Today is Lag BaOmer, and we did not say Tachanun (supplicatory prayer). It became a Minhag (custom), but the truth of the matter is that it is a very complicated subject, for the simple reason that the Shulchan Aruch does not bring it at all. The Shulchan Aruch has a list of days when we do not say Tachanun. Why didn’t he bring Lag BaOmer? He doesn’t bring it; he just omits it. The one who does bring it is the Rema. The Rema brings it. It says, “Nohagim shelo lipol al peneihem beyom Lag BaOmer.” The Minhag is to not say Tachanun on Lag BaOmer.
So the question is: why didn’t the Shulchan Aruch bring it? That’s a good question. I don’t really have an answer for that. But that means that the Minhag of not saying Tachanun is pretty recent. Although Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai was Niftar (passed) 1800 years ago, and the Shulchan Aruch was 450 years ago, that means that for 1500 years, according to the Shulchan Aruch, they did say Tachanun on Lag BaOmer, even though Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai was a Tanna (Mishnaic sage) who had passed. It must have been something to do with the Kabbalah (Jewish mysticism).
But the Mishnah Berurah says that the reason the Minhag the Rema brings—not to say Tachanun—is observed is, number one, because of “she-pasku Talmidei (students) Rabbi Akiva mi-lamut.” Because there was a cessation of the plague of the Talmidei Rabbi Akiva. That’s another point that I never understood, quite frankly. Why? There was... How many students did he have? 24,000? How many died? 24,000. Ah, okay. There was nobody left to kill. Oh, no more plague. Great, let’s party. That’s a terrible reason, because if you had 100,000 and 24,000 died... And still, I wonder who would make a party when 24,000 died. I say, “Oh, thank God we didn’t kill the other 76,000.” But I could hear somebody say, “Look, we’ve got to look at it in a positive light. You could have had 100,000.” In fact, if... Lo Aleinu (God forbid), on Holocaust Remembrance Day somebody makes a party, you say, “What are you doing? Why are you happy today?” “Well, only 6 million died. It could have been 15 million. You know, you have to look at it that way. Thank God we had 9 million Jews left.” “Oh, great, let’s party.” Anybody would do that?
No. Now here it’s worse, because the Gezerah (decree) was on the 24,000 Talmidei. They all died. Not one survivor. And you say, “Okay, the plague stopped. Let’s party.” What are you talking about? This is very difficult to understand. I don’t understand the ta’am (reason) the Mishnah Berurah brings. If any of you is clearer than I am, please let me know.
The other reason they give is that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai’s yahrzeit (anniversary of death) is on... It seems to have nothing to do with this story, because Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai is the new wave of Talmidei. And so maybe... I don’t know. Because when he was Niftar, it was maybe 50, 60 years later. You have Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai passing.
Now the question: since when do we party when Talmidei Chachamim (Torah scholars) die? That’s not a Jewish custom. It’s a Hasidic custom. Sorry to my friend the Hasidim (Hasidic Jews). Why? Because it’s a Mishnah Meforeshet (explicit Mishnah) in Masechet Sanhedrin, daf ayin alef amud bet (folio 71b), at the bottom. Over there, the Mishnah says, “When the Resha’im (wicked people) die, it’s great. It’s a good Hana’ah (good pleasure) for them, and it’s a good pleasure for the world.” It’s bad for them, says Rashi over there. Why is it bad for them? Because during life they could grow, and after death they can’t, because of the influence that they have, etc. It’s not good. We don’t party when Chachamim die. So why are we partying when Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai died? We celebrate life.
Besides, do we party for any other Chacham (Torah scholar) who died? Anyone? Someone answers, “Baba Sali.” “Baba Sali, do you party?” “I don’t party.” “You make barbecues, you make fries?” “Yeah.” That’s wrong. Absolutely wrong. One more: Hilula (celebration). Why do we do that? Hilula?
The Shulchan Aruch says the day of the death of the Tzaddikim (righteous people) is “Ra’ui lehit’anot Bahem.” It’s a day that you should do. It’s a day that you should do. You should be doing... You should be fasting on that day. We don’t party when Chachamim die. Why would you party when Chachamim die?
So the two reasons that the Mishnah Berurah brings, to be quite frank, al pi halakha (according to Jewish law), make very little sense. I don’t understand any of them. I’m not cholek (disputing), chas veshalom (God forbid), mi ani u’ma ani (Who am I and what am I?), but we’re allowed to ask questions. These questions are very valid, and if you have an answer, please come to me. However, the Kaf HaChaim brings, and most post...
And the biggest question again is: why didn’t the Shulchan Aruch bring it? I mean, clearly he didn’t like those reasons, because they’re not new reasons. He didn’t like those. Yes, it could be that the Zohar says that. But when the Zohar and halakha (Jewish law) contradict, we don’t follow the Zohar. But for some reason, here we do.
It seems... I would like to reformulate. The day that he died, we don’t party because he died. That’s not what we do. But there were special revelations on that day. So let’s reformulate. On the day of Lag BaOmer, we party, or we’re thankful and bring light because of the light that was taught. Let’s celebrate the last day of life of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, not the day of death. No, no, no—the last day of life of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, when he gathered his Talmidim, Rabbi Abba specifically, and said, “I have a lot of things to say before I pass.” And he taught tremendous Torah on that day. That’s what we are thankful for: the last Torah that he taught, which was the strongest Torah that he taught. And if you do that, at least... I’m not saying it’s the greatest of answers, but at least we got something. He doesn’t contradict something. We celebrate Torah. We celebrate revelations. We do not celebrate 24,000 people who stopped dying because they all died. And we do not celebrate when a Chacham passes. We celebrate when a Chacham lives. His Torah was his life, and that’s what we celebrate on Lag BaOmer.