Generally, when a person wakes up in the morning, he needs
to relieve himself. The question thus
arises as to when he should perform the morning Netilat Yadayim – before using
the restroom, or afterward. On the one
hand, we might assume that he must wash his hands first, because it is
forbidden to touch the openings of one's body before washing Netilat Yadayim,
and one is likely to touch an opening when cleaning himself. On the other hand, before drying one's hands,
he must recite the Beracha of "Al Netilat Yadayim," and it is forbidden to
recite a Beracha when one feels an urge to relieve himself. Which, then, is the correct sequence?
The Mishna Berura suggests resolving this dilemma by washing
one's hands twice. One washes the first
time immediately after waking up, without reciting a Beracha, and then relieves
himself. After using the restroom, he
washes a second time, and recites the Beracha over this second washing. This allows a person to wash his hands before
using the restroom while reciting the Beracha after relieving himself. This is the ruling also of the Ben Ish Hai
(Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909).
However, Hacham David Yosef, in Halacha Berura, questions
this practice, noting the view of the Rambam that one must recite the Beracha
of "Al Netilat Yadayim" when washing to fulfill the Misva of the morning
hand-washing, and not after. When one
washes the first time, he fulfills the Misva, and he thus can no longer recite
the Beracha according to the Rambam. Now
the Mishna Berura likely relied on the view taken by several Ashkenazic Poskim
allowing one to recite the Beracha of "Al Netilat Yadayim" after washing and
drying his hands. We, however, do not
follow this opinion. Seemingly, then,
the practice advocated by the Mishna Berura and the Ben Ish Hai is not an
acceptable option for us.
Rav Yisrael Bitan offers two approaches to defend this
practice. First, the Rambam himself
maintains that one must wash with a Beracha before each of the daily
prayers. Therefore, when one washes a
second time after using the restroom, even the Rambam would require reciting a
Beracha, because the person had dirtied his hands and must therefore wash them
in preparation for the Shaharit prayer – and, according to the Rambam, this
washing requires a Beracha. Therefore,
according to all opinions – even the Rambam – a Beracha may be recited over the
second washing.
Secondly, Rav Bitan writes, when one follows the procedure
suggested by the Mishna Berura, he does not intend to fulfill the Misva with
his initial washing. He washes the first
time only to remove the impurity from his hands so he can clean himself without
concern; he does not intend to fulfill the obligation at this point. It is only at the time of the second washing,
after leaving the restroom, that the person wishes to fulfill the Misva, and so
he may recite the Beracha over this second washing.
The Halacha Berura and Yalkut Yosef also raise the question
of "Bal Teshakesu" – the prohibition against postponing relieving oneself. They write that if someone wakes up with an
urgent need to use the restroom, then he may not first wash Netilat Yadayim, as
he would then be delaying the performing of his bodily functions. Rav Bitan, however, disagrees, explaining
that such a brief delay – the few moments needed to wash Netilat Yadayim – does
not violate the prohibition of "Bal Teshakesu."
Another option, as discussed by the Yalkut Yosef, is to
first use the restroom and ensure not to touch one's openings, as he has yet to
perform Netilat Yadayim. He may then
leave the restroom to perform Netilat Yadayim.
If the sink is in the restroom, he may wash there and bring the towel
outside to recite the Beracha, though in such a case it is preferable to
perform Netilat Yadayim somewhere else, outside the restroom. (In a later installment, we will discuss in
greater depth the subject of where one should perform Netilat Yadayim.) If one went to sleep after halachic midnight,
then there is a basis to permit touching the openings to the body, as discussed
in a precious installment (based on the Kabbalistic teaching that the impurity
descends upon the hands only if one was sleeping at the moment of Halachic
midnight).
There is also a third option, which was told to me in the
name of Raav Shmuel Pinhasi, and that is to first wash one's hands without a
cup in order to "weaken" the impurity.
According to some sources, although formal Netilat Yadayim – pouring
three times from a cup on each hand – is needed to eliminate the impurity,
normal washing has the effect of diminishing its strength, such that it can no
longer be transferred and cause harm.
(Thus, for example, as discussed in a previous installment, there is
room to allow eating food that was touched by a Jew who did not wash Netilat
Yadayim, because his normal hand-washing weakened the impurity such that it
cannot be transferred to food.) This
washing – running each hand under running water three times – allows a person
to use the restroom without concern. But
since he did not use a utensil, he did not yet fulfill the obligation of
Netilat Yadayim, and so he may wash a second time, with a utensil, after using
the restroom, and recite a Beracha.
If a person wakes up in the middle of the night to use the
restroom, and plans to immediately go back to sleep, he should wash his hands
normally, for cleanliness purposes, without reciting the Beracha of "Al Netilat
Yadayim." He then recites "Asher Yasar."
According to Sephardic practice, one who does not need to
relieve himself in the morning does not recite "Asher Yasar."
Summary: When one wakes up in the morning and needs to use
the restroom, he may wash Netilat Yadayim before using the restroom, without
reciting a Beracha, and then repeat Netilat Yadayim with a Beracha after using
the restroom. Alternatively, he may use
the restroom first, before washing Netilat Yadayim, and exercise care to ensure
he does not touch his openings when cleaning himself. If he had gone to sleep after Halachic
midnight, he does not need to avoid touching his openings. A third option is to first run each hand
under running water three times without a utensil, use the restroom, and then
wash with a utensil and recite a Beracha over that second washing.