The
Torah commands in Parashat Mishpatim (Shemot 23:32), in reference to the seven
nations which inhabited the Land of Israel (Canaan) at that time, “Lo Tichrot
Lahem Ve’l’Elohehem Berit” – that it is forbidden to make a treaty with these
peoples. The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains
that these nations – who are knowns as the seven nations of Canaan – were the
“Ikar Aboda Zara Ve’yesod Ha’rishon” – the primary “foundation” of idol-worship
in the ancient world. As G-d wants us to
eliminate idolatrous beliefs and practices, so that all of humanity recognizes
Hashem as the single, true G-d, we are commanded not to make peace with the
Canaanite peoples, and to instead eliminate them.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch adds that this command also forbids making a treaty with any idolatrous
people, though a distinction exists in this regard between the seven Canaanite
nations and other pagans. When it comes
to the seven Canaanite nations, we are forbidden from making a treaty with them
even if they do not seek to wage war against us. Since they are, as mentioned, the primary
idolaters, we are not to deal peacefully them even if they are not interested
in conflict. When it comes to other
nations, however, we are permitted to enter into peace treaties with them as
long as they do not seek to engage in conflict.
Proof
to this position may be drawn from the story told in the Book of Yehoshua of
the Gibonim, a tribe that belonged to the seven nations and which approached
Beneh Yisrael disguised as a foreign nation.
Knowing that Beneh Yisrael set out to eliminate the seven nations, the
Gibonim pretended to have originated from a distant land, and asked to make a
treaty with Beneh Yisrael. Even after
discovering that the Gibonim were actually from Eretz Yisrael, the leaders of
Beneh Yisrael nevertheless decided to honor the treaty, and had them work as
woodcutters and water-carriers. The
Rabbis explained that they honored the treaty because if they had killed the
Gibonim after having made a treaty with them, this would have created a Hilul
Hashem (defamation of G-d). Although the
treaty was made under deception, nevertheless, killing the Gibonim would have
given the appearance of breaking an agreement, thus creating a Hilul Hashem. It emerges, then, that if not for the concern
of a Hilul Hashem, Beneh Yisrael would have eliminated the Gibonim, even though
they did not seek hostilities and were interested in peace. This proves that when it comes to the seven
nations – as opposed to other pagan peoples – the prohibition against making a
treaty applies even if these nations are not interested in war.
Even
when it comes to the seven nations, however, if they commit to abandon
idolatry, then we may accept their repentance and make a treaty with them. Indeed, the Midrash (Debarim Rabba) relates
that before Beneh Yisrael waged war against the seven nations, Beneh Yisrael’s
leader – Yehoshua – sent a message to these nations offering them peace in
exchange for their rejection of idolatry.
One
who enters into a peace treaty with one of the seven nations, or a different
pagan nation that is hostile to Beneh Yisrael, violates this prohibition. The violator does not receive Malkut,
however, because this violation does not involve a concrete action.
This
prohibition reflects the broader notion that the Jewish People are charged with
the responsibility of leading the entire world to the recognition of the one,
true G-d. This mission will be fully
accomplished in the times of Mashiah, when, as the famous prophecy foresees,
“Ve’haya Hashem Le’melech Al Kol Ha’aretz, Be’yom Ha’hu Yiheyeh Hashem Ehad
U’shmo Ehad” – “Hashem shall be the King over the entire earth; on that day,
Hashem shall be one and His Name shall be one” (Zecharya 14:9).