In the second Perek (chapter), we mentioned that if you have an earthenware utensil from which a piece broke off, and it has the ability to hold a certain amount of liquid without being supported by anything else, it can stand on its own. It is still considered to be a keli (utensil) and has the ability to become tameh (ritually impure). Let’s elaborate on what it means for it to be able to stand on its own.
The Mishnah says that a broken piece of earthenware doesn't have the ability to stand on its own and hold liquid because of the handle which causes it to tip over. For example, let’s say there is an earthenware jug with two handles attached to it, and the utensil cracks and breaks. One piece of the utensil falls off with one of the handles. If there were no other handle on the other side, it would have been able to support liquid and stand on its own. But now that another handle is still on the jug, it weighs too much on that side, and therefore the broken piece falls over. So the broken piece cannot hold the required amount of liquid unless it is propped against something else to distribute the weight properly. It really could hold the liquid; it is just that a piece on the utensil is weighing it down and pushing it in a certain direction.
In that type of case, or in the following case, a sharp point was sticking out from the bottom because of the break, and the sharp point caused it to tip over. Here again, it is a similar type of case: the utensil has the ability to support itself, but because of the break, it now cannot, because there is a sharp point on the bottom. In those cases, the utensil is pure. It cannot stand on its own and hold the required amount of liquid; therefore, it is not considered to be a keli. We disregard the fact that it is not the utensil itself that cannot stand on its own; we disregard the fact that a detail is preventing it from standing on its own. We say that it cannot stand on its own, and therefore it is considered tahor (pure) going forward.
If the handle that was causing it to tip over was removed, or the sharp point that was preventing it from balancing was broken off, the broken piece remains tahor, even though it can now hold the required amount of liquid. Once an earthenware utensil loses its ability to become tameh, it can never become tameh again. We learned this from the case of gistera, as we had earlier: a broken piece that does have the ability to hold liquid. It is still considered to be tameh and has the ability to become tameh, because people would hold on to it and have some use for it because it could hold liquid. But once the gistera, the broken piece, is broken even more—for example, when it gets a hole—people usually throw that piece out. Therefore, it is no longer considered to be a utensil and is considered tahor; it is pure. Only a utensil could become tameh, even if the hole is later plugged up. We said that it does not matter; it is no longer considered a keli because people usually throw it out.
So we would apply the same din (law) to this. The broken piece remains tahor, even though the ozen—the piece that was on it, the handle—was removed. But according to Rabbi Yehuda, it is tameh because he does not compare it to the case of gistera. He says, “No, gistera is different.” He says that in the cases we are talking about in our Mishnah, the broken piece was fit to hold liquid. There is no hole in it like in gistera. It was just that something else was there—the handle or the sharp point—that was preventing it from functioning on its own. But once those obstacles were removed, everything is back. Therefore, the broken piece is considered to be a keli, even though it was not a keli before. But in the gistera case, the hole in it took away its ability to hold liquid, and therefore it was not even a keli. So Rabbi Yehuda would not compare the two cases.
The barrel’s bottom was broken, but it could still hold liquids with its walls when you put it down on its side. If you lay it on its side, it could still hold liquid. Or the barrel was split down the middle from top to bottom, and when you lay it on its side, it becomes two ovals that can hold liquid on their sides. According to Rabbi Yehuda, the remaining pieces are tahor. They are not considered kelim because they cannot hold liquid in their original, normal position. But the rabbis say, “No, they are tameh. They are considered kelim because even complete barrels are sometimes laid on their side, and therefore that is considered to be their original position as well.”

