A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Keretot 6-1

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 16, 2026
Duration
6:31
Lecture code
RJD-MKERETOT-6-1

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

In this Mishnah, we’ll talk about a person who designated an animal to be an Asham Talui, which means he is in Safek (uncertainty). He doesn’t know whether he committed an aveirah (sin) that he would be liable to bring a Chatat (sin offering) for if he had definitely committed it. Then he finds out that he isn’t really obligated to bring that Asham Talui.

The Mishnah says that somebody who designated an animal to be an Asham Talui thinks he may have committed an aveirah punishable by Karet (excision). Then he finds out that he definitely did not sin. So he is exempt from bringing an Asham Talui.

For example, let’s say a person had two pieces of meat. One was Chelev (forbidden fat), and one was permitted Shuman, permitted fat. He ate one of them, but he doesn’t know which one he ate. Since it was possible that he ate the Chelev, he designated an animal to bring as the Asham Talui. But later on, he finds out that he ate the permitted Shuman, and no Asham Talui is necessary.

So what does he do now? If he discovers that he is innocent before the Korban (offering) was slaughtered, the animal can go out and graze like a regular Chullin (non-sacred) animal. The animal has no sanctity and is considered an ordinary animal. That’s because the owner consecrated it on the assumption that he needed to bring it for an Asham Talui. But when he later finds out that there’s no need to bring an Asham Talui, we say retroactively that the animal was mistakenly consecrated. Therefore, the consecration is null and void, and the animal has no sanctity. This is the opinion of Rabbi Meir.

But the rabbis say that even though you can’t bring the animal now as an Asham Talui because he found out that he definitely did not commit the aveirah, the animal remains holy. When a person designates an animal as an Asham Talui, it doesn’t matter what ends up happening in terms of whether he is guilty or whether he committed the aveirah. The animal remains consecrated. So even if he later finds out that he never sinned, the animal still remains holy. Therefore, it is treated as an Asham (guilt offering) that is not needed, and the animal is left to graze until it develops a blemish that would disqualify it from being a Korban. Then it is sold, and the money from its sale is donated to the Beit HaMikdash (Temple) for voluntary Korbanot.

Whenever no Korbanot are being brought on the Mizbeach (altar), they consider it a Bizayon, not a good thing for the Mizbeach to be sitting there idle. So they would bring voluntary Korbanot to make sure that the Mizbeach stays busy. They would take the blemished animal from here, sell it, and use the money to purchase more Korbanot for the Mizbeach.

Rabbi Eliezer says, omer yakriv (says, it shall be offered): no, the animal can be offered on the Mizbeach as an Asham Talui for its owner, even though he doesn’t require an Asham Talui for the sin he may have committed, because he didn’t commit it. Now he still could have been presumed to have committed some aveirah. If the Korban does not come as atonement for this aveirah, it comes as atonement for a different aveirah that he committed and doesn’t know about. Rabbi Eliezer says that the Asham Talui doesn’t have to come just to atone for a sin that somebody knows about; it could even come to atone for something someone doesn’t know about.

Now we’ll talk about a person who finds out that he does not need the Asham Talui after it has already been slaughtered. But if it only becomes known to him that he didn’t commit the aveirah after the Asham Talui was already slaughtered, but before the blood was thrown on the Mizbeach, the Korban cannot be offered since it is no longer needed. What we do is get rid of the Korban, which is invalid and cannot be brought. The blood is poured into the stream that flows in the courtyard of the Beit HaMikdash, and the meat is taken out to the place of burning, where it is burned. Whenever we find an invalid Korban, there is a process: there is a spot in the Temple courtyard designated for burning invalid Korbanot. Nizrak hadam (the blood was sprinkled). But if the blood was already thrown on the Mizbeach when they found out that the owner was innocent, then the Korban is valid and the meat is eaten. So they found out about the owner’s innocence too late. The Asham Talui was already offered and is valid, and therefore the meat is allowed to be eaten. The Asham Talui is valid as long as the owner was unsure at the time the blood of the Korban was thrown on the Mizbeach. So it was all done correctly. The owner was unsure at that point in time, and therefore the meat could be eaten. That’s how things are: the Korban is valid like a regular Asham.

Rabbi Yose says that even if the owner’s innocence is established while the blood is in the cup where it was received after the slaughter, and it hasn’t been thrown on the Mizbeach, the blood should be thrown on the Mizbeach and the meat should be eaten. According to Rabbi Yose, as soon as the blood is in the cup from which it is going to be thrown on the Mizbeach, it is considered to have already been thrown on the Mizbeach. Therefore, if he finds out that he does not need to bring the Korban after the blood is already in the cup, it is as though he found out after the blood was thrown, and the Korban is valid. The meat can be eaten. So that is the point in time considered to be the crucial zone: if he was unsure about the whole Korban at that moment, and the blood was there, the Korban is valid. That’s the machloket (dispute) between the Chachamim (Sages) and Rabbi Yose.