A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Keretot 6-5

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 16, 2026
Duration
3:20
Lecture code
RJD-MKERETOT-6-5

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We mentioned Yom Kippurim (Day of Atonement) and how it affects the obligation of korbanot (offerings) in the last Mishnah. Now we'll bring it up in a different context, with a bird chatat (sin offering) brought by a woman who had a miscarriage and doesn't know what the fetus looked like. As we mentioned earlier in the Masechet (tractate), if she doesn't know, she now has a safek (out of doubt) obligation. A woman had to bring a bird chatat out of doubt. Yom Kippurim passed before she had the opportunity to bring it. She's obligated to bring the korban after Yom Kippur, even though we said that Yom Kippurim takes the place, in terms of the kapparah (to atone), of a korban that's being brought to atone for something like a safek, like an asham taluy (conditional guilt-offering), as we learned in the last Mishnah. A bird chatat is brought out of doubt, but it's not brought out of atonement, because the korban enables her to eat the korban, which she's forbidden to eat until she brings this korban. Therefore, the korban has nothing to do with kapparah or Yom Kippurim necessarily. And that's why Yom Kippurim doesn't replace its obligation. She has to bring the korban, even though Yom Kippurim has already passed.

Now we'll talk about another law about this type of bird chatat: chatat of a ba'al ha-safek (one in doubt), a bird chatat that's brought out of doubt. If it became known to the owner after the melikah was done—melikah, the way the Kohen (priest) kills this bird using his thumbnail, is a unique type of shechitah (ritual slaughter), really, that's done only for bird korbanot—that the chatat wasn't needed, harei zu tikaver, the bird has to be buried. A person is forbidden to benefit from it whatsoever. It's treated like a regular bird chatat that's brought out of doubt; you can't have any benefit from it whatsoever.

Let's just play this out for a second. If the chatat being brought was, let's say, a valid chatat, then of course you're not allowed to benefit from it in any way. But here they found out that they were not obligated to bring this korban because they found out that the person never actually sinned over here, and the korban wasn't needed. So the bird really should be permitted to be used. So we say, of course, it can't be eaten now because it was killed by melikah. Melikah is only a way to kill an animal when it's being used for a korban. But if I did melikah on a chullin (non-sacred) animal, if I did it on a bird that's for my own purposes, the bird is now a terefah. It's not a kosher bird because I killed it through melikah and not through proper shechitah. So I can't eat it for sure. But why can't I derive benefit from it? It's now a chullin bird. The reason is rabbinic. Chachamim (Sages) were afraid that people were going to confuse this bird with a regular bird chatat that's being brought out of doubt, which you can't eat or benefit from in any way. So they decreed that this type of bird is not allowed to be used either. And to ensure that it's not used, it has to be buried.