A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Keretot 3-5

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 4, 2026
Duration
9:57
Lecture code
RJD-MKERETOT-3-5

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

This Mishnah gives an example of someone who had relations and has to bring more than one chatat offering for that single act. The Mishnah says there is an example of a person who has one act of relations and is obligated to bring six different korban chatatot (hatat offerings) for that one act. If a man has relations with his daughter, that same act could also obligate him for relations with his sister, his brother’s wife, his father’s brother’s wife, ve’eshet ish, a married woman, and ve’nida (menstruant). And maybe that woman was also a nida. This seems like a Yevamot type of case, but here’s the basic gist of what happened.

A man, we’ll call him Reuven, had an incestuous relationship with his mother, Leah. They have a daughter named Dina. So Dina is now Reuven’s daughter, and she is also his half-sister because they share a mother named Leah. Dina then marries Reuven’s brother, whose name is Shimon. Shimon dies, and then Dina marries the brother of Reuven’s father. So she marries Reuven’s uncle, his father’s brother. His name is Yaakov. Reuven then has relations with Dina while she’s a nida, while she is still married to that uncle.

He ends up having relations with this married woman and violating all six types of aveirot (transgressions). He has relations with his daughter first, really, and with his sister, because they have the same mother. He has relations with his brother’s wife because she was once married to Shimon, who was Reuven’s brother. His father’s brother’s wife, because she was married to Reuven’s father. She is married to Reuven’s father. His father’s brother is named—we’ll call him Esav. Dina is also a married woman, so eshet ish, a married woman. And then she’s also a nida. By having relations with Dina, he committed six different aveirot. If it was done on purpose, it would have been karet (excision). If it was unintentional—if, for example, he didn’t know who the woman was—he would have to bring six chatat offerings. That’s how this Mishnah ends up having this type of case.

The next type of case is similar to the one we had, but it involves a granddaughter rather than a daughter. It’s possible for someone to have relations with his daughter’s daughter, his granddaughter. He could also be obligated to bring a korban chatat (sin offering) because he is with his granddaughter—number one, his daughter’s daughter—and his daughter-in-law, his wife’s sister, his brother’s wife, his father’s brother’s wife, a married woman, and a nida. So he could have another type of situation where he ends up having relations with his granddaughter, and it leads to all of these problems.

The way it plays out, let’s say there are two men, one named Yaakov and one named Lavan. Both of them have daughters. Yaakov’s daughter is Dina, and Lavan’s daughter is Leah. Lavan marries Leah, and Lavan marries Dina. Lavan and Dina have a daughter called Serah. Serah is Yaakov’s granddaughter because she is the daughter of his daughter, Dina. Serah is also Yaakov’s wife’s sister because Leah, who is Lavan and Dina’s daughter, ends up marrying Yaakov, so Serah and Leah are sisters.

Serah marries Yaakov’s son, Reuven. Reuven eventually dies, and then Serah marries Yaakov’s brother, Esav, so she becomes Yaakov’s brother’s wife. Esav dies, and Serah marries Yishmael, who was the brother of Yaakov’s father, Yitzhak, so she becomes the wife of Yaakov’s father’s brother. She’s also married to Yaakov, and so she’s a married woman. Then Yaakov has relations with Serah when she is a nida. You end up with him being with his granddaughter, and you have all of these problems. There are seven different aveirot being done through Yaakov’s relations with Serah. He’s doing seven aveirot. He’s with his granddaughter, his wife’s sister, his daughter-in-law, his brother’s wife, his father’s brother’s wife, a married woman, and a nida for all of these aveirot. If done unintentionally, he would have to bring a korban chatat.

Another case that we have: Reuven, if her great-grandfather ended up marrying her, and in an aveirah (transgression) he sinned, the grandfather, if he, when he was a nida, when he had relations with her, also in sin, would be obligated to bring another chatat on account of her being his father’s wife. If Yaakov was with Serah when she was married and a nida, then besides the seven aveirot that we spoke about, he also violates an additional one: having relations with his father’s wife.

We’ll now bring another case, or two more cases, that parallel the first two cases: relations with a person’s daughter or with their granddaughter. If a man has relations with his wife’s daughter—not his own daughter, his wife’s daughter—or with his wife’s daughter’s daughter, his wife’s granddaughter, he would also get into a similar situation as before.

The case would be as follows. There’s a man named Yitzhak. He has relations with a woman named Leah. They’re not married, and they have a daughter, Rachel. Yitzhak’s son, Yaakov, marries Leah, which he’s permitted to do because she was never married to his father; they just had relations. So Yitzhak has relations with Leah, and they have a child, and then Yitzhak has a son named Yaakov who ends up marrying the woman he had relations with, all permitted. Then Leah’s daughter, Rachel, becomes forbidden to Yaakov as his wife’s daughter.

In addition, Rachel is Yaakov’s sister because they have the same father, Yitzhak. Rachel then marries Yaakov’s half-brother from the share of the same mother, Esav, so therefore she becomes Yaakov’s brother’s wife. Rachel was allowed to marry Esav because they’re not siblings at all: they don’t have the same mother or the same father; they just basically have a common element with a common brother. Esav dies, and Rachel marries the brother of Yaakov’s father, Yishmael. So she becomes Yaakov’s father’s brother’s wife. Yaakov has relations with Rachel when she is a married woman and a nida, so we have the same type of situation there.

We also mentioned that the person who had relations with his wife’s granddaughter could be obligated to bring the same number, seven korbanot (offerings), as a person who has relations with his own granddaughter. In that previous case we brought, a person’s wife’s daughter would also mean six korbanot that he would have to bring, just like for the daughter.

In this type of case, where you have seven for a man having relations with his wife’s granddaughter, Yaakov’s wife, Leah, has a father named Lavan and a daughter named Dina. Yaakov has—Lavan commits incest with his granddaughter, Dina, and they have a daughter named Rachel. Rachel is Leah’s granddaughter because she is the daughter of Leah’s daughter. Rachel is also Leah’s sister because they have the same father. Since Leah is Yaakov’s wife, Rachel is both his wife’s granddaughter and his wife’s sister.

Rachel marries Yaakov’s son Reuven, from a different marriage, becoming Yaakov’s daughter-in-law. Reuven dies, and Rachel then marries Yaakov’s brother Esav, becoming Yaakov’s brother’s wife. Esav dies, and Rachel marries the brother, Yishmael, of Yaakov’s father, Yitzhak, becoming Yaakov’s father’s brother’s wife. Yaakov then has relations with Rachel when she is married and when she is in nida. That ends up with a violation of seven aveirot, and therefore seven korbanot have to be brought.