Parashat Pinchas, for me, is a confusing parasha. There are conflicting commentaries on this story because, on one side, Pinchas did the heroic thing of jumping in to save Klal Yisrael by killing the head of the tribe of Shimon, who was being intimate with the Midianite lady, and this was bringing terrible things upon Klal Yisrael. The Pasuk (verse) says that Hashem says, “I stopped it. I stopped the Magefah (plague) because of that.” So it’s heroic; it saved Klal Yisrael. On the other side, taking things into your own hands is very dangerous. Kinah, which is what we call people who have zealotry, is very dangerous, because I don’t have to explain much. Imagine a country where people would start behaving like zealots. It could be very dangerous. So, about the whole story, you could ask: Was Pinchas right to do this, or should they have consulted with Moshe, etc.? There are a lot of Gemarot in Masechet Sanhedrin that discuss this. But the Perushim (commentaries) could be of different flavors on this.
For that, I’ll explain perhaps what the point is of Hashem saying, “Oh, he did this; for sure I’m stopping this Magefah,” based on something that is happening. Since the beginning of the war, October 7th, Klal Yisrael in America and around the world has been so supportive of so many needs. It started with helping the IDF. That was the first thing: they were missing equipment, and the whole Jewish world around the world was so generous. It was incredible. I’m in shock till today, and the whole Klal Yisrael. Then different needs started coming our way. Some were perhaps more specific in some places, but there was also rebuilding the physical structures of several Kibbutzim (communal settlements), which were destroyed. Then they needed some psychological help and financial help for the orphans and the widows. There were so many things that, in a sense, many people felt bombarded by. Somebody else would come and ask for help again and again and again. But we know it’s real. We’re just human. At one point, people say, “It’s taking a toll; the generosity is going down.” Many times, people who have the ability to help experience what is called mental fatigue. It’s normal.
Now, I thought to myself: When is there no mental fatigue when something repetitive is happening in the world? What’s happening in our lives? It’s very simple. You look at different things in life. I would say that whenever something is personal and a necessity for me, there’s no mental fatigue, and there’s no problem with repetition. Take, for example, eating. You eat breakfast in the morning. When lunch comes, you don’t say, “Oh, again, I’m going to eat.” No, you eat again. When dinner comes, you don’t say, “Again, I’m going to eat.” No, you eat again. There’s no problem with that. It’s a repetitive thing that one does not get tired of. Why? It’s for me. You get a client in the morning, you make a killing, Baruch Hashem (thank God), make a lot of money—great. In the afternoon, somebody else knocks on the door. They want to do business with you. Do you say, “Oh, I already did business today. I’m mentally fatigued by the repetition of my lifestyle, of making more money”? You never say that. Why not? Because it’s for us. Because when it’s my game, I have no problem with doing that. Even with bills, you get tired of paying electricity bills. It could be annoying, but you do it. Why? Because you don’t want to pay electricity bills. Why? Because you don’t want to turn off the air conditioning in Miami or anywhere you are during the summer. You’re just going to pay the bills because you want air conditioning. It’s a repetitive thing that you do gladly. You wish it would be less, but it’s a necessity; you do it.
But when somebody from outside comes to us and asks us for help, at one point we may say, “I’ve already given; it’s enough.” Imagine I help one day, and the next day I ask you again to help Israel, and the next day again. At some point, you’re going to say, “It’s enough.” What’s the difference between the two? I think the difference between the two, and we need to maybe change our perspective a little, is the following: When it’s for me, I don’t mind the repetition at all. Actually, the more the merrier. When it’s for someone else, I’m limiting myself because it’s not me. That battle, that war, is not for someone else. It’s for us. We’ve seen the reaction of the world against the Jews. It’s one package. Those soldiers, those people who are suffering, they’re not suffering for them. They’re suffering for us. It’s an extension of us. They go for us. They’re not fighting for them. And we shouldn’t feel that way, because it’s us. We’re paying our bills; we’re eating again. There’s no problem eating again and again and again because it’s us. We have to change that perspective. Perhaps this is something I learned from you.
What made God say, you know what, there's something there? Whether he was right or wrong to react, there’s a lot of discussion on this again in the Mefarshim (commentators). But one thing is clear. If he reacted like this, it’s because he couldn’t take it that somebody would break the Torah in such a Chillul Hashem (desecration of Hashem’s name). It was not external to him. It was his problem. It was his life. It was touching his Torah. He felt that this was attacking him, because you don’t react like this. If it’s not your problem, God’s problem became his problem. And because it was his problem, God said, “Wow, Kol HaKavod (well done).” This is the point that made God say, “You know what? He’s going to save the Klal Yisrael because of his dedication, because of the message he’s sending.” If I react in such a violent way, it’s because he’s touching my principle and my life. He wouldn’t have reacted like this if it was somebody else’s problem. Well, it’s not somebody else’s problem. It’s our problem. When somebody touches the authenticity of our Torah, it’s our problem. It’s our life. And that is what made Pinchas such a hero. Shabbat Shalom.

