Should Tefillin Be Worn During a Berit Mila—and Do All
Attendees Share in the Misva?
A Berit Mila is one
of the holiest events in Jewish life, symbolizing the covenant between Hashem
and Am Yisrael. Tefillin, too, are a sign of this covenant. So when a Berit
Mila takes place during or after Shaharit, should one continue wearing Tefillin
for the ceremony? And is the Misva of the Berit shared by all who are present?
Are Tefillin and Berit Mila Connected?
Yes. Both Tefillin
and Berit Mila are called an "Ot"—a sign of the Jewish people's bond
with Hashem:
- Berit Mila is the physical covenant, marked on the body.
- Tefillin are a daily reaffirmation of that covenant, worn on the body as a
public declaration.
The Zohar teaches
that these "signs" complement each other, and the greater the combination of
"Otot" present, the stronger the spiritual impact.
Should One Keep Tefillin On During the Berit?
Yes—ideally, a
person should keep his Tefillin on during the entire Berit Mila ceremony,
even if it takes place after Shaharit has ended. This applies even if
the Berit occurs after Musaf on a weekday or Rosh Hodesh (more on that
in the next Halacha).
Keeping the Tefillin
on during the Berit adds to the holiness of the moment. Many great Rabbis,
including Hacham Ben Zion Abba Shaul, would be careful not to remove their
Tefillin until the Berit was completed.
Exception: If it is extremely
late and the person must go to work or is in discomfort, he may remove them
after Tefilla—but if possible, it is praiseworthy to wait.
Does Every Attendee Share in the Misva?
Absolutely.
According to many Rishonim and Aharonim:
- The Misva is
not only on the father and Mohel.
- All those
present—men standing respectfully and celebrating the
moment—are rewarded for participating in the Misva.
- Rav Hida writes that being
present for a Berit Mila is like joining in a public Kiddush Hashem.
Therefore, remaining
in Tefillin and treating the Berit with reverence—even as a bystander—brings
spiritual reward.
Extra Care During the Ceremony
Because the Tefillin
are on during the Berit:
- One should avoid casual chatter.
- Try to stand respectfully and
listen to the Berachot.
- If possible, recite verses of
Torah quietly or say Tehillim until the ceremony concludes.
Summary:
- Tefillin should remain on during
a Berit Mila whenever possible—even after Shaharit.
- All those present share in the
Misva—not just the father or Mohel.
- Wearing Tefillin during the
ceremony enhances its holiness and connects the covenant of the body
(Berit) with the covenant of the mind and heart (Tefillin).