A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Meilah 4-1

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 24, 2026
Duration
3:34
Lecture code
RJD-MMEILAH-4-1

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

A person only violates me'ilah (misappropriation of sacred property) if they have at least a perutah's worth (small coin) of benefit from the holy item. Here the Mishnah will talk about whether a person violates me'ilah when they have a benefit smaller than a perutah, but a combination of benefits from a few different items together is worth more than a perutah. How do we work out that situation? We'll talk about this in the context of, number one, the kodshei mizbeach (altar), the items that were dedicated to the mizbeach. These are animals like cattle, sheep, goats, doves, and pigeons, and also flour, oil, and wine that are used for the minchah (meal offering) and the libations. We'll also talk about it with the kodshei bedek habayit, the items that were dedicated for the upkeep of the Beit HaMikdash. That means items that themselves are going to be used, like gold, silver, and other materials, and also items that are dedicated but can't be used in the upkeep itself, so they're sold off. The funds are used for the upkeep of the Beit HaMikdash.

The Mishnah says that items dedicated for the mizbeach combine with each other to make a person liable for me'ilah. If somebody unintentionally benefits from a combination of items worth a perutah, then that combined benefit makes the person liable for me'ilah. If he has half a perutah's worth of benefit from an olah (burnt offering) and half a perutah's worth of benefit from a chatat (sin offering), and it's all in one lapse of awareness, then he violates me'ilah. There can even be a very long time between them. If there's one lapse of awareness, then they combine to make a person violate me'ilah. They also combine to make a person liable for karet (spiritual excision) for eating them when they were pigul, notar, or tameh (ritually impure). Pigul is a korban (offering) that was brought with improper intentions to offer it or to eat it past the proper time. Notar is a korban that became invalid because it was left beyond the time when it was supposed to be eaten. And tameh: if a person ate a korban while they were in a state of tum'ah (ritual impurity), if somebody did one of these, then they're liable to karet. What we're saying here is that if a person ate half a kezayit (olive-sized amount) of pigul from an olah, and another half a kezayit of pigul from a chatat, they're liable to karet because the two half-kezayitot (olive-sized amounts) combine into one.

Kodshei bedek habayit mitztarfin zeh im zeh. Likewise, items that were dedicated for the bedek habayit combine with each other to reach a perutah's worth to make a person liable for me'ilah. So that idea is not limited to the kodshei mizbeach, but it also extends to the bedek habayit. If a person has half a perutah's worth of benefit from one item that was dedicated for the bedek habayit and another half a perutah's worth of benefit from another item, they combine to create a situation of me'ilah.

Kodshei mizbeach ve-kodshei bedek habayit mitztarfin zeh im zeh le-me'ilah (for me'ilah). And likewise, even if you have items that were dedicated for the mizbeach and items that were dedicated for the bedek habayit, they also combine with each other to reach a perutah's worth to make a person liable for me'ilah. So it's really any combination of any items that come together that were dedicated to the bedek habayit. Whether they're kodshei mizbeach, whether they were bedek habayit, kodshei bedek habayit, they could combine to create a situation of me'ilah if the combination of them reaches a perutah.