A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Can someone who prayed Arbit of Shabbat answer the Kedusha of Minha?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
December 30, 2025
Duration
3:04
Lecture code
RGK-1717

Joining a Mincha Minyan After the Early Minyan

  • When one minyan prays early Friday night and another prays at the regular time, someone who has not yet prayed Mincha cannot answer Barechu to the early minyan: by doing so, he accepts Shabbat and can no longer pray Mincha.
  • If the later minyan has nine people for Mincha, the question is whether someone from the early minyan, who has already prayed Arvit and accepted Shabbat, may join as the tenth.
  • Ideally, he should not be part of that minyan; the minyan should find someone else. If he is the only option, however, he can complete it.

Answering Kedusha After Arvit

  • The question also arises when someone leaving the early minyan hears Kedusha from a Mincha service and wonders whether he may answer.
  • Rav Shlomo Kluger rules that he may not answer, even on a weekday, because after finishing Arvit he is already in a different dimension.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says this is incorrect. He cites Terumat HaDeshen: the only possible concern is zilzul to Shabbat, diminishing Shabbat’s honor by answering after entering Shabbat mode. That concern does not apply on a weekday.
  • Rabbi Koskas says that even on Friday night, at the end of the day, one may answer Kedusha. Some disagree, but he says this is the halacha lemaaseh and is what they do.

Answering Keter While Wearing Tefillin

  • On Rosh Chodesh, some people think they cannot answer Keter of Musaf while still wearing tefillin. Rabbi Koskas says this is incorrect: they should answer Keter even while wearing tefillin.

Hacham Ovadia’s Ruling

  • Hacham Ovadia says that lechatchila, someone who has already prayed Arvit should not serve as the tenth person in a Mincha minyan.
  • Someone who comes to complete the minyan can be counted.