A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Meilah 6-2

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 30, 2026
Duration
5:26
Lecture code
RJD-MMEILAH-6-2

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

If somebody—the Baal HaBayit—sent hekdesh (consecrated property) money, my mistake, with somebody who wasn’t halachically knowledgeable enough to serve as a shaliach (agent)—a deaf mute, a person who lacked knowledge, or a minor—and told them to buy something with the money, then if the agent here, this cheresh (a deaf mute), shoteh (a person who lacked knowledge), or katan (a minor), did what they were supposed to do and purchased what he told them to, the Baal HaBayit, the person who gave them the money originally, committed me'ilah (inadvertent misuse of hekdesh). Even though a person who is a shoteh, cheresh, or katan cannot serve as an agent, if they followed through with the instructions and did what they were supposed to do, then the Baal HaBayit is the one who did me'ilah, just as if he had sent a regular, qualified shaliach.

What we see over here is that even though we say a cheresh, shoteh, or katan cannot actually serve as a shaliach, when it comes to me'ilah, it’s the exception to the rule. Likewise over here as well. Even though a cheresh, shoteh, or katan cannot serve as an agent, if the actions were done—if the me'ilah was done, a transference of money, exactly like the Baal HaBayit wanted, like he desired—he’s responsible, regardless of who does the action. So if someone sends a person who lacked the proper knowledge to do the act of me'ilah, even though that person isn’t a real agent, the sender caused me'ilah to happen in the way he wanted, and therefore he would be responsible. Lo asu shlichuto, hachenvani ma'al (If they did not carry out his assignment, the shopkeeper commits me'ilah). Lo asu shlichuto, hachenvani ma'al.

But if the agent, the messenger, did not do his assignment properly—if he made the wrong purchase or did something different—then the Baal HaBayit here is not responsible for the me'ilah because his instructions weren’t followed. You can’t say the shaliach is responsible for the me'ilah either, because they lack the knowledge and aren’t responsible for their own actions. So me'ilah wasn’t committed, and the money remains hekdesh even after it’s handed over to the shopkeeper. Therefore, the shopkeeper is the one who’ll eventually do me'ilah when he spends this money. The person who commits me'ilah with hekdesh makes it lose its holiness. But here, no me'ilah was committed, so the item is still hekdesh. When the shopkeeper receives the money, he becomes the person who’s holding on to it. Even though he has no idea about it, when he spends the money, he removes it from hekdesh and commits me'ilah.

Like we learned, me'ilah only happens when there’s a mistake going on. It’s inadvertent misuse of hekdesh. It will talk about when a person sends hekdesh with a shaliach, but the messenger or the shaliach doesn’t act with that lack of understanding. If somebody sent hekdesh money with a normal adult to make a purchase from a store, and the sender remembered that the money was hekdesh before the agent reached the store, the sender is exempt from me'ilah. He’s aware that the money is hekdesh at the moment it was supposed to be switched over. Therefore, he couldn’t be liable for me'ilah because there’s no inadvertent use of hekdesh. If the agent was unaware that the money was hekdesh, he’s the one who commits me'ilah when he gives it over to the shopkeeper. So he’s aware that the money is hekdesh. If the agent is also aware that the money is me'ilah but spends it anyway, then the agent is also exempt from me'ilah because he did not act without the proper understanding. When the shopkeeper receives the money, no me'ilah was done over here, so the money is hekdesh. He commits me'ilah when he spends the money inadvertently.

Now we’ll talk about what the storekeeper should do if the case above is hekdesh. If the case above happens to him, he finds out that the money he received was hekdesh after he mixed it in with other money. What should he do? What should the shopkeeper do in this case? He was given a peruta (a small coin) of hekdesh, but he doesn’t know which peruta coin it was. Notel peruta o keli, he takes a peruta or a utensil that was worth a peruta. V'yomar (and he says): “Peruta shel hekdesh, b'chol makom shehi mechulelet al zeh.” The peruta of hekdesh, whoever it was, let it be redeemed. It could be redeemed onto this peruta or onto this utensil. He then takes that. The sanctity is pushed onto whatever he was holding. Shehahekdesh nifdeh b'kesef u'veshaveh kesef. Because hekdesh could be redeemed with money or with items worth money. The holiness of an item of hekdesh could be transferred onto something else, and therefore the storekeeper could transfer the holiness of the peruta whose location he doesn’t know onto another peruta or another item. At that point, he could use all of his coins.