The
Torah in Parashat Re’eh discusses the case of an Ir Ha’nidahat – a city whose
inhabitants were led to worship foreign gods – and it commands that the entire city
must be burned, together with all its property (Debarim 13:17). The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that the Torah
treats this situation with greater severity than an ordinary case of
individuals who worship foreign deities, because it is far more grievous when a
city’s population worships other gods all together, collectively. Therefore, the entire city must be burned.
For
a city to be formally condemned as an “Ir Ha’nidahat,” at least two people from
the city, who belong to the same tribe, must succeed in convincing the majority
of the city’s population to worship a foreign deity. Those lured to foreign worship must number at
least 100 people, but they must not comprise the majority of one of the
tribes. If the majority of a tribe was
led to foreign worship, then they are judged not as an “Ir Ha’nidahat,” but
rather as individuals. They are executed
by Sekila (stoning), and their property is not burned, but rather given to
their inheritors.
This
command is assigned to the Sanhedrin, who bears the obligation to carry out
this punishment against the city. Of
course, this Misva applies only in times when there is a Sanhedrin. If the judges are delinquent in this regard,
and fail to carry out their responsibilities vis-à-vis an “Ir Ha’nidahat,” then
they transgress this affirmative command.
The Sefer Ha’hinuch warns that they will be severely punished, because
by failing to properly respond to the city’s worship of foreign gods, they
cause a proliferation of idol worship in the Land of Israel.
In
this same verse, the Torah issues an additional command, forbidding rebuilding
an “Ir Ha’nidahat” after it is burned – “Lo Tibaneh Od.” It is permissible to plant gardens and
orchards on the site of the city, but it may not be made into a residential
area like it had been previously. This
Misva, naturally, applies only in the times of the Sanhedrin, when the
obligation to burn an “Ir Ha’nidahat” applies.
This command is binding upon both men and women.
The
Torah then commands in the next verse, “Ve’lo Yidbak Be’yadecha Me’uma Min
Ha’herem” – that nothing from the property of the “Ir Ha’nidahat” may “stick to
your hand.” The Sages explained this to
mean that it is forbidden to derive any sort of benefit from this property. Beyond the obligation to burn the city’s
possessions, it is also forbidden to derive any benefit from them.