A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Keretot 3-4

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 4, 2026
Duration
3:27
Lecture code
RJD-MKERETOT-3-4

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

In the previous Mishnayot (Mishnah passages), we spoke about somebody who does several different averot (sins) unintentionally, all of which would have been karet (excision) if he had done them on purpose. Here, he did them unintentionally. Therefore, he has to bring a chatat (sin offering) for each one. In the next few Mishnayot, we’ll talk about how this even applies to somebody who does an aveirah with one single action but commits many different averot, for which they have to bring many different types of korbanot (offerings).

The Mishnah says there could be a case of a person who does one single action of eating and would therefore be obligated to bring four different chatat offerings and one asham (guilt offering). Of course, this is somebody who does it by mistake. He doesn’t do it on purpose; he’s doing it unintentionally, but he would still have to bring all of these korbanot. A person who was tameh (ritually impure) ate chelev, the forbidden fats, and the fats he ate were notar. They were leftover parts of the korban (offering) that were not burned and were not eaten within the required time. They were from korbanot. They were sanctified. And he ate them on Yom Kippur. So this tameh person ate chelev from a korban that was notar on Yom Kippurim. He would therefore be liable for five sins: eating on Kippur, eating a korban while he was tameh, eating the chelev, eating from notar, and benefiting from a sacred object, which is me'ilah. Even though all of these were unintentional, he is still liable, and he has to bring a korban chatat for the first of the four sins. For the fifth one, me'ilah, benefiting from something sacred, he has to bring a korban asham.

Rabbi Meir says, “I can add in another little detail that would obligate him to bring another korban. If it was Shabbat and he carried the chelev out in his mouth from Reshut HaYachid (private domain) to Reshut HaRabim (public domain), he would be chayav, obligated to bring another korban for violating Shabbat.” It is not allowed to carry on Shabbat. That would include having something in his mouth, and that would be a situation in which he was normally eating. Therefore, when he went outside with it, he violated another lav (prohibition), and he would have to bring another korban for that. So the first Tanna (rabbinic sage), even though he agrees that another chatat has to be brought, is going to explain why he didn’t include that in his model case. “Amru lo, Ein min ha-shem hu zeh.” The Tanna Kamma (first tanna) responds to this: “Ein min ha-shem hu zeh”—that sin of carrying on Shabbat is not in the same category as the other sins we were talking about. The situation Tanna Kamma was bringing out is about someone who’s eating. It includes all of the problems and all of the isurim (prohibitions) he could come up with that are involved with eating. Even though he’s eating in this case as well, and the carrying happens as a result of his eating, that’s not within the same category that Tanna Kamma was trying to speak about, so he didn’t include it in his example.