A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 3-5

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
June 1, 2026
Duration
3:38
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-3-5

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

In the previous Mishnah, we spoke about a cracked barrel that was coated with something to make it stronger. Here we’ll talk about the coating itself. We’ll start with the coating applied to a complete, undamaged utensil. The Mishnah says: If somebody coats an earthenware utensil that was healthy and undamaged, and the utensil becomes Tameh (ritually impure) through Tum’ah (ritual impurity) that enters its airspace, Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Shimon say that the coating becomes Tameh along with the utensil. Even though the utensil can function perfectly without the coating, the coating does help it last longer, and therefore it is considered part of the utensil and becomes Tameh together with it. Once the Keli (utensil) becomes Tameh through its airspace, it transmits Tum’ah through the coating. The coating is now considered part of the keli, and any food or liquid that touches the coating becomes Tameh as if it touched the wall of the utensil itself.

The Hachamim (the Sages) say: No; it depends. If someone coats an undamaged utensil and it becomes Tameh, the coating is Tahor (pure). The utensil doesn’t need the coating whatsoever. The coating is not considered a vital part of the keli, and therefore it is not considered part of the keli at all. It’s not even considered to be a yad, a handle, because it doesn’t contribute whatsoever to the use of the utensil. So food or liquid touch the coating; they remain pure, they remain Tahor. But if someone coats a cracked utensil to keep it from breaking, and the utensil becomes Tameh, then the coating becomes Tameh as well. In this case, the utensil needs the coating in order to function properly, and therefore the coating is considered a vital part of the utensil and becomes Tameh along with the rest of the utensil itself.

In the times of Chazal (the Sages), they would use shells of a squash or a pumpkin as a bucket to draw water from a well, to make sure that the pumpkins themselves didn’t crack when they were bumped. So when they rubbed against a hard object, they made a ring of wood or metal around them to reinforce them. The Mishnah will tell us the halacha (Jewish law) for this type of case, for this type of wood. The same machloket (disagreement) between Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Shimon and the Hachamim applies to the coating of a ring around the shell of a pumpkin or a squash. According to Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Shimon, the ring protects the shell from breaking, and therefore it’s considered part of the shell. So if the shell becomes Tameh, then the ring, the wooden ring around it, would become Tameh as well. According to the Hachamim, no. Right now, the pumpkin, for example, is strong enough to be used on its own as is, and the ring around it doesn’t make it more usable whatsoever. Therefore, it’s not considered part of the shell, even though it does help prevent it from breaking. So if it’s not part of it, it remains Tahor the whole time, even if the pumpkin itself becomes Tameh. That’s the machloket between Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Shimon and the Hachamim.