A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 2-7

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
June 1, 2026
Duration
6:44
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-2-7

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Masechet Kelim, Perek Bet, Mishnah Zayin will now list earthenware kelim (utensils) that are similar to those in Mishnah Gimel. The difference is that these can become tamei (impure), so they must have some sort of container that can hold something. The Mishnah says: a tray that has a rim around it. The rim keeps the plates on it from sliding off. And a complete shovel for coal. The shovel also has a rim around it on all four sides, which makes sure the coal doesn't fall off.

The law for a tray filled with all bowls that are attached to it is as follows. These are trays that had different compartments where people would put bowls, so the bowls were part of the original utensil and then physically attached to it. They seem to have been common in Egypt during the time of the Rambam. If one of them became impure through a sheretz, a creepy crawler that fell in it, the others do not become tamei. Even though the bowls are attached to the tray, each is considered a separate keli (utensil), and the tum'ah (impurity) of one does not affect the tum'ah of another. Each bowl is used independently, and therefore the bowls are considered separate kelim. So if one of them becomes tamei, it doesn't affect the status of the others.

But if the tray has a rim around it that's taller than the sides of the bowls, then if one of the bowls becomes tamei with the sheretz, all of the bowls become tamei. As soon as the sheretz enters the airspace of the rim—which happens before it enters the airspace of the bowl—boom, at that moment, the entire tray becomes tamei. Since the rim of the entire tray is higher than each individual bowl, the entire tray becomes tamei once the sheretz lowers into that spot that's higher, which is the rim around the tray, and all the bowls are therefore considered part of the tray. The same applies to an earthenware spice box that has different compartments for all different types of spices, like a desk organizer with different compartments for the different tools a scribe would use, some for ink and some for quills. If a sheretz falls into the airspace of one of the compartments, only that compartment becomes tamei, not the others, because they're all considered separate compartments. But if the container has a rim or wall that's taller than the walls of the individual compartments, and a sheretz falls into that airspace—or even into one of the compartments, with the rim there, higher than the compartments—the entire box becomes tamei, along with all its compartments.

Now, I was talking first about an earthenware spice box, and then a scribe's box. Now we'll talk about a wooden spice box and show how there's a similarity between them. The source of tum'ah in this case is a liquid that's tamei. As we learned above, only midrabanan, on a rabbinic level, can a tamei liquid make a utensil tamei. But if the tamei liquid touches only the outside of the utensil, just the outside becomes tamei, not the inside. We'll now explain how this rule affects a tamei liquid that falls into one of the compartments of a wooden spice box.

If one compartment of a wooden spice box becomes tamei through a tamei liquid touching it inside, the other compartment that shares the wall with it doesn't become tamei because the second compartment was touched by the liquid only on its outside. When a tamei liquid touches the outside of a utensil, only the outside becomes tamei, but the inside remains tahor (pure). When two compartments here share a wall, the inner side of the wall of one compartment is the outer side of the wall of the other compartment. So, let's say tamei liquid falls into one of them. That's considered the inside of that compartment, but it's also the same wall as the outside of a different one. Therefore, only the outside of the section next to it in the spice box becomes tamei, while the inside stays tahor, stays pure.

From the din (rule) that we just learned, it would seem that even though the second compartment has not become tamei, the wall between the two compartments does become tamei. Now we'll say how much of that wall becomes tamei. Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri says, “We divide the wall's thickness in half.” The half of the wall that serves the tamei compartment is tamei, and the half of the wall that serves the tahor compartment is tahor. A utensil becomes tamei from tamei liquids only rabbinically. Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri says here that the wall is divided in half, and only half of it becomes tamei. The Hachamim (Sages) disagree with his opinion and say, “No, on a rabbinic level, the entire wall becomes tamei.” That's how they concluded in the last part of the Mishnah.

The spice box we were talking about until now is one where the walls are the dividers between the compartments. Those walls are as high as the outer walls of the box. Now we'll teach the din for a spice box where the dividers are not as high as the outer walls of the box. But if the spice box has a rim that's higher than the walls of the individual compartments, then if one of the compartments becomes tamei by being touched by tamei liquids, all of the compartments also become tamei. The outer rim here combines all the compartments below it into one utensil, so that if one part of the utensil becomes tamei, the rest of the utensil becomes tamei as well. Even though there are individual compartments, it doesn't matter. Since the rim sort of brings them all together and turns them into one utensil, all of them become tamei in this scenario.