A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Keretot 1-5

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
February 26, 2026
Duration
2:15
Lecture code
RJD-MKERETOT-1-5

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

The following women do not bring the korban yoledet (childbirth offering). They don't bring it at all. Not only does the Kohen (priest) not eat it, as in the last Mishnah, but they don't bring it whatsoever. A woman who miscarries a sack full of water, full of blood, or full of colored liquids. A woman who aborts something that looks like fish, locusts, which are all different types of worms, snakes, and scorpions, and tiny maggots that would grow inside rotting food. If this is what she miscarries, then she would not have to bring anything whatsoever.

We stated in Mishnah Gimel that Rabbi Meir said a woman who aborts something that looks like an animal or a bird does have to bring the korban yoledet. But here, in this case, if it resembles the shekatzim u'remasim (creeping things), there's no obligation to bring a korban (offering). The reason is because when it came to the birds and the animals, we used the word yatzar (creation) in Maaseh Bereshit, in the creation of the world, a word that the Torah also uses with the creation of human beings. So we would bring it. We connect them. But in the case of shekatzim u'remasim, we do not use the word yatzar. So there's no connection whatsoever to humanity. It can't be human, really. There's something else going on over there that's so undeveloped. And therefore, we say she does not have to bring these korbanot.

HaMapelet Yom Arbaim, if a woman aborts or she miscarries on or before the 40th day after the pregnancy began; V'yotze Dofen, a woman who had a regular baby that was delivered by C-section: in all of these cases, they do not have to bring any type of korban. Rabbi Shimon mechayev b'yotze dofen. But Rabbi Shimon disagrees about that last case, and he says if a woman had a C-section, she's obligated to bring a korban yoledet.