A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Meilah 5-3

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 30, 2026
Duration
5:24
Lecture code
RJD-MMEILAH-5-3

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

The Torah teaches that when somebody commits Me'ilah (misuse of sacred property), the item that was holy loses its holiness, and now it is totally allowed to be used. Even so, one repercussion is that Me'ilah cannot be committed again with the item, because its status is no longer the same after somebody else has already committed Me'ilah with the item of Hekdesh (consecrated property). Again, as we said, it loses its sanctity and is therefore no longer subject to Me'ilah. The only cases where Me'ilah could be repeated after someone else has already committed it are an unblemished animal that was dedicated as a korban (offering) and a Kli sharet, a holy utensil of the Beit HaMikdash. A korban and a Kli sharet have physical sanctity; they have Kedushat Haguf (physical sanctity), and they cannot be redeemed.

The sanctity of Hekdesh that Me'ilah removes depends on whether the Hekdesh has Kedushat Haguf or Kedushat damim (monetary sanctity). A korban or Kli sharet cannot be redeemed. Their sanctity is not just Kedushat damim; they have an internal Kedushat Haguf, an inherent Kedushat Haguf. Therefore, Me'ilah does not take them out of the domain of Hekdesh, and they remain holy. A person who misuses one of them does not remove it from Hekdesh, and therefore, if another person comes and misuses it after him, they would both be subject to Me'ilah. An item that has Kedushat damim, on the other hand, has only monetary sanctity and can be redeemed from Hekdesh. Therefore, it leaves the domain of Hekdesh once someone commits Me'ilah with it. It becomes unconsecrated, and people are allowed to use it.

How is Me'ilah committed more than once with a korban or Kli sharet? Somebody rides an unblemished animal that was dedicated as a korban, and then his friend rides on it after him, and then another friend rides on it. Or somebody drinks from a gold cup that was a Kli sharet, a utensil of the Beit HaMikdash, and his friend comes afterwards and drinks from it as well, and then another friend comes and drinks from it. Or somebody plucks hair from an unblemished animal that was dedicated as a korban, and then his friend comes and plucks hair from it, and then another friend comes and uses the animal, and then another friend comes and plucks hair from it. Kulan ma'alu. In all of these cases, everyone—the three who rode the animal, the three who drank from the cup, and the three who plucked hair from the korban chatat (sin offering)—did Me'ilah. The item remains holy even after the first act of Me'ilah.

Rebbi omer (says): kol she'ein lo pidyon, about any Hekdesh item that cannot be redeemed, including an animal that was designated as a korban and later developed a blemish and was slaughtered without being redeemed first. A person could commit Me'ilah by misusing it even after someone had already done so with it. For an animal to be redeemed, it has to go through the process of Ha'amadah veha'arachah (standing and assessing it): it has to stand on its own before a Kohen (priest), who gives it an assessment of its value for redemption. According to the opinion of Rebbi, which we just stated, that applies not only to animals that were donated to the Beit HaMikdash, but even to those that were designated as a korban and later developed a blemish. That type of animal could be redeemed only before it is slaughtered. If it was not redeemed beforehand, it can be redeemed afterwards, since we cannot do Ha'amadah veha'arachah. So that is how Rebbi understands it. Therefore, it remains subject to Me'ilah if it was not redeemed; it is still subject to Me'ilah.

According to Tanna Kamma (first tanna), on the other hand, he says that if an animal was not redeemed, it could still be redeemed even after slaughter, because, according to him, the idea that an animal has to stand on its own to be redeemed applies only to an animal that was donated to the treasury of the Beit HaMikdash, not to a korban that developed a blemish. Therefore, since the item can be redeemed, it loses its sanctity through Me'ilah, and Tanna Kamma would say that once somebody commits Me'ilah with a blemished korban, it loses its sanctity and can no longer be subject to Me'ilah. But Tanna Kamma does agree that an animal has to be redeemed before it is slaughtered. Here, in this situation, if it was not redeemed before it was slaughtered, according to how Tanna Kamma understands it, it could still be redeemed even after the slaughter because there is no obligation of Ha'amadah veha'arachah.