A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Hilchot Birchat Cohanim - If someone says “Kohanim” in a Ashkenaz minyan

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
July 1, 2025
Duration
4:52
Lecture code
RGK-BC-27

A Sephardi Kohen in an Ashkenaz Minyan

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas raises whether a Sephardi Kohen praying in an Ashkenaz Minyan, where Birkat Kohanim is not performed, must leave at the time of the blessing. The Pri Megadim holds that he has a chiyuv to go up even if they did not call “Kohanim” (“lo karu lo Kohanim”); according to the majority of poskim, he violates that obligation only if he is invited to go up.
  • Rabbi Koskas cites the wording of the Shulchan Aruch, based on two Rishonim and a Machloket between them, as saying that the Kohen must leave; the question is when.
  • There is also a concern about how his absence or presence may look to others. They might suspect that he is not a valid Kohen—for example, wonder if he became a chalal overnight.

When a Kohen Cannot Give Birkat Kohanim

  • The discussion also covers Kohanim who do not want to go up or cannot give Birkat Kohanim. They do not have to wait outside during the blessing merely for that reason; the obligation to leave relates to the moment the Chazan says “Kohanim,” so that a Kohen does not remain when he is obligated to go up.
  • The Shulchan Aruch’s wording, as Rabbi Koskas explains it, identifies the halachic problem as being present when “Kohanim” is called and not going up. If no one calls “Kohanim,” there is technically no such problem.
  • In an Ashkenaz Minyan, where they do not call “Kohanim” and proceed directly to “Eloheinu v’Elohei avoteinu, barecheinu baberacha,” the Kohen does not have to leave on that halachic basis. Still, people might wonder why he is not giving the blessing and suspect a problem with his kehuna.
  • In a Sephardic Minyan, a Kohen who cannot give Birkat Kohanim leaves when “Kohanim” is called. Halachically, he does not need to remain outside for the entire blessing. However, there is a minhag not to enter the beit haknesset until Birkat Kohanim has concluded, to avoid suspicion—for instance, that something has affected his status as a Kohen, such as marrying a divorcee.

If Someone Calls “Kohanim” in an Ashkenaz Minyan

  • Rabbi Koskas considers the case of someone in an Ashkenaz Minyan calling out “Kohanim b’chavod” despite that not being the community’s practice, perhaps to tease a Kohen. The question is whether that person has authority to call them.
  • The Mishneh Halachot says that the Kohen has no chiyuv in this situation: the person calling has not been appointed by the tzibbur, and if it is not the minhag of the place, there is no obligation. On this view, even if the Shaliach Tzibur mistakenly says “Kohanim,” it makes no difference when the tzibbur does not follow that practice.
  • The Maharsham holds that once anyone calls “Kohanim,” the Kohen is chayav la’alot. Rabbi Koskas notes that some places have a minhag not to do this, while others do it only on Shabbat, and says this will be discussed later.
  • The Kohen is left with a safek among the poskim about what to do, including a doubt about whether not going up would be an issur de’oraita. Rabbi Koskas warns that this is not a harmless prank.