A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 9-1

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
July 13, 2026
Duration
6:31
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-9-1

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We'll continue talking about the tum'ah (impurity) of ovens and what is considered part of an oven. The Mishnah says: If a tamei (impure) needle or a tamei ring is found in the earth—the floor of a tahor (okay) oven—we know that ovens had no bottom of their own. They were placed on the ground, and the needle or ring is visible on the inside, but it is not sticking into the oven. What is the law? The needle or ring here is on the indentation in the ground under the oven, so it is exposed to the oven, but it is not within the walls of the actual oven. What do we treat this as? How do we treat this needle or ring? Is it considered to be within the airspace of the oven or not? If it is in the airspace, the oven is tamei. If it is not within the airspace, the oven is okay.

If, when he bakes the dough in the oven, some of it leans downwards and touches the ground, it will touch the needle or the ring. The needle and the ring are considered to be part of the oven's airspace, and the oven would become tamei from them. What type of dough are we talking about when we give this ruling? A medium dough, not a dough that is too loose and not a dough that is too stiff. A loose dough is for sure going to sink downwards and touch the needle or the ring, and a stiff dough is for sure not going to. So we're talking about a medium type of dough that could or could not sink down below. That's how we judge the scenario.

Now we're talking about a case where a needle or a ring is somewhere else in an oven that's in the same house as a corpse. In this case, let's say a tahor needle or ring was found in the clay of an oven. The clay of an oven was there to insulate the oven, so that it would stay hot. And here we're talking about a case where the needle or ring is tahor, and it's in that section of the oven, and the oven is sealed up. It has a tzamid on top. It has a covering on top to make sure that tum'ah cannot enter the oven. And let's say the oven is in a house that has a corpse.

So we say the halacha (law) as follows. If the needle or the ring are in an oven that's already tamei, then the oven is tamei, but that doesn't automatically mean that the needle or the ring will become tamei, because they're in the outside part of the oven. They're in the clay part. They're not actually part of the oven. But we say that the needle or ring would become tamei even though the oven here is covered up, because a covered-up oven only works to stop things from coming in—to stop the impurity, the tum'ah, from coming in and making whatever's inside it impure. For other items—say, earthenware utensils in there, like this ring or other types of utensils, or this needle—the covering only works to stop the tum'ah if the oven itself is tahor. But if the oven itself is tamei, even though it's covered up, whatever's in there becomes tamei.

The needle or ring that were in the oven are tahor. They stay tahor, just like the sealed earthenware oven does not become tamei from the corpse in the house if it's covered up. If it's stuffed up over here, then the same thing applies: the needle or ring in the coating, the clay coating, does not become impure either.

Another similar case: If a needle or ring was found in the clay cork—the stopper—of an earthenware barrel inside a house with a corpse, the barrel's mouth is sealed with the stopper. So it's like an earthenware vessel that has a cover sealed all around, and therefore whatever's inside it doesn't become tamei. The question becomes: What about the needle or the ring? Could they become tamei from a corpse that's in the house? We say it depends on where in the stopper they are. Mi-tzideha, if they're embedded in the extra part of the stopper—that means the side of the barrel, the nonessential part of the stopper, of the cork—they are tame'im (impure). They become tame'im from the corpse because the extra part of the stopper is not part of the barrel. It's extra, it's an overhang, and therefore it's not protected. The needle or the ring here is not protected by the barrel. So we say tame'im, they become impure from the corpse because they're not in the essential part of the barrel. Mi-k'neged piha, tehorim. But if they're in the direct part of the mouth of the barrel, they are tahor. That part of the barrel—the part of the cork—is considered an essential part of the barrel.

Now we'll define when the needle and the ring are considered embedded in the stopper and therefore tafel, secondary to the stopper of the barrel. In other words, they're not within the actual barrel itself. They're within the coating, they're within the cork, like we said—the covering—and therefore they're subordinate to the stopper. They're not part of the barrel, but if they were at all, like we're going to say in a moment, within the barrel, then they would have the regular halacha for how we treat metal utensils that are within a barrel, which are not shielded from the tum'ah and could become tamei from a corpse.

The Mishnah says: If they're exposed and visible on the inside of the barrel, but they don't stick into the airspace, they're considered to be within the cork, and they remain tahor. But if they stick into the barrel and there's a layer of clay there, like a peel of garlic under them, they're not really in the airspace; they're considered to be embedded within the cork, and therefore they remain tahor.