The
Torah commands in Parashat Re’eh (Debarim 14:1), “Lo Titgodedu,” forbidding
making gashes in one’s skin, which the ancient pagans would do as an expression
of grief upon the death of a loved one. This
verse forbids following this practice; we are prohibited from performing acts
of self-mutilation to mimic the custom of the ancient pagan, or as an
expression of mourning.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch presents two explanations for this command. First, he writes, it is meant to distance us
from idol worship; the Torah forbids us from doing anything which bears
resemblance to pagan practices as part of the effort to keep us away from
idolatrous influences. Additionally, the
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, it is unfitting for Am Yisrael, G-d’s treasured nation,
to act in such a foolish way, excessively grieving over personal loss. We must remember that everything that happens
is caused by Hashem, and we are thus forbidden to express anguish beyond the
limits set by the Torah. If a person
mutilates his body in response to a loved one’s death, this displays a lack of
faith in Hashem. Indeed, the Ramban, as
the Sefer Ha’hinuch cites, points to this command as the source for the
Talmud’s statement that it is forbidden to excessively mourn the death of a
loved one. Halacha acknowledges the
human need to mourn, and even commands a person to mourn a family member’s
death, but it is forbidden to extend beyond that which the Torah prescribes.
A
person who gashes his skin is liable for each gash he makes; if he is warned
before each gash, then he receives a separate set of Malkut for each act of
self-mutilation. Interestingly enough, a
person who gashes his skin once as an expression of mourning for five people
who passed away is liable to five sets of Malkut. Although he committed only one forbidden act,
nevertheless, since this act was performed to express grief over five deaths, the
violator is guilty of five separate violations, and is thus liable to five sets
of Malkut. This prohibition marks an
exceptional situation where a person can be liable to multiple punishments for
a single act.
The
Rabbis also taught an additional understanding of the command of “Lo
Titgodedu.” As the Rambam discusses in
Hilchot Aboda Zara (12:14), this verse commands, “Lo Ta’asu Agudot Agudot” –
that we may not create different groups.
If two courts are situated in the same city, they may not reach
different views, as this will create strife and conflict. The Sefer Ha’hinuch qualifies this rule,
clarifying that two equally competent courts in the same city may hold
different opinions, and it is only within a single institution that Halacha
requires groups that disagree to reconcile their differences and reach a
unanimous decision in order to avoid quarreling and unrest.
The
prohibition of “Lo Titgodedu” applies in all times and places, and is binding
upon both men and women. One who
mutilated his or her body to imitate pagan practice, or as an expression of
mourning, is in violation of this command, and, as discussed, is liable to
Malkut.
In
this same verse, the Torah adds a related command – “Ve’lo Tasimu Korha Ben
Enechem La’met,” forbidding pulling out one’s hair, as this, too, was a pagan
expression of grief and mourning. If one
pulls out his hair to mimic pagan ritual, or to express grief, he violates this
command.
As
in regard to violations of “Lo Titgodedu,” one can be liable to five sets of
Malkut through a single act, if he removes his hair in mourning for five
different deaths. Likewise, if a person
removed hair five times over a single death, then if he received a warning
before each act, he is liable to five sets of Malkut.
One
violates this command by removing his hair with his hand, or even with a depilatory. The Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that if a person
dips five fingers into a depilatory, and then places his hand on his head,
causing the removal of hair in five places on his head, he is liable to five
sets of Malkut. Even though he performed
just a single action, Halacha in this case considers the violator guilty of
five separate violations, for each of which he is liable to punishment.
As
discussed in the context of “Lo Titgodedu,” the Torah forbids grieving
excessively over personal loss, as we are to temper our pain and anguish with
Emuna, firmly believing that everything that happens is Hashem’s will, and He
is always caring for us and doing what is ultimately best for us, even when we
cannot understand how.