The Mishna in Pirkeh
Abot (1:6) famously instructs, "Aseh Lecha Rav U'kneh Lecha Haber" – literally,
"Make for yourself a Rabbi, and 'purchase' for yourself a friend." This is commonly understood to mean that that
as important as it is to have a Rabbi, it is even more important to have a friend,
and one should therefore go so far as to "purchase" a friend if necessary.
The Hida (Rav Haim
Yosef David Azulai, 1724-1806), however, added a different interpretation,
explaining "U'kneh Lecha Haber" to mean that the quill – "Kaneh" – should be
one's "friend." One should make sure to
learn from a knowledgeable Rabbi – and he should also grow accustomed to writing
the Torah he learns as much as possible.
There is immense value in writing the Torah that one studies, as this
helps him retain the material and also preserves it.
The question arises as
to whether one who wishes to write words of Torah in the morning must first
recite Birkot Ha'Torah. Halacha requires
reciting Birkot Ha'Torah before learning Torah in the morning, but (as we saw
in a previous installment) a distinction exists between silently thinking about
Torah and speaking words of Torah.
Birkot Ha'Torah is required in the morning before verbally speaking
words of Torah, but not – according to the consensus opinion – before silently
thinking words of Torah. At first
glance, we would assume that silently writing Torah material is no different
from silently thinking about Torah, and thus this may be done before reciting
Birkot Ha'Torah in the morning.
Interestingly,
however, the Shulhan Aruch distinguishes between thinking about Torah in one's
mind and writing Torah. When it comes to
thinking about Torah, the Shulhan Aruch follows the view of the Agur (Rav
Yaakob Landau, 1410-1493) that silent Torah thoughts do not require Birkot
Ha'Torah. However, the Shulhan Aruch
rules that writing Torah indeed requires the recitation of the Birkot Ha'Torah. This is based on the position of the
Abudarham (Rav David Abudarham, Spain, 14th century) which Rav Yosef
Karo – author of the Shulhan Aruch – brings in his Bet Yosef.
Importantly, however,
Rav Yosef Karo wrote a collection of notes to the Bet Yosef called Bedek
Ha'bayit, in which he corrects or amends certain passages in the Bet
Yosef. And in the Bedek Ha'bayit,
commenting on his citation of the Abudarham's ruling concerning one who writes
Torah, Rav Yosef Karo remarks: "See the words of the Agur" – a clear reference
to the aforementioned ruling of the Agur that Birkot Ha'Torah is not required
before thinking about Torah. It thus
appears that the Bet Yosef retracted his opinion, and concluded that one does
not, in fact, need to recite Birkot Ha'Torah before writing Torah.
The question then
becomes, what was Rav Yosef Karo's final ruling? In the Bet Yosef, he seems to have concluded
that writing Torah does not require Birkot Ha'Torah, but in the Shulhan Aruch,
he wrote that it does.
The Poskim dispute the
question of whether the Rav Yosef Karo wrote the Shulhan Aruch before or after
he wrote his emendations to the Bet Yosef.
Therefore, it is unclear which ruling reflects his final position – his
ruling in Bedek Ha'bayit, or his ruling in the Shulhan Aruch.
If we follow the
Shulhan Aruch's ruling, which distinguishes between thinking about Torah and
writing Torah, what's the rationale behind this distinction? Why would thinking about Torah not require
Birkot Ha'Torah, but writing Torah would?
Later commentators
offered several explanations. One
approach is that the obligation of Torah study is inherently linked to the
obligation to teach Torah. Therefore,
Birkot Ha'Torah – the blessing over the Misva to learn Torah – is recited only
upon a kind of learning which could also facilitate the teaching of Torah. As Torah can be taught through speech and
through the written word, these two forms of Torah learning require Birkot
Ha'Torah, whereas silently thinking about Torah, which of course is not a way
in which Torah can be disseminated, does not.
Others explain that
one must learn Torah with the goal of remembering the material. Therefore, the Beracha is recited only when
one speaks or writes Torah, as one is more likely to remember material which he
verbalizes or writes than material which he simply thinks in his mind.
The Lebush (Rav Mordechai
Yoffe, 1530-1612) answers, very simply, that writing, as opposed to thinking,
is an action, and a Beracha is recited only before a Misva act.
Finally, the Hayeh
Adam (Rav Abraham Danzig, Vilna, 1748-1820) explains that people often tend to
say the words as they write, and therefore Halacha requires reciting Birkot
Ha'Torah before writing, given the likelihood that he will end up speaking
words of Torah.
As for the final
Halacha, the Mishna Berura cites several Poskim who rule that due to the
uncertainty surrounding this question, one who wishes to write Torah must first
recite Birkot Ha'Torah and then recite verses from the Torah before proceeding
to write. This is the ruling of Hacham
Ovadia Yosef, as well. Verbally reading
verses before writing satisfies all opinions and thus avoids this Halachic
uncertainty. (Rabbi Yisrael Bitan notes
that in one work, Hacham Ovadia is cited as ruling that a person in this
situation must recite Birkot Ha'Torah and should then "preferably" recite
verses before writing – indicating that this is a preference, but not a requirement. However, Rabbi Bitan shows that this is an
inaccurate representation of Hacham Ovadia's position, as in truth he
maintained that one must first verbally read verses in order to satisfy all
opinions.)
This Halacha applies
also to a Sofer who wishes to do some work – writing a Sefer Torah, Tefillin or
Mezuza – in the morning. Some Poskim
maintained that since a Sofer merely copies the Torah text, and is not actually
learning Torah, Birkot Ha'Torah is not required before such work. However, due to the different opinions that
exist, a Sofer should ensure to recite Birkot Ha'Torah and then verbally read
verses before writing. This applies also
to somebody who is typing Torah material from a handwritten text, without any
intention to learn as he types. Although
one could argue that this does not qualify as Torah learning, nevertheless,
given the uncertainty, the typist should first recite Birkot Ha'Torah, verbally
read some verses, and then proceed to the typing.
Summary: One who
wishes to write Torah insights, commentaries, etc. in the morning should first
recite Birkot Ha'Torah and then verbally read some Torah text before writing,
in order to satisfy all opinions. This
applies also to a Sofer – he should recite Birkot Ha'Torah and then verbally
read some verses before writing in the morning.