. When
it comes, however, to the exceptional categories, such as “Lav Ha’nitak
La’aseh,” for which violators are not liable to Malkut, we should perhaps
assume that such prohibitions do not apply to women. And yet, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes
explicitly that women are included in the prohibition against leaving over the
meat of the Korban Pesach – despite its being a “Lav Ha’nitak La’aseh.”
The
Minhat Hinuch addresses this question at length, and his analysis lies beyond
the scope of our discussion.
There
is also another interesting question that arises with regard to the status of
women vis-à-vis this Misva. The command
to burn leftover meat of the Korban Pesach would seem to fall under the
category of “Misvot Aseh She’ha’zman Gerama” – affirmative commands that apply
only at certain times, as it applies only the morning after the sacrifice is
offered. As a rule, women are exempt
from “Misvot Aseh She’ha’zman Gerama,” and thus, it stands to reason that women
are not bound by the Misva to burn leftover meat of the Korban Pesach. The Minhat Hinuch observes that if so, then
as far as women are concerned, the prohibition against leaving over meat of the
sacrifice does not fall under the category of “Lav Ha’nitak La’aseh” – because
for them, there is no Misva to “correct” the violation if meat was left
over. Seemingly, then, we should
conclude that if a woman left over meat of the Korban Pesach, she should be
liable to Malkut, because she violated a prohibition which for her is not
considered a “Lav Ha’nitak La’aseh.”
Once again, the Minhat Hinuch’s analysis lies beyond the scope of our
discussion.