A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 5-3

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
June 1, 2026
Duration
6:53
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-5-3

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Here we'll talk about different items that are associated with a tanur (oven) or a kirah (stove), and ask whether they're part of the tanur and the kirah, so that when the tanur and kirah become tameh (ritually impure), these items become tameh as well, or whether they're not really considered to be part of them.

Mishnah says that the rim that could be attached to the roof of the kirah is put there; it's like an atarah (crown). It's put there many times to preserve the heat by holding it in and covering a spot that would be open on top. Tehorah is considered pure; it does not become tameh because most people do not attach rims to their kirah. So even if somebody did attach a rim to the kirah, it's not considered to be part of it.

Tirat ha-tanur, the law for the courtyard of the oven, quote unquote courtyard, is an enclosure next to the oven where hot bread is placed after it's removed from the oven. It's like a little box that goes on the side of it. The point of it is to keep the bread a little bit warm. When it's four tefachim (handbreadths) high, it becomes tameh through direct contact with a source of tum'ah (ritual impurity) that touches the inside of it, and through tum'ah entering its airspace without even touching it. The enclosure is next to the oven and used with it, so it's treated like the law of an oven. So if it's four tefachim high, which is the size of an oven, it becomes tameh like the rest of earthenware ovens. It's not a kli (vessel) on its own, but a space in front of the oven that's surrounded by walls. So in order for it to be considered tameh, it has to be considered basically like an oven. To be an oven, it has to be at least four tefachim high, like the minimum height of an oven to become tameh. But if the little enclosure is less than four tefachim high, it's tahor (pure), because it doesn't have the minimum size needed for an oven.

In this last case, the item we're talking about, the tirat ha-tanur, wasn't really attached to the oven. Now we'll talk about the rule if it actually is attached. If this item, this little box next to the oven, was attached by being pasted onto it, even if it was sitting on three stones rather than on the ground, it's a very weak connection. It's not properly attached to the oven. It's just semi-attached. It's considered tame'ah (ritually impure), even if it's less than four tefachim high. If it's attached to the oven, automatically it's considered to be part of the oven, and it doesn't need to be the minimum size of an oven on its own.

Now we'll talk about different types of containers that were attached to the outside of a kirah. Beit ha-pach, an oil holder, which is a jar of oil that's placed to be warmed by the heat of the kirah, or a spice holder or a lamp holder that's attached to the side of a kirah. They're used here for cooking. The lamp here is used so people could have illumination and light when they're cooking, and the spices are used to actually flavor the food. They become tameh through contact when a source of tum'ah touches the kirah that they're attached to. They become tameh as well. Ve'einan metame'in ba'avir, but they do not become tameh when something tameh enters the airspace of the kirah. If the source of tum'ah touches the inside of the kirah and makes it tameh, these holders become tameh as well. But if the source of tum'ah only enters the airspace of the kirah without touching it, then the kirah itself only becomes tameh, not the holders. That's the way it works.

Similar case: if the tum'ah touches the inside of these holders, it makes them tameh, and the kirah becomes tameh as well. But if the tum'ah enters the airspace of these holders without touching them, only the holders would become tameh, but the kirah would not become tameh. That's the idea over here. If the source of tum'ah touches the inside of the kirah, it makes it tameh, and these holders become tameh as well. But if it only enters the airspace of the kirah, the kirah becomes tameh, but not the holders.

The difference between the two of these is that the holders are not really considered to be part of the kirah, and they shouldn't become tameh with it whatsoever. But Hachamim (the rabbis) made a decree, and they said it's going to be considered to be like the kirah in some respect, only in terms of maga, in terms of touching. If something tameh touches the inside of the kirah, but not when something enters the airspace. So it's all on a rabbinic level. But on a de'oraita (biblical) level, the holders are not considered to be part of the kirah whatsoever because they do not have the same function. They don't really help in the cooking of the food, but they help with the storing of ingredients or provide light when the cooking is going on. But the rabbis decreed over here that they will become tameh in some respect, and they wanted people to remember that it was only rabbinic. We don't want people to associate it totally as the same in terms of the tum'ah. So they said, "We're only going to show the strength of the Hachamim by being strict with maga, with touching. But with airspace, we aren't going to be at the same level of strictness." So they limited the tum'ah to only the case of maga. It's important for people to remember not to burn Terumah (priestly portion) and Kodashim (consecrated offerings) that became tameh from these holders, because you're not allowed to burn unless they become on a level, and these holders are not really considered to be part of these holders, so they wouldn't be biblically. We wanted people to remember that so they don't make a mistake. This is the view concerning the holders in the case of something becoming tameh by being touched on the inside by a source of tum'ah. According to Rabbi Shimon, Hachamim never made a decree to make the holders tameh through the tum'ah of the kirah, even through touching.