One of morning
blessings we are required to recite each day is "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" – "who
Has made for me all that I need." This
Beracha expresses gratitude for the ability to wear shoes, as it is only
because we have shoes that we can go about and do all that we need to do.
On a personal note, I
gained greater appreciation for this Beracha after a bizarre experience I had
during a trip to Mexico City. I was
invited by the Syrian-Jewish community there to come as a guest speaker, and I stayed
in a hotel. In the hotel room, I noticed
that the hotel offered a shoe-polishing service, whereby the guest gives in his
shoes before going to sleep, and they are placed outside his door
freshly-polished the next morning. I
gave in my shoes, but the next morning, after I got dressed, they were not by
my door. I had no choice but to go down
the lobby – where the leaders of the community were meeting me to bring me to
the synagogue – without my shoes. I
explained to them what happened, and we spoke to the hotel staff. They brought me to the room where the shoes
are kept, and I had to rummage through piles of shoes for quite some time until
I found mine.
That morning, I
understood the significance of this Beracha that we recite each morning –
"She'asa Li Kol Sorki." We tend to take
it for granted that we can put on shoes every morning, but this is, in truth, a
wonderful gift that we must appreciate.
This message applies
as well to the Beracha of "Malbish Arumim" which we recite each morning to
thank Hashem for having clothing. This
blessing, too, should never be taken for granted. Every so often it happens that a fire breaks
out in a home or building during the night, forcing the residents to go outside
in their bathrobes, as all their clothing goes up in flames. We must always appreciate the fact that
Hashem provides us with clothing and shoes to wear each and every day.
Grammatically, the
word "She'asa" in the phrase "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" should be pronounced with
the emphasis on the second syllable: "She-A-sa."
This Beracha is unique
in that it is formulated in the past tense – "She'asa" ("who has made"), as
opposed to the present tense – "Ha'oseh" ("who makes"). The reason why this Beracha is formulated in
the present tense might be that people sometimes recognize how Hashem has
fulfilled their needs only in retrospect, after the fact. Often, things happen in life that make us
feel that Hashem is specifically not fulfilling our needs, that He is ignoring
us, or withholding our necessities from us.
For example, when a person loses his job, or when his business takes a
downturn, he might not recognize how "Oseh Lo Kol Sorki," that G-d is currently
taking care of him. But later, when he
finds a better job, or when he finds a different business opportunity, he
realizes that everything was for the best, and that Hashem was always doing
what was best for Him. Therefore, it is
only afterward when we can look back and say, "She'asa Li Kol Sorki,"
recognizing in hindsight that Hashem was caring for us all along, even when it
seemed like He wasn't.
Our custom is to
recite the Beracha of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" after the Beracha of "Ha'mechin
Mis'adeh Gaber" (as opposed the custom to reverse the order). Furthermore, we pronounce the final word of
this blessing "Sorki," and not "Sorkai."
There are two days on
the Jewish calendar – Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur – when Halacha forbids wearing
regular shoes. The Ben Ish Hai (Rav
Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909), in Parashat Vayesheb, thus writes that the Beracha
of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" is not recited on these days. Since this Beracha expresses gratitude for
the ability to wear shoes, it is omitted on days when wearing shoes is
forbidden. Citing the Sha'ar Ha'kavanot,
the Ben Ish Hai explains that although the Arizal taught that there are deep
mystical concepts underlying the morning blessings, and their meaning thus
extends beyond the actual phenomena which they mention, nevertheless, this is
relevant only when other Jews benefit these phenomena. If a person himself does not benefit from a
certain phenomenon mentioned by one of the Birkot Ha'shahar, he nevertheless
recites that Beracha because others are benefitting. On Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur, however, nobody
is allowed to wear shoes, and so the Beracha of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" cannot
be recited.
Hacham Ovadia Yosef,
in a responsum in Yabia Omer, questions this ruling of the Ben Ish Hai,
presenting several reasons why this Beracha should be recited even on days when
wearing shoes is forbidden. Firstly,
Halacha permits wearing shoes on Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur to protect against
potential harm, such as if there may be scorpions on the ground where one
walks. Therefore, we indeed benefit from
the protection provided by shoes even on Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur. Secondly, we recite Birkot Ha'shahar to thank
Hashem for "Minhago Shel Olam" – the natural order which He created that allows
us to live and function, irrespective of whether we actually benefit from these
phenomena on a particular day.
Therefore, even on days when we do not wear shoes, we should thank
Hashem for the blessing of shoes from which people normally benefit. Another argument is that Halacha does not
forbid all shoes on Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur, only those made from
leather. Therefore, there is reason to
recite the Beracha of "She'asa Lo Kol Sorki" even on these days. Additionally, at night, after the conclusion
of Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur, we are permitted to wear shoes, and as Birkot
Ha'shahar are recited only in the morning, they clearly cover the entire day
and also the following night. Hence,
even if we would understand Birkot Ha'shahar as expressing gratitude for the
benefit we receive, we should still recite "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" on Yom Kippur
and Tisha B'Ab, because we can wear shoes at night. (The Gaon of Vilna had the practice of
reciting "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" when he put on his shoes upon the conclusion of
Yom Kippur. We, however, follow the view
that Birkot Ha'shahar can be recited only during the day, and the Beracha
covers the rest of the day and the following night.) Finally, whereas the Arizal maintained that
Birkot Ha'shahar thank Hashem specifically for the blessings that He grants us,
the Jewish Nation, others, including Rabbenu Nissim, felt that these Berachot
refer to the natural order that benefits all mankind. Hence, even though Jews do not wear shoes on
Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur, the Beracha of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" should perhaps
be recited since gentiles benefit from shoes on these days.
Indeed, Rav Yosef Karo
(author of the Shulhan Aruch, 1488-1575), in one of his published responsa (Abkat
Rochel, 54), writes explicitly that the accepted custom is to recite the
Beracha of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" even on Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur, and
emphasizes that this custom should be followed.
Accordingly, Hacham
Ovadia Yosef ruled that if somebody asks whether or not to recite this Beracha
on Tisha B'Ab and Yom Kippur, he should be told not to recite it, given the
different views that exist. If, however,
a person does recite the Beracha, he should not be corrected, because this
practice has strong Halachic basis. This
ruling of Hacham Ovadia appears in the first edition of Yalkut Yosef (p.
55). But in a later work – Halichot Olam
(vol. 1, p. 53) – the Hacham changed his position, and ruled that the Beracha
of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" should be recited on Yom Kippur and Tisha B'Ab. This was his final ruling, and this is the
Halacha that should be followed. Hacham
Ovadia's son, Hacham David Yosef, writes in Halacha Berura that his father
would make a point of wearing his regular leather shoes at night after Tisha
B'Ab and Yom Kippur, in order to strengthen the case for reciting the Beracha
of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" on these days.
It goes without saying
that a mourner, Heaven forbid, recites "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" even though he
does not wear regular shoes, since everybody else is wearing shoes.
Summary: The Beracha
of "She'asa Li Kol Sorki" – which thanks Hashem for the gift of shoes – should
be recited after the Beracha of "Ha'mechin Mis'adeh Gaber." The emphasis in the word "She'asa" should be
on the second syllable ("She-A-sa"). We
pronounce the final word "Sorki," and not "Sorkai." The Beracha should be recited even on days
when shoes are not worn – during mourning, on Tisha B'Ab, and on Yom Kippur.