In
the beginning of Parashat Tesaveh (Shemot 27:21), the Torah commands that the
Kohanim should arrange the candles of the Menorah in the Bet Ha’mikdash each
day – “Ya’aroch Oto Aharon U’banav…”
Needless
to say, G-d does not need us to provide light for Him; He is the one who
illuminates the entire earth. However,
as the Sefer Ha’hinuch repeatedly emphasizes, the Torah’s commands are given
for our benefit, because of the positive impact and effect that they have upon
us and upon our lives. In this instance,
the Sefer Ha’hinuch explains, we are commanded to light a candelabra in the Bet
Ha’mikdash because people who want to make their homes look beautiful and
majestic ensure that they are well lit. This
was particularly so before electric lighting, when candles and candelabras were
needed throughout the home in order for the home to have a warm, impressive
appearance. The atmosphere in the Bet
Ha’mikdash was intended to instill within those who visited a sense of awe and
reverence for G-d, and thus, as part of the effort to create this atmosphere,
the Torah commanded that lights be kindled there. The illumination contributed to the general
aura which would help motivate and inspire the people to draw closer to G-d.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch adds that this is the reason for the kindling of the Menorah on
the level of Peshat – the simple, straightforward understanding. He concedes that the scholars of Kabbalah are
aware of deeper, more profound explanations behind the significance of this
Misva.
The
lamps of the Menorah were kindled each and every day in the Bet Ha’mikdash (as
opposed to our kindling of the Hanukah lights for eight nights, which commemorates
the Hanukah miracle, not the daily kindling of the Menorah in the Bet
Ha’mikdash). The Torah refers to the
light of the Menorah as a “Ner Tamid” (“constant flame”), indicating that this
Misva overrides the Shabbat prohibitions, and thus the Menorah was lit even on
Shabbat. The word “Tamid” (“constant”)
instructs that the given Misva must be performed even on Shabbat; for example,
the daily sacrifice – “Korban Tamid” – was offered even on Shabbat. By the same token, the Menorah was kindled
even on Shabbat.
Each
lamp of the Menorah needed to be filled with a half-Log of olive oil for the
kindling. The Sages determined that this
was the quantity of oil needed to sustain the flames throughout the night
during the period around the time of the winter solstice, when the nights are
longest, and so this amount was established as the standard quantity of oil
required.
The
Misva to light the Menorah includes also the obligation of “Hataba” – preparing
the Menorah by cleaning the lamps, changing the wicks, and pouring new
oil. The Ner Ha’emsa’i – the middle lamp
– was to always remain lit. If it was
ever extinguished, it would be kindled anew from the fire on the Mizbe’ah
Ha’hison (the altar in the outdoor courtyard of the Bet Ha’mikdash). All the other lamps were lit from this candle;
they had long wicks which were lit from the flame of the middle candle.
The
Rambam controversially maintained that the obligation to kindle the Menorah and
the obligation of Hataba both comprise a single Misva. The vast majority of Rishonim (including
Rashi, the Rashba, the Ramban and the Ra’abad), however, disagreed, and held
that these are two separate Misvot – to prepare the Menorah for lighting, and
then to light it.
The
Rambam also advances another surprising, unique view regarding the kindling of
the Menorah, claiming that this does not need to be performed by a Kohen. The conventional understanding is that the
kindling, just like the other rituals in the Bet Ha’mikdash, must be performed
specifically by a Kohen. Indeed, the
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes explicitly that this Misva is charged upon the
Kohanim. The Rambam, however, in Hilchot
Bi’at Mikdash (9:7), writes that even a “Zar” – somebody who is not a Kohen –
is suitable for the kindling of the Menorah.
He draws proof from the Gemara’s comment in Masechet Yoma (24) that the
lighting of the Menorah does not have the formal status of “Aboda” – a ritual
of the Bet Ha’mikdash. Of course,
non-Kohanim are not permitted to enter the Bet Ha’mikdash, but the Rambam
writes that a Kohen can prepare the Menorah and then bring it outside into the
“Azara” (courtyard), where a non-Kohen may then light the lamps. (The Rambam concedes that the “Hataba” must
be done by a Kohen, because it is only the “Hadlaka” – the kindling – that the
Gemara does not consider an “Aboda.”)
Rav
Haim of Brisk (1853-1918) raised the question of how, according to the Rambam,
the Misva can be fulfilled in this fashion.
If the Menorah is not kindled in its proper place, but rather brought
outside, kindled, and then returned, how is the Misva fulfilled? Should we not assume that the Menorah needs
to be kindled in its proper location?
Rav
Haim answers this question by positing that according to the Rambam, the Misva
is defined not as an obligation to light the Menorah, but rather as an
obligation to see to it that the Menorah is lit. The Misva – even in the Rambam’s view – is
charged upon the Kohanim, but the Misva is to ensure the Menorah is lit, and
not the act of kindling. Therefore, the
Kohanim can fulfill the Misva by bringing the Menorah out into the “Azara,” having
a non-Kohen light it there, and then returning it to its place inside the Bet
Ha’mikdash.