The
Torah commands in Parashat Mishpatim (Shemot 23:18), “Lo Tizbah Al Hametz Dam
Zibhi,” forbidding offering the Pesach sacrifice while one has Hametz in his
possession. The Pesach sacrifice is
offered on the afternoon of the 14th of Nissan, and it is forbidden
to have Hametz in one’s possession while the sacrifice is being offered. The Sefer Ha’hinuch maintains that this
prohibition applies to everyone involved in the sacrifice – including the one
who slaughters the animal, the Kohen who sprinkles the blood on the altar, the
Kohen who places the fats on the altar, and all participating members of this
sacrifice. According to the Sefer
Ha’hinuch, anyone who had registered to be included in a Korban Pesach violates
this prohibition if he or she possesses Hametz at the time the sacrifice is
offered.
The
reason behind this command, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, is because every Misva
has its designated time, and the Misva of the Korban Pesach is to be performed
once one has rid Hametz from his possession.
This sacrifice is, of course, part of the observance of Pesach, when
Hametz is forbidden, and so naturally the Torah expects us to eliminate all
Hametz before proceeding to perform the Korban Pesach.
This
Misva is, quite obviously, applicable only during the times of the Bet
Ha’mikdash, when the Korban Pesach was sacrificed, and it is binding upon both
men and women, as both are included in the obligation of Korban Pesach. The Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that those who
transgress this prohibition are liable to Malkut, though the Minhat Hinuch
raises the question of why this should be the case. If a member of the group who is not involved
in the offering of the sacrifice has Hametz in his possession, he has not
performed any forbidden act. A famous
rule establishes that Malkut are administered only when one violates a Torah
prohibition by committing a forbidden action.
It thus seems difficult to understand why the Sefer Ha’hinuch maintained
that one is liable to Malkut for having Hametz in his possession at the time of
the offering of the Korban Pesach. The
Minhat Hinuch leaves this question unanswered.
Tosafot
in Masechet Pesahim (63) advance a different position, maintaining that only
those who actually perform the rituals associated with the Korban Pesach are
included in this prohibition. According
to Tosafot, this command is directed towards only those who slaughter the
sacrifice, sprinkle its blood, and place its fats on the altar. The members of the group do not violate this
prohibition by having Hametz in their possession at the time of the
offering.
Rav
Leib Malin (1906-1962) explained that this debate between the Sefer Ha’hinuch
and Tosafot reflects a fundamental question regarding the nature of this
prohibition. Namely, is this prohibition
a law relevant to the sacrifice, forbidding offering the Korban Pesach while
possessing Hametz? Or, is this
prohibition part of the laws of Hametz, requiring one to eliminate his Hametz
before the time the Korban Pesach is offered?
Tosafot, apparently, viewed this prohibition as part of the guidelines
regarding the offering of the Korban Pesach, and thus in their view, only those
who offer the sacrifice are bound by this prohibition. The Sefer Ha’hinuch, however, maintained that
this prohibition is part of the laws of Hametz, and thus all people are bound
by this command, and may not have Hametz in their possession when their Korban
Pesach is offered.
These
perspectives likely underlie an interesting question posed by the Minhat Hinuch
as to whether, hypothetically, this prohibition would apply to meat of the
Korban Pesach which is not consumed on the altar until after Pesach. Let us imagine that the sacrifice was placed
on the altar in its proper time, on the 14th of Nissan, but, for
whatever reason, some of the meat was not burned throughout the seven days of
Pesach, and remained on the altar when Pesach ended. Would it be permissible for the person who offered
that sacrifice to take possession of Hametz at that point? The Minhat Hinuch is inclined to say that
even though Pesach has ended, the person would not be permitted to have Hametz
in his possession, since the Korban Pesach is still being burned on the
altar. This view, seemingly, reflects
the perspective viewing this prohibition as part of the laws of the Korban
Pesach, such that as long as the sacrifice is not consumed, one may not own
Hametz, even after Pesach. If, however,
we perceive this prohibition as part of the laws of Hametz, then it clearly
does not apply after Pesach, when Hametz is entirely permissible.