Each morning, before
the Korbanot section, we recite a prayer ("Ribon Ha'olamim") in which we
acknowledge our lowliness, recognizing that we are unworthy of G-d's kindness,
and that even the most powerful are weak in relation to G-d and even the wisest
are ignorant in relation to G-d. In this
prayer, we humbly confess, "Ki Chol Ma'asenu Tohu" – "for all our actions are
worthless."
The obvious question
arises as to how we can make such a pronouncement. After all, while we must all acknowledge that
we are far from perfect, is it true that "all our actions are worthless"? We spend time praying, learning Torah, and
performing acts of kindness for others, we give charity, and we do numerous worthwhile
things throughout the day, every day. We
of course all have much room for improvement, and, unfortunately, we are all
guilty of wasting time on vanity, but it certainly seems exaggerated to claim
that nothing we do has any value.
Due to this question,
there were some Poskim who changed the text of the phrase – replacing the word
"Kol" ("all") with the word "Rob" ("most").
With this emendation, the text acknowledges that most of our actions are
valueless, as we pursue vanity, but not that we never involve ourselves in
meaningful activities such as prayer, Misvot and Torah study.
However, the word
"Kol" appears in all the texts that we have from earlier generations –
including the text of the Rambam, Rav Amram Gaon, the Tur, and the
Abudarham. Therefore, it seems very
difficult to emend the text and change "Kol" to "Rob."
The explanation, as
Rav Yisrael Bitan discusses, likely stems from a comment of the Midrash (Vayikra
Rabba 28:1) interpreting the verse in Kohelet (1:3), "Ma Yitron La'adam Be'chol
Amalo" – "What does a person gain from all his toil?" The Midrash notes that certainly, there is
much gained from a person's toil in Torah study, but Kohelet speaks of "Amalo"
– a person's own "toil," meaning, that which he does for himself, for his own
enjoyment and satisfaction. The "toil"
that a person engages in for G-d, so-to-speak – his efforts in Torah and Misvot
– are certainly precious and immensely valuable. It is only "Amalo" – his self-serving
pursuits – that offer him no benefit. Likewise,
we may explain the phrase "Ki Chol Ma'asenu Tohu" to mean that "Ma'asenu" –
everything we do for ourselves, and not for the service of Hashem – has no
value or significance. Therefore, we
should not change the text to "Rob," and should instead maintain the text found
in earlier sources – "Ki Chol Ma'asenu Tohu."