A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Those who don’t allow a non jew to build on Shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
February 26, 2025
Duration
4:09
Lecture code
RGK-1512

Contract Work and Strict Halacha

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says that, al pi halacha, work done bekablanut (by contract) is permitted: the owner pays a company for the project, not workers by the hour, so there is no marit ayin. The company’s decision to pay its workers hourly is not the owner’s concern.

Local Concerns About Shabbat

  • In a heavily Jewish, concentrated community, having workers build houses for a Jew on Shabbat may be considered ziluta de Shabbata (disrespect of Shabbat).
  • This is a local concern for the local rabbanim to address. They may prefer that such work not take place; if a local issur (prohibition) applies, it should be followed. Rabbi Koskas distinguishes this from the position of strict halacha, which permits the work.

The Magen Avraham’s Concern

  • The Magen Avraham notes that some Gedolim did not want to permit the work because, in their time, non-Jews did not work on their holy day, Sunday. Allowing workers to build for Jews on Shabbat could lead them to say that Jews have workers working on their Shabbat while they themselves rest on Sunday, creating chilul Hashem.
  • Rabbi Koskas says this point should be considered in light of current practice. Construction usually stops on Sunday, except in emergencies, but it is unclear whether this is because Sunday is religiously observed or simply a day of rest. He notes that people drive and go about their activities on Sunday, and says he does not know whether the practice is religious.
  • He says the poskim focus on the practical fact that people do not work on Sunday because it is a day of rest. He adds that 500 or 600 years ago, religion may have been much more observant.

Chacham Ovadia’s Conclusion

  • Chacham Ovadia presents the matter as a safek (doubt) of the Rabbanan; since the issue is rabbinic, he concludes that it is mutar (permitted).
  • Rabbi Koskas reiterates that a local rabbi may still rule against construction in a particular place because it conflicts with the observance of Shabbat. Where no such local restriction exists, it is permitted for a non-Jew to continue building on Shabbat if he chooses to do so.