We've been talking a lot about the asham talui in this masechet (tractate). It is a korban (offering) brought when a person suspects that he committed an averah (sin) that, if done on purpose, is punishable by karet (excision). He will bring down three opinions about whether one could bring the asham talui in other situations.
The Mishnah says that a person could bring or donate an asham talui any day, any time he wants, even though an asham talui is obligatory if a person is unsure whether he committed an averah that, if done on purpose, is punishable by karet. You could also voluntarily bring the asham talui at any time that you'd like. When a person does this, the voluntary asham talui is called the asham (guilt offering) of the hasidim (pious individuals). A person who's doing more than they have to do is doing something above the letter of the law.
We're going to say now that there was a rabbi who wanted to follow the view of Reb Eliezer and bring an asham (guilt offering) when he wanted to, and the rabbi stopped him. Amru alav al Bava ben Buta (They said about Bava ben Buta). There was a rabbi named Bava ben Buta who would bring an asham talui whenever it was possible, every day, whenever he could bring a nedavah (voluntary offering). So obviously, he couldn't bring it on Shabbat or the holidays. The day after Yom Kippur (Day of Atonement) was an exception.
He said, “If they would let me over here, I would bring an asham talui even on the day after Yom Kippur because I like the opinion of Reb Eliezer and I hold like it: an asham talui is voluntary and could be brought at any time. But the people around me disagree and tell me, ‘Wait until you have a situation where you have some sort of safek (doubt) about whether you sinned.’”
The rabbis who were with Bava ben Buta hold that an asham talui is not fully voluntary. It can only be brought for a person who thinks they have a possible situation. There has to be reasonable doubt about it. They have to assume that maybe you sinned in some way, even if it's not a sin that's possible. If it's punishable, like by karet, or is a severe situation, you have to have a little bit of thought that you committed an averah here.
The day after Yom Kippur, a person's sins are wiped away. There's no averah to atone for because Yom Kippur does the job of atonement. Therefore, the day after Yom Kippur, the rabbis told them, “Take it easy. Don't bring it every single day. Wait at least one day, because maybe during that one day you committed another averah, and therefore you could bring it two days after Yom Kippur. Let it be, for a reason. Don't just bring the voluntary asham just because you want to.” And even if he did a sin that wasn't punishable by karet, they would allow him to bring it. So they said, “Have a little bit of patience before you bring the korban so quickly.”
A third opinion: The rabbi said, “We bring asham talui only for an averah. If it was done intentionally, it would be punishable by karet, and if done unintentionally, it would be a korban hatat (sin offering), but it's not a voluntary korban whatsoever.” As the other rabbi said to Bava ben Buta, it can't be brought for a person who committed some sort of averah. It could only come to atone for a person who has a doubt about whether he committed a certain averah that, if done on purpose, would be punishable by karet. If done by mistake, he would have been obligated to bring a regular korban hatat. So the rabbis say it's not voluntary at all. You have to really have the certain criteria in order to bring it.

