A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

If someone ate Kazayit of olives before Hamosi

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
January 19, 2023
Duration
5:07
Lecture code
RGK-768

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We spoke yesterday about people who eat between Kiddush and the Hamotzi (blessing over bread), and we saw the different shita (approach) on this. Assuming that somebody does, you probably know there is a big problem in halacha (Jewish law) if somebody ate a kezayit (olive-sized portion) between Kiddush and Hamotzi: are you supposed to say Beracha Acharona (after-blessing) on what somebody ate? After Kiddush, they start eating a couple of olives before the Hamotzi. Let’s say they ate three or four olives, so now they have a kezayit. Oh my gosh, I didn't realize it was so good, these olives. Mmm. Does he have to say Beracha Acharona before he does netilat yadayim (ritual handwashing) and Hamotzi, or not? It’s a big machloket (dispute) among the Rishonim (early rabbinic authorities). Big machloket.

Rabbeinu Zerachya Halevi, the Baal HaMaor, one of the earliest Rishonim, says that Birkat Hamazon has this bulldozer power to include everything with it. You’re going to say Birkat Hamazon on the seudah (meal); that is going to cover everything that happened before that, because it’s not in this bracket that starts with the bread and ends with Birkat Hamazon. Obviously, anything that is in the middle of the day is included in Birkat Hamazon, that’s for sure. But something that happened prior to eating the Hamotzi—why would that be part of this? No, Birkat Hamazon is going to include everything.

Now, it’s not so clear, because that would be post facto if you already started eating bread and said, “Hey, my Birkat Hamazon is going to take care of everything.” You’re going to start eating bread and say, “Do I have to say Beracha Acharona or not?” It seems that the fact that you know you're going to start the seudah immediately, you are included in that, and you don't say Beracha Acharona. That’s the opinion of Rabbeinu Zerachya Halevi.

The Ramban and the Rashba disagree. They say, “What the hell? Birkat Hamazon is only going to take care of things that happened in that bracket. Whatever started with the Birkat (blessing of), with the beracha (blessing) of Hamotzi lechem min ha'aretz (Who brings forth bread from the earth), is included. But anything else? Why would it be included? I understand Birkat Hamazon is powerful. So what? You ate before the seudah; you conclude your beracha has nothing to do with this.” That’s the opinion of the Ramban and the Rashba.

The Rosh takes a middle approach. The Rosh says it really depends. If you’re eating something that is opening the appetite, an appetizer, or you did Kiddush, because Kiddush is to allow you to eat, then there’s a connection. All you have to do is try to connect and say, “Well, this bracket that starts with the bread and ends with Birkat Hamazon is really more inclusive than that.” The Rosh says it’s something logical. It depends on the nature of what you ate. If it’s something that is introducing, opening the appetite for the meal, then it’s connected, even if it was before that, the same way Kiddush is going to be included in Birkat Hamazon because that was an introduction to the meal.

But if the nature of what you’re eating has nothing to do with the meal itself—for example, those who have the minhag (custom) to make a hundred berachot (blessings)—it has nothing to do with the meal. It’s not to open the appetite for the meal. Why all of a sudden? It’s just because they want to do more berachot. So then the Rosh says, “Oh, for sure it’s not included; you have to say Beracha Acharona.”

That’s a big problem. Therefore, of course, only because of the shita of Rabbeinu Zerachya Halevi—see the power of one man. One man who said the Birkat Hamazon includes, because of that, safek berachot (doubt about blessings) against all the other Rishonim. But why put yourself in a safek (doubt)? You put yourself in a safek; it’s not good. Therefore, those who are going to taste something before the Hamotzi have to make sure it’s a minimal amount, so that way they don’t put themselves in a safek.

Not putting yourself in a machloket is very, very important. If somebody made a mistake and ate a little too much of something, or they have a safek and they don’t know, we don’t say Beracha Acharona, and we rely on Birkat Hamazon to include everything.