Masechet Temurah, Perek Aleph, Mishnah Bet.
The Torah tells us that if a person violates Temurah (substitutes an animal for an animal). So it doesn’t tell us specifically, like a sheep for a sheep, but it tells us, “Behemah for Behemah,” which tells us that anything within the Behemah (animal) family could become Temurah with each other.
So we’ll see how that plays out in the Mishnah. The Mishnah says a person can make Temurah by substituting unconsecrated, unholy cattle for korbanot (offerings) of sheep and goats, or by substituting sheep and goats for the korbanot of cattle. So the word tzon includes sheep and goats. The word bakar is talking about bulls, cows, and calves. These are cattle.
So what we’re saying here is, if a person, for example, took a sheep and wanted to substitute it for a bull as Temurah, that’s of course not allowed. He’s in violation of the Torah, but it’s effective. He creates Temurah. The Temurah—the Hiddush (innovation). What we’re saying here is that it doesn’t have to be specific: a bull for a bull, a sheep for a sheep, but even if a person takes a sheep for a sheep for a sheep for a bull. Since everything here falls within the category of Behemah, which is what the Pasuk says, a person would be violating Temurah by substituting sheep for goats, or goats for sheep. Even within each family, the goats and sheep are both categorized as tzon. So a person would be violating Temurah as well if he did that.
Or by taking male chullin (unconsecrated, unholy) animals for female korbanot as Temurah, or female chullin animals for male korbanot. He could also make Temurah by substituting unblemished animals for blemished animals, or blemished animals for unblemished animals. All of these would be effective.
We’ll now give the source that blemished animals could make Temurah and be substituted for unblemished animals and also become Temurah. The Pasuk (verse) tells us about Temurah: “He should not exchange it, and not substitute it, good for bad or bad for good.” The good animal here is the unblemished animal because he could offer it as a korban. A bad animal is a blemished one because it cannot be offered as a korban. So when the Pasuk is telling us, “Good for bad or bad for good,” what it’s really telling us is: you’re not allowed to substitute an unblemished animal for a blemished one, or a blemished animal for an unblemished one. And if you do it, then Temurah kicks in, and a person now has created—the substitute is holy as well—and a person violated the Torah. So a blemished korban could make Temurah, and a blemished chullin animal can become Temurah. Even though this Pasuk tells us that a blemished korban can become a Temurah, the Mishnah is now going to explain that not all blemished korbanot can do so.
What’s the case of good for bad where Temurah would be effective? Which type of blemished korban could produce Temurah? Blemished korbanot whose consecration came before the blemishes, which is an unblemished animal when it was sanctified as a korban, and then afterwards became blemished. Since at one point in time it had the ability to be offered as a korban, and it was holy at that point in time, it acquires the full korban status. So even after it becomes blemished, it could still produce a Temurah. But if it was blemished before it became consecrated, it never took on full korban sanctity, and therefore it cannot make Temurah.
The Mishnah will now say that Temurah is a blemished korban. The Mishnah will now say that Temurah is a blemished korban. Let’s say that a person could make Temurah with an uneven or unparalleled number of korbanot to chullin animals. It doesn’t matter the number that are being substituted. A person can make Temurah by substituting one chullin animal for two korbanot, or two chullin animals for one animal korban. For example, let’s say he says, “Let this animal be a Temurah for these two,” or the opposite, “Let these two animals be a Temurah for this one animal.” In these cases, the chullin animals, either one or two, become holy. Or even one chullin animal for one hundred korbanot, or one hundred chullin animals for one animal korban.
We learn this out from the phrasing of the Pasuk. Behemah is understood to be a plural type of language, even though it could also be singular. We understand it in this context to be plural. Rabbi Shimon says: a person cannot make Temurah except by substituting one chullin animal for one consecrated korban, because the Pasuk says, “It and its substitute should be holy.” So we compare a korban substitute to itself. Just like the word hu implies a single animal, the Temurah also has to be a single animal.

