Here we’ll talk about an oven that was half-filled with dirt. The Mishnah says: An earthenware oven filled with dirt up to the midpoint. The part of the oven from where the dirt begins all the way to the bottom becomes tamei (impure) only through touching a source of tumah (impurity) inside the top of the oven, the empty upper half. So we’re saying the whole thing becomes tamei. If something tamei touches the top part of the oven, including the dirt-filled part, it becomes tamei as well.
But if a source of tumah only enters the avir (airspace) of the top half of the oven without touching it, the bottom half of the oven—the part filled with dirt—remains tahor (pure). This is a de-rabbanan (rabbinic) type of tumah. Me'afar ulemala mitame ba'avir. But the part of the oven from the dirt up becomes tamei even through tumah entering its airspace without touching it. If tumah enters the top half of the oven through the airspace, the top half becomes tamei, but the bottom half does not.
An oven made of earthenware usually becomes tamei either by being touched on the inside or by something tamei entering its airspace. In this case, the bottom half of the oven becomes tamei only through touching the top part, but not through the airspace. The reason is that the part of the oven filled with dirt is not really an oven anymore. It can’t be used for baking anymore, so it cannot become tamei on a biblical level. It is only tamei on a rabbinic level.
So the Chachamim (Sages) here are the ones who said it will become tamei only when a source of tumah touches the inside of the top half of the oven, but not through the airspace. The empty part of the oven, like any other part of an earthenware oven, could become tamei when something enters its airspace. The rabbis here made a decree that the bottom half of the oven becomes tamei along with the top half when something touches it, but they didn’t make this decree when something entered the airspace of the top. The reason is that they wanted people to realize that the tumah of the bottom half is always rabbinic, and that even when it is touched, its status is still rabbinic. If they went all the way and said it could become tamei even through airspace, people would forget that it was the Rabbanan (the rabbis), because it would always be tamei just like the regular top of the oven. So, to emphasize that point, they only decreed through maga (touching), not through the airspace.
We learned a few times that an oven has to be heated to a certain point for that to be the finishing act on the oven, after which it can become tamei. An oven is normally heated when it is attached to the ground. Here we’ll talk about whether heating is effective if the oven is not attached to the ground but is placed over a pit in the ground.
Suppose somebody placed a new oven over a pit or a cistern and placed stone between the oven and the side of the pit to hold the oven in place. The ovens were shaped like an upside-down pot, as we discussed. The bottom had no floor; it was usually just attached to the ground with clay around it. The fire sat on the ground. In this case, the oven is not attached to the ground but is placed over a pit. The pit here is wider than the bottom of the oven, so the stone was placed between the wall of the oven and the side of the pit so that the oven wouldn’t fall all the way into it. The stone sort of leverages the oven. As we’ll see below, the fire for the oven was located at the bottom of the pit.
In this type of case, if somebody lights a fire at the bottom of the pit and the oven above it is heated to the required temperature, the oven is fit to become tamei. The fire at the bottom can heat the oven. Consider the oven to be attached to the pit, and therefore attached to the ground. So the oven becomes fit to become tamei through this type of heating. But if the fire at the bottom of the pit cannot heat the oven to the required temperature, and the only way to use the oven is to place the fire on a platform of some kind under the bottom of the pit, then the oven is not considered attached to the pit or the ground. This type of heating, which is not attached to the ground, would not make it fit to become tamei.
We’re talking about a case, as we said, where the pit is not that deep and not much wider than the oven. The fire at the bottom of the pit is close to the oven, and there’s just a small gap between the pit and the oven, so not much heat escapes. The fire is able to heat the oven for baking. In the last scenario, where we said it’s problematic, the fire at the bottom of the pit is not enough to heat the oven to the required temperature. That’s if the pit is all the way down, so the fire is too far away from the actual oven and heat escapes before it heats it properly. So if somebody wants to heat it properly, what they would have to do is bring a stone, place it in the pit, and make the fire on it. In that type of case, it wouldn’t be considered a gemar melachah (completion of work), and the oven is not ready. It’s not susceptible to becoming tamei.
But the rabbis disagree. VehaChachamim omrim, ho'il vehusak mikol makom tamei. The rabbis say the oven was heated. It doesn’t matter how it was heated. Once it’s heated, it’s fit to become tamei even though it was not connected to the ground when it was heated.

