A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 9-2

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
July 13, 2026
Duration
3:33
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-9-2

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

At the end of the previous Mishnah, we said that a metal utensil inside a sealed earthenware vessel is not shielded from Tum'ah (ritual impurity). Here we’ll elaborate on that and say that it was actually a machloket (dispute) between Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel.

The Mishnah says: If an earthenware barrel was full of tahor (pure) liquids, and there was a metal pipe used to draw liquids inside it. It has a cover seal all around it, and it’s put in the same roof as a corpse. What is the halacha (Jewish law)? How do we treat the metal utensil inside the earthenware barrel that’s full of liquids? It says that the barrel and the liquids inside it are pure because they’re shielded from Tum'ah by being in the sealed container. But the metal pipe is tameh (impure) from the corpse. It’s not shielded from Tum'ah, even though it’s inside the barrel.

Even though, on a de'oraita (biblical) level, a sealed earthenware vessel shields everything within it, Beit Shammai makes a decree that an earthenware vessel does not shield non-earthenware utensils. Beit Hillel says, “No, even the pipe is tahor; it’s shielded because it’s in a sealed barrel.” There’s no reason to say that there’s a decree that an earthenware vessel only protects earthenware things within it. According to Beit Hillel, there’s no reason to say that there’s a distinction between the barrel and the liquids and the pipe within it.

But Beit Hillel became aware of Beit Shammai’s ruling later on. Later on, Beit Hillel took back his ruling and held like the ruling of Beit Shammai: on a derabbanan (rabbinic) level, a pipe or any other type of non-earthenware utensil is not shielded by the barrel and becomes tameh from a corpse because it’s not earthenware.

The reason for the decree is because we want to make sure that a chaver—somebody who was reliable, somebody who was very careful with Tum'ah and Tahara (ritual purity)—doesn’t get influenced as much and doesn’t have as much interaction with the kelim, the utensils, of an am ha'aretz, who’s not reliable. We’re nervous that an am ha'aretz is going to claim that whatever he has in an earthenware container was sealed up. So he may just say everything was sealed up and not appreciate that he’s being put into question, as opposed to now, when there’s a rabbinic decree that says, across the board, anything non-earthenware that’s in an earthenware barrel is not protected by the seal that’s on it.

The am ha'aretz is not going to feel targeted or singled out, and there’s transparency across the board. He’ll have more openness to talk about it and to be direct about what he has in his kelim. There’s a lot more elaborate detail involved here about why the decree was made, but bottom line, Beit Hillel agrees to the decree of Beit Shammai.